Bloodborne and why the hell are you even playing anything else.
Well, Persona 5's there, too. There really isn't much to say about these games because their reputations precede them by a pretty fair margin. Other than those two I'd really have to know what you're into, because P5 and BB are the types of games you don't have to be into Turn-based RPGs or Action RPGs (respectively) to like, so I could recommend them to just about anyone. But if I were to throw something like Disgaea 5 your way then...well, I couldn't good and well say whether you'd be interested in its grind-based gameplay and the overwhelming number of systems.
With that said, what're you into, fam? The library's pretty diverse in terms of what's on offer, so knowing what you like'd be a pretty healthy starting point.
Oh, and also, sorry about your loss, there, really sucks what happened to your old PS4. Really do hope we can at least make this one feel like one hell of a purchase by throwing games at your face that you hopefully fall in love with.