Map Rating/Review Thread

thanks, fixed

Disturbed said:

Okay, now posting my top 5 maps in my *cough*humble *cough* opinion. So enjoy and please rate! Also, you may have seen some of these before... too bad for you ^_^
:D

Map one: Some random requested map or something ><
Comments: None

Spoiler:

Map two: Unknown Forest (literally)
Comments: hmm, Connection only at bottom right, and all the borders work, thank you very much!

Spoiler:

Map 3: Some random requested Academy
Comments: Secret exits, all borders properly work, so don't call me off on them. (Most of them are connections anyways) Also, there is a reason the beach is kinda empty.

Spoiler:

Map IV: Dirtbeat mountain
Comments: Um, well... I'm aware of some emptyness, but can't be full everywhere!

Spoiler:

Map V: Rocket Town (requested)
Comments: none

Spoiler:

Um, don't skip me please?
Well, thats all for now.

Click to expand...

Mew_Ryn said:

hey peepz
ive got a map tht seems good 2 me but i wanna c wat the community thinks
(see attachment)
Comments: um will its a cave and im not the best with caves but i wanted some practice so i did some and did this map...
thnx

Click to expand...

Well, the map is quite square, empty, and lacking rocks.
2/10

Golden Shaymin said:

thanks, fixed

Click to expand...

Switch around some trees for different ones instead of using the same tree over and over for the boarder. Also, add more trees in the middle, and maybe less flowers on the bottom.
5/10

Finally internet works again ^o^ *YAY*
Here are my maps:

This is version1...

And this is version2...

And this is a map tried to make it look like a vacation park or something it's a bit weird XD

Satoshi Sugimori said:

Finally internet works again ^o^ *YAY*
Here are my maps:

This is version1...

And this is version2...

And this is a map tried to make it look like a vacation park or something it's a bit weird XD

Click to expand...

1-2 maps look a bit boring but great shape i give them a 7/10
and the last map great shape again but its just the house placement you need to work on i give this map a 8/10.
good job keep the mapping up

.:God:. said:

Map name: Rosewood Town
Codebase: Pokémon FireRed

Description: Complaints from Rosewood Town villagers have forced Falna Region government to plant more foliage.

Mapshot:


------------
Comment:
I'm open to any constructive criticsm. And regarding that description, I couldn't resist and let my imagination work. This is the result :P

Click to expand...

Can somebody please rate this... please? :)

You should put some trees behind the lab and maybe some kids running on the beach, so you'll fill the free space. Oh, yeah, and the houses on the beach should be placed differently. Everything else is fine.

7/10

rom name : fire red
map name : dont have one yet
comments: please rate this map !
because its proberly my best map with ruby and im not really used to the tiles yet
well here is the map.

map :

.:God:. said:

Map name: Rosewood Town
Codebase: Pokémon FireRed

Description: Complaints from Rosewood Town villagers have forced Falna Region government to plant more foliage.

Mapshot:


------------
Comment:
I'm open to any constructive criticsm. And regarding that description, I couldn't resist and let my imagination work. This is the result :P

Click to expand...

hmm...
very nice as stated by others a bit empty (mostly in the water)
nice shape
7.8/10
p.s. the water tiles you are using r rong if its meant for surfing just thought i mention tht

.:God:. said:

Can somebody please rate this... please? :)

Click to expand...

I already did two times, and so have other people.

Disturbed said:

Okay, now posting my top 5 maps in my *cough*humble *cough* opinion. So enjoy and please rate! Also, you may have seen some of these before... too bad for you ^_^
:D

Map one: Some random requested map or something ><
Comments: None

Spoiler:

Map two: Unknown Forest (literally)
Comments: hmm, Connection only at bottom right, and all the borders work, thank you very much!

Spoiler:

Map 3: Some random requested Academy
Comments: Secret exits, all borders properly work, so don't call me off on them. (Most of them are connections anyways) Also, there is a reason the beach is kinda empty.

Spoiler:

Map IV: Dirtbeat mountain
Comments: Um, well... I'm aware of some emptyness, but can't be full everywhere!

Spoiler:

Map V: Rocket Town (requested)
Comments: none

Spoiler:

Well, thats all for now.

Click to expand...

Guys seriously, Don't skip over me again! That is twice in a row!!!
I'm just gonna keep posting these until I get atleast one rating.

Disturbed said:

I already did two times, and so have other people.



Guys seriously, Don't skip over me again! That is twice in a row!!!
I'm just gonna keep posting these until I get atleast one rating.

Click to expand...

Map 1 Comments: 8.3/10 It's a great map all the tiles are perfect.
Map 1 Suggestions: The Thicker patches of grass placed randomly around the lower are are unnecessary. Also the little 3 bush tile behind the small house could be removed.And a sign in front of the lab thingwouldn't hurtMap 2 Comments: 8.5/10 I'm a little confuzzled about the conections. I see all these open areas, but do they really all lead out of the forest?
Map 2 Suggestions:Hmm... Only thing would be the open areas and pick a different type of trees. I don't remember the last time a saw a willow forest.
Map 3 Comments:10/10.Wonderful. It's perfecly laid out with the size and shape. The peath connects perfecly and the way routes could just pop onto there is perfect.
Map 3 Suggestions:Maybe make it A bit less crammed. If you were to add people too it, they would almost block the path at some points.
Map 4 Comments: 7/10. The cliffs that you can jump off of messes with my eyes. The ground I can't tell is it going up? staying the same? It's a good map, but theres room for improvment.
Map 4 Suggestions:Remove some of the cliffs you can jump off of.also I wouldn't like playing in this map. make it smaller or add little caves and secret hard-to-find spots that may have items..
Map 5 Comments:7/10. The darkness looks bad with the bright tiles like the lab and the flowers. The house placement is a bit crummy too. YOUR worst map. Not THE worst map, but yours.
Map 5 Suggestions: Move the hoses around. Change the tileset so either it's all dark, or all bright. If it's supposed to be night time, make the buildings dark and make the windows look lit up.

-cracks knuckles- Righty-ho! Time to get to work on my first ratings in a few months.
Disturbed, I'll only rate the Academy cos I'm lackin time:

8.4/10
Is that the right way to use waterfalls? They look kinda weird.
The shape of the mountains, river, trees are all awesome and the way you placed Pokecenters, Pokemarts, labs and lecture rooms was great!
Suggestions? Well, try to use the same form of waterfall cos at the top, there are two waterfalls alongside each other. They're the same height but they look different. To each other AND to other waterfalls.

Oh, and Disturbed, don't fret that people are skipping you.

Map name: Route 66
Codebase: Pokémon FireRed

Description: The first route on your Journey through FALNA. It Contains a few patches of grass for catching various pokemon, and two ledges that make it easy to go from Rosewood town to Highview town.


Mapshot:


------------
Comment:
I'm open to any constructive criticsm. And regarding that description, I couldn't resist and let my imagination work. This is the result :P

.:God:. said:

Map name: Route 66
Codebase: Pokémon FireRed

Description: The first route on your Journey through FALNA. It Contains a few patches of grass for catching various pokemon, and two ledges that make it easy to go from Rosewood town to Highview town.


Mapshot:


------------
Comment:
I'm open to any constructive criticsm. And regarding that description, I couldn't resist and let my imagination work. This is the result :P

Click to expand...

A really great map,
The only things I notice is that it looks a little unnatural at some
spots, like; The "lake" have a little too "perfect" size.
And those 3 small trees doesn't make sense.
Othervise it's a really great map
(Kinda reminds me of Route 102 though xP)

I give it a 8/10

----------------------------------------

And now here's a map from me;
Map Name: Fierebourgh City
Comments: The 2nd town in the game, you get your Pokedex
in the Research lab in the upper middle of town.
Huge credit to Kyledove/Kymotonian for tiles.

Mapshot: (Attachment)


//44tim44

44tim44 said:

A really great map,
The only things I notice is that it looks a little unnatural at some
spots, like; The "lake" have a little too "perfect" size.
And those 3 small trees doesn't make sense.
Othervise it's a really great map
(Kinda reminds me of Route 102 though xP)

I give it a 8/10

----------------------------------------

And now here's a map from me;
Map Name: Fierebourgh City
Comments: The 2nd town in the game, you get your Pokedex
in the Research lab in the upper middle of town.

Mapshot: (Attachment)


//44tim44

Click to expand...

Your map doesn't show.

.:God:. said:

Map name: Route 66
Codebase: Pokémon FireRed

Description: The first route on your Journey through FALNA. It Contains a few patches of grass for catching various pokemon, and two ledges that make it easy to go from Rosewood town to Highview town.


Mapshot:


------------
Comment:
I'm open to any constructive criticsm. And regarding that description, I couldn't resist and let my imagination work. This is the result :P

Click to expand...

Scratch my last comments, this is your best map. I would say you are finally becoming better.

6/10
It could be better, by patching the grass, adding depth to water, but it is pretty damn good.

Disturbed said:

Your map doesn't show.

Click to expand...

That's strange... It does for me...
Maybe you have to refresh the page or someth'n...

//44tim44

44tim44 said:

That's strange... It does for me...
Maybe you have to refresh the page or someth'n...

//44tim44

Click to expand...

i can see it too
but i had to click on it twice so it opened in a new window

Neti said:

i can see it too
but i had to click on it twice so it opened in a new window

Click to expand...

Yeah, xD
So... What do you think of it, Neti?
2 people have quoted me but no one
have posted a rating... xP


//44tim44

44tim44 said:

Yeah, xD
So... What do you think of it, Neti?
2 people have quoted me but no one
have posted a rating... xP


//44tim44

Click to expand...

i actually just had a quick look at it cause im looking tv now and just came to my pc cause i got an email that someone replied to this thread. so i checked the reply and read that someone couldnt open yourrmap, so i tried it.
btw im wondering where you got that tiles^^
but now i want to continue watching tv cause its already pretty late here in germany

Neti said:

i actually just had a quick look at it cause im looking tv now and just came to my pc cause i got an email that someone replied to this thread. so i checked the reply and read that someone couldnt open yourrmap, so i tried it.
btw im wondering where you got that tiles^^
but now i want to continue watching tv cause its already pretty late here in germany

Click to expand...

OK, I just hope someone will
comment it...
The maps on the "previous page"
are always ignored. ._.
Anyway, yeah it's getting late in sweden too.
Ehrr.... Happy mapping? xD


//44tim44

44tim44 said:

A really great map,
The only things I notice is that it looks a little unnatural at some
spots, like; The "lake" have a little too "perfect" size.
And those 3 small trees doesn't make sense.
Othervise it's a really great map
(Kinda reminds me of Route 102 though xP)

I give it a 8/10

----------------------------------------

And now here's a map from me;
Map Name: Fierebourgh City
Comments: The 2nd town in the game, you get your Pokedex
in the Research lab in the upper middle of town.
Huge credit to Kyledove/Kymotonian for tiles.

Mapshot: (Attachment)


//44tim44

Click to expand...

omg omg this map is awsome i love the tiles the shape is good good house placement.
well i give this awsome map a 10/10.
please tell me how to insert them tiles