Any games you disliked at first, but like now (or vice versa)?

  • 42,782
    Posts
    18
    Years
    I'm sure a lot of us weren't so keen on certain games in the series at first, but eventually grew to like them. And on the opposite end, some fans could have enjoyed a specific game but when they went to replay it later, realized they didn't enjoy it as much anymore.

    What games were that for you?
     
    I LOVED Diamond as a kid, but going back and playing it now... don't get me wrong, I still like the game and I have fond memories of it, but it's really slow and clunky to play now that I am a conscious adult. For the longest time I guess I was blinded by nostalgia.

    I guess in the opposite direction, I didn't like White 2 as much as I did Diamond because I was biased to Diamond since it was my first game. Now White 2 is the only of my games that I've maxed out the playing time, and I still play it today. I really need to replay it because it's been over 10 years since I last played through the main story.
     
    I loved Gen1-4 but after learning about Imposter Ditto from Gen 5 onwards.. I can't play older gens as I love Imposter Ditto so much
     
    I'm sure a lot of us weren't so keen on certain games in the series at first, but eventually grew to like them. And on the opposite end, some fans could have enjoyed a specific game but when they went to replay it later, realized they didn't enjoy it as much anymore.

    What games were that for you?
    Black and white. I couldn't quite grasp or understand the concepts of the story as a small child. But every time I replay those games I like the story more and more. And I love how fast the game moves as well. Very respectful of your time. Added some very convenient features as well. Things I just couldn't appreciate as an 8 year old that I now love about the games
     
    Diamond and Pearl were games I loved as a kid but going back to was really hard. They are definitely the slowest of the games to play and a bit of a slog to get through. I think the reason I like Platinum a whole lot more is because that fixed several things from D/P.

    Another game I liked when I was younger but dislike as I got older has to be gen 2. It is shocking how gen 2 introduces so many new pokemon but only allows the player so little. Like why are there Johto mons in Kanto? Why are the evolutionary stones in Gold and Silver locked to post game and only obtainable once?? Especially when the game offers you a Bellsprout very early on? Now that's just an evil tease. Also Lance is really difficult because your only options are the Red Gyarados with poor special attack, while Lapras and Slowbro are really slow. Piloswine or Jynx are also ok but they're frail while Lance's 3 Dragonites are faster and tough.

    As for games I liked the older I got it has to be Ruby and Sapphire. I thought these were downgrades from Emerald, but I've come to see they match Emerald's quality rather well. They don't have the Battle Frontier nor both Groudon or Kyogre, but they're still fun to experience.

    One last game I liked more the older I got has to be gen 1. Used to view its remakes as far superior but not anymore. Gen 1 is a different experience and I like it as much as I love its gen 3 remakes. It feels like an old school dungeon crawler that doesn't overstay its welcome and is decently challenging. The bugs also contribute heavily to its replayability like the trainer fly glitch allowing you to get pokemon earlier or ones you cannot obtain through normal means (like Mew).
     
    Obligatory "I enjoyed R/B, G/S/C, and R/S when they first came out, but they've aged horribly, lack modern QOL features, and I was young and stupid back then, and I can't stand to return to them now" answer. FR/LG are the oldest games that I can return to and still enjoy playing, if you're curious,

    Other than that, I don't think I've had any major swings from one end of the love-hate spectrum to another. I think I put a surprising number of hours into Emerald on account of the Battle Frontier, but over time enen the Frontier and its bangin' soundtrack couldn't keep me from losing interest in the games (and in fact, the Frontier might have contributed to that coughcoughstupidRNGcoughcough.) I haven't even had the slightest desire to return to Emerald. Though to be fair, I felt they were a step down from FR/LG and even from R/S, so I wasn't exactly a big fan of them in the first place.

    HG/SS continued to get worse for me the farther I got into them, but I really didn't have too high of an expectation for them pre-release anyway, so I'm not sure if they count. Same thing with Sw/Sh.

    And I highly doubt I'd enjoy any of the trash-tier shovelware titles I skipped (ORAS, 7th gen, Let's Go) if I was forced to play them today, since the characters, storylines, and overall design of them still looks like crap.
     
    I'm sure a lot of us weren't so keen on certain games in the series at first, but eventually grew to like them. And on the opposite end, some fans could have enjoyed a specific game but when they went to replay it later, realized they didn't enjoy it as much anymore.

