FIRST
Rating: 2.5
Reason: Considering the quality of your other maps this one is really bad. Don't have a square border for water. Don't use those house tiles at all.
Suggestions: Start again, there are too many mistakes to fix.
SECOND
Rating: 6.5
Reason: Looks great up til the mountains. Which need to be re-done, always have another layer of mountain over the cave entrance otherwise it looks like it has been chopped off. Thickness of the paths IMO is too large.
Suggestions: Fix the mountains and add more flowers.
THIRD
Rating: 8.5
Reason: Very good, the mountain entrance needs another layer though.
Suggestions: Use a different house.
Description(or whatever): I edited this to look better now
and sign is supposed to be unreachable
It's edited pallet town
Rating: 2.5
Reason: Lots of tile errors, pointless mini-mountain. Flowers arranged incorrectly. Too much empty space, pointless fenced off tree.
Suggestions: Start again, practice a bit more before you post again. Next time don't attach the picture, host it somewhere.
FIRST
Rating: 7.5
Reason: Looks great. Row of mini-trees look ugly (above the red roofed house).
Suggestions: It looks great but IMO it would look better with a different pallete and tiles but that's just my opinion and if I were you I wouldn't take it as the majority of people here like those kind of tiles and colours.
SECOND
Rating: 8.5
Reason: VERY nice. The only bad thing is the pointless ledges.
Suggestions: Same as the first.
Rating: 7
Reason: Looks great but you may have over used the ledges.
Suggestions: Reduce the amount of ledges (not by a lot just a couple). Disable the grid.