Back to the Basics [Game Over]

[Ullion]

[kill] jdthebud

Before the day ended, JD quoted my post asking me to take my vote off GB - then when the day ended he deleted his post soooooooooooooo that strikes me as super suss.

 

[Ullion]

[kill] Mana

Tbh I was contemplating the cult being dead since we haven't had any more 3rd party deaths and both GB AND Bard came up as mafia. But if the 'flavour text' is hinting at a mylo situation then yes we do need to kill 3rd party. But I feel like if the cult was still alive, then wouldn't the majority of the town be cult by now? :/

 

[Mana1]

@Ullion: That would mean that jdthebud is mafia and we have to kill the cult, since there's only one mafia left. Why would the phase post say this then?

This is saying we're at a mylo situation, and it sure as hell isn't because of the mafia.

There's only one reason Mana would ignore this line of thought and suggest that the cult is dead, [KILL]Mana

GG WP

nudge

You're the one chasing ghosts, we haven't killed a 3rd party player since N5. That means they could have recruited N6, N7 and N8. That would put them at 4 and they'd have obviously won by this point. Unless the player is so inactive they have only in a single night action our of 3 (AND we'd killed all their recruits prior to that), we'd have lost already.

I believe that Lycan is warning that a mislynch now could lead to us losing by the end of the night.

You've been jumping for the cult for a long time. Nagi cleared you from being cult, but I wonder if you're actually mafia, