Leftovers Squad 2 [Game Over]

Desi being aware he's a miller with an open setup feels iffy. However it's not enough to lynch him today.

Charlie Brown said:

Ok something is up with Neon Sword bc he's never made a post of longer than ten words before in all the mafia games he's dedicated himself to. Not necessarily something bad but just something curious all the same.

Spreading the votes onto people who haven't rocked up yet, +1 at town vibes on Aldo and +1 to the sentiment that GP is being GP so nothing to read there

[Devour] Desinishon

Click to expand...

If possible I'd recommend you switch your vote to someone who hasn't claimed.

[Devour] Nick Wilde

Don't really have any suspicions here, but he's the only one who hasn't talked so far, and a completely random lynch almost always helps mafia and doesn't help town with reads.

I'm a little suspicious of a Miller claim naturally but the fact that desi claimed asaap on day 1 rather than wait and get lynched by a cop check is a good sign. The fact that everyone knows all the roles in the game means that it will be a lot harder for to make a fake claim makes it seem extra towny.

xD gimmepie

I'm sure Desi did the right move as Town, but my only worry is if perhaps there's a second miller. I hope each named role is unique, for it simplifies wolf hunting.

I believe leaving the zero poster aside would be better, and attacking them should only be done if we have no leads.

I'm also inclined to town read gimmepie for his light hearted approach on Desi, by joking. A Town mind doesn't feel pressured to appear innocent, allowing them to joke a few times.

And a question. What is wrong with Desi's claim?

Aldo! said:

xD gimmepie

I'm sure Desi did the right move as Town, but my only worry is if perhaps there's a second miller. I hope each named role is unique, for it simplifies wolf hunting.

I believe leaving the zero poster aside would be better, and attacking them should only be done if we have no leads.

I'm also inclined to town read gimmepie for his light hearted approach on Desi, by joking. A Town mind doesn't feel pressured to appear innocent, allowing them to joke a few times.

And a question. What is wrong with Desi's claim?

Click to expand...

But we have no leads, which is why I am voting for Nick. I don't want to leave the lynch completely random, since town can't get any information that way.

As for Desi's claim, typically in an open setup the miller is not self-aware, but would get a role PM saying they are a vanilla town, but since the roles are known they would know they have the possibility of being a miller. However, now that I think about it, since the game did not fill up completely, some roles were cut from this game. So I would be really surprised if there are any vanilla towns in this game. If Desi is lying, he risks a CC, so I am willing to believe his claim.

I wanted some of you guys to be sus about me so mafia don't target me at night - _ -

still gp is looking ok to me too, saws is null.

Agreeing with Neon about the miller claim, a bit suss but the early claim makes it look a lot better imo. It's a weird play so I'm not sure exactly how I feel about it yet but those are some initial thoughts from it. Desi's follow up reminds me of him as town so I'm going to ride with the claim for now.

Going to go for lynching the inactive because it's just going to be a handicap for the rest of the game and most of the people that have spoken other than saws look pretty good.
[Lynch] Nick Wilde

Yasssss gj doc!!!

And GP has a point here Aldo, right now we've nothing to go on due to the little participation we have, so I guess we just throw ideas around and chit-chat, see if any chinks in the armour become apparent.

Somehow I have the feeling you haven't read Page 2 yet.

Time is up!

Notification Spam

Times up will post phase post when I get home.

Notification Spam

tbh salty @ Nick Wilde not saying that he was Yams, and giving maf another free kill :/ at least if he revealed when the votes were stacked against him, we could've had a shot at hitting a maf (before maf would kill Nick)

Guessing Aldo is Apple Brown Betty? Which is nice since it means we probably don't have a Fool in this set-up as well. Though since ABB isn't counted as town for the mafia win con, it'll be 4 town : 2 maf by the end of this next night phase and put as in MYLO unless ABB for some reason decides to side with town

green bean casserole tastes good D:

Charlie Brown said:

tbh salty @ Nick Wilde not saying that he was Yams, and giving maf another free kill :/ at least if he revealed when the votes were stacked against him, we could've had a shot at hitting a maf (before maf would kill Nick)

Guessing Aldo is Apple Brown Betty? Which is nice since it means we probably don't have a Fool in this set-up as well. Though since ABB isn't counted as town for the mafia win con, it'll be 4 town : 2 maf by the end of this next night phase and put as in MYLO unless ABB for some reason decides to side with town

Click to expand...

Why do you think Aldo is ABB?

I think you are right about it being MYLO next day unless shenanigans happen. We may want to do a mass claim tomorrow if we are in MYLO. Any FOS?

Mine are Saws and Naku. I see Aldo! as the most towny, followed by GP, though I'm always paranoid of him. Your post here gives me good vibes too. And Desi is uncc'd Brussel Sprouts.

I feel like Doof is saying just enough to get by, you know?
He's made like three posts in the game, which is odd for him, and of those only one is particularly pro-town... and it amounts to "I agree"

Charlie Brown said:

tbh salty @ Nick Wilde not saying that he was Yams, and giving maf another free kill :/ at least if he revealed when the votes were stacked against him, we could've had a shot at hitting a maf (before maf would kill Nick)

Guessing Aldo is Apple Brown Betty? Which is nice since it means we probably don't have a Fool in this set-up as well. Though since ABB isn't counted as town for the mafia win con, it'll be 4 town : 2 maf by the end of this next night phase and put as in MYLO unless ABB for some reason decides to side with town

Click to expand...

As Aldo pointed out yesterday, I don't think Nick Wilde had even read page two and thus noticed the votes against him before he'd posted lmao

I was thinking the exact same thing about Aldo, though

jdthebud said:

Why do you think Aldo is ABB?

Click to expand...

Aldo acted as a Loudmouth last night and there's no Loudmouth in the game. ABB can apply random effects to players it visits, including itself

Which means Aldo could also be the target of ABB, so don't go all in on that just yet

jdthebud said:

Mine are Saws and Naku. I see Aldo! as the most towny, followed by GP, though I'm always paranoid of him. Your post here gives me good vibes too. And Desi is uncc'd Brussel Sprouts.

Click to expand...

That's an interesting statement. Care to elaborate on why?

Nakuzami said:

As Aldo pointed out yesterday, I don't think Nick Wilde had even read page two and thus noticed the votes against him before he'd posted lmao

I was thinking the exact same thing about Aldo, though

Aldo acted as a Loudmouth last night and there's no Loudmouth in the game. ABB can apply random effects to players it visits, including itself

Which means Aldo could also be the target of ABB, so don't go all in on that just yet

That's an interesting statement. Care to elaborate on why?

Click to expand...

You haven't given me a reason to townread you, unlike the others I listed. Mostly process of elimination. If I had a vote it would probably go to Saws.

gimmepie said:

I feel like Doof is saying just enough to get by, you know?
He's made like three posts in the game, which is odd for him, and of those only one is particularly pro-town... and it amounts to "I agree"

Click to expand...

He's dead bro.

jdthebud said:

You haven't given me a reason to townread you, unlike the others I listed. Mostly process of elimination. If I had a vote it would probably go to Saws.

Click to expand...

Fair enough.

And, looking back, I only just noticed that I made two posts during the last day. My attention's been quite split; I thought I'd done more

jdthebud said:

He's dead bro.

Click to expand...

lmao

I say that this may confirm Aldo! as town which is a good thing. At the moment no one really sticks out to me, although I say that Saws is slightly pinging my radar with one or two other neutrals.