I can respect that instead of getting too personal with debates, which tends to lead to a lot of frustration at opposing parties, you go into lawyer-mode. As someone who was interested at one point or another to studying law, it does seem very smart of you - even on a Pokémon forum.
Why don't, in the future, instead of focusing all of your posts on the law-side of things and why something may or may not be against the constitution, thus unlawful or inconvenient, post your personal belief and view on the matter, and gently ease into the political side of the discussion? That way people get the sense that the topic actually matters to you as a person, and touches you in some way.
I think the issues between you two will iron out on themselves if you both take the time to learn the opposing side and talk to eachother. I mean, I came to you today because I was really getting pissed off with -- not what, but how -- you were posting what you were posting in the recent threads I've been in, and all of the threads that I've seen you post in. I think the only thing you need to really realize is that, a lot of the time, people are just posting their belief on a matter. They're not really saying this or that should happen. But I don't think you choose to get people angry, that's just what happens as a result of your matter-of-fact posting.