Goddamn only less than 35 minutes left
Ok well I was hoping for Bardothren to answer my question but since there's no time for that I'm just gonna have to go ahead with this:
I think it could be Bardothren, and there's a few reasons as to why. The first being what I asked him about. He made the claim that the spears themselves will not provide any clues. He said this right after the body was discovered, before the investigation period started. How could he have gotten any info at all at that point? All Hope students were not able to do any actions during night zero, meaning he shouldn't have been able to learn anything before the rest of us.....if he was a Hope student. He very well could've gotten that info because he is a Despair student. Then there's also the fact that he decided to investigate the Trophy Room along with WizMan, despite that it was clearly stated in the investigation post that having multiple people investigate the same area may cause some people to not get clues. He said that he didn't see that WizMan had already went off to the Trophy Room, but there was a 3 hour gap between their posts and it's not like their was 5 pages of shit for him to read that would've caused him to skip over some posts. Furthermore, he erased the one piece of evidence found in the Trophy Room (which prevented WizMan from seeing it): the rouge on the glass door. Why the hell would you erase evidence? Maybe because he did it.
I don't know if that's proves for sure that Bardothren killed machomuu (there could be something I missed or a hole in my reasoning), and I don't exactly expect that to convince anyone else, and maybe I'm just biased because I though of it, but it sounds far more plausible to me than Melody or Bidoof at this point.
I admittedly am suspicious of Deceptio because his username is the only one that starts with D, not to mention that he's been hella adamant about what he thinks about this case, is very willing to die for some reason, and I feel he's not telling us something, but that's honestly not enough for me to (confidently) place a kill vote for him.
So....[KILL] Bardothren