    What games were that for you?
    I have done this multiple times with HGSS. I had a lot of fun as a kid, especially when I did a second run where I used the tiniest bit of strategy, but also as I grew up I realized it kind of sucked to play through with how slow leveling is.
    As a romhacker my understanding of it has increased tremendously over the last few years and it feels like every other month I swap between "this game is a work of art" and "this game has so many flaws how did nobody think to do anything about it".
    The price of reliving memories haha
     
    Platinum. I like it more than Heart Gold/Soul Silver.

    It has a good difficulty balance and I like most Gen 4 pokemon, so I can put up with the slower speed.
     
    Black and White I didn't like at all when they came out. The fact that you could only get Pokemon from Unova was (and still is honestly) a baffling decision that soured me on the whole thing back when it was announced even before the game proper came out, and I saw the story as more intrusive than interesting once I played it. Nowadays there was outrage when Sword and Shield removed the National Dex, and a lot of people think that the games are way too hand holdy and have way too many cutscenes, and I think that stuff was already present in some way all the way back in Gen V. Most importantly, the game came out at a point in my life where I wasn't really able to appreciate all the good things it did, and in general I was feeling pretty burned out on the franchise back then.

    After a few years I did come back to the game, and I found it a delight. It aged really well in my eyes. A lot of it is thanks to its sequel, Black 2 and White 2, which unlike the first games I ended up loving almost instantly. Back when I thought I may be done with the franchise, those were the games that made me realize I still had a lot of love for it. Those games allowed me to engage with the Unova Pokemon in an environment where I felt I wasn't forced to use them, since they not only gave you access to every generation, they had the biggest variety of Pokemon seen yet in a main line game thus far back then. And because I was able to engage with the Gen V mons on my terms I realized I ended up loving a lot of them, and notice how good they fit in with the rest of the franchise's Pokemon, so I ended up really liking them.

    The story also felt a lot less overbearing back then, in comparison to how Black and White had felt to me. Just one rival that showed up occasionally, most gym leaders had already been introduced back in Black and White so there was no need to go through introductions for each of them with a small plot line in the story, etc. So not only did I that allow me to enjoy the game much more on my own terms, it also allowed me to get interested and see the fascinating parts of the original game's story by paying attention to how the characters and region had evolved since then.

    So when I did come back to Black and White years later, hoping to appreciate them more this time, I did so on much better terms, and I found a lot of stuff to like. The fact that I could only use Unova Pokemon didn't bother me anymore because I had grown to love them, and the characters and storylines became stuff that I found really interesting to see and analyze with the hindsight of the developments to come in the sequel, which allowed me to get invested into every character and plot point. I then played the Blaze Black and Volt White versions by Drayano, and that ended up making me like the games even more, now seeing them full of Pokemon from all regions. So overall, I really grew to love Black and White.

    Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon had something similar happening. I first played them when they came out, right after Sun and Moon, because I thought that since they were making dual versions again, which had only previously happened with Black 2 and White 2, that the scope of these games would be similar, and since I had loved Black 2 and White 2 so much, I got Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon really quickly after Sun and Moon. Instead, I ended up basically playing through Sun and Moon again with slight differences, which made me feel really burnt out, and like Black and White, it caught me at a time in my life where I wasn't really able to focus on the good stuff so much as I was just looking to get through it.

    Well I replayed Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon last year, and with the foresight of knowing the pacing of the game and the placement of the cutscenes and plot points, etc. I was able to focus on finding all the stuff about the game I liked. Things like the SOS Battles, Z-Moves, The Battle Royal, which I hadn't even tried the first time I played the game, and the general convenience of the region. When I first played Alola I really didn't like the layout, it felt way too simplistic, and the routes all felt like either hallways or open circles. Replaying it with that knowledge and trying to look for the good side I actually ended up liking all the streamlining, if nothing else because it made it feel like a unique experience on its own, and it allowed other parts of the region design, like the setpieces and the NPCs, to shine.

    At the end of the day I think a lot of it is the mentality I come to these games with, and the point in my life I'm at. I hope I can find a bunch of stuff to love about Sword and Shield and Scarlet and Violet, as well.
     
    No, not really, they've been stable for me. I changed my mind on BW, because I now think they're good games, but there are some things, mostly personal, that still make the experience less enjoyable than other games, including many pokemon designs i don't like, a graphics and region I don't exactly go crazy for.
     
    When I first played Sun and Moon around release I got really frustrated by the railroading in the first few hours and I think it was just a bit different than I was expecting, so I only finished the first 1 or 2 islands. But last year I went back to it properly and enjoyed it a lot more, I liked Alola and the story, a lot of the designs, etc. Excited to play Ultra Sun and Moon soon.
     
    Back
    Top