Well, this is a strange interaction.
To be honest I think both arguments are really weak. They've both accused each other of being scum, so I wouldn't be surprised if Melody came back with a vote on GP. Imo this is town v town or town v witness and they're both clutching at straws looking for reasons to lynch someone on D1, or one of them is a Witness Lyncher role (if it's either of them, it's probably GP) and the other is their target (again, idk if Lyncher really works in an AitP setup, but it's a possibility?) I don't think either of them are prosecutors yet.
I'm going to put down a [Vote] Abby (and yes I know I'm stacking)
because I think his reasoning for trying to start a Melody wagon is flawed and not very well thought out, like scum keen to start up a mislynch.
> The whole "softing" thing is probably just a poor use of words. Substitute "softing me" for "suggesting that I'm scum" and she's conveying the same idea, just in a clearer way.
> I think scum bussing is the least likely scenario here, since a) why would two scum bus each other on D1 when there was literally no suspicion on either of them beforehand? and b) how would bussing another scum at this point benefit the prosecutors when we have no idea what people's alignments are after they've died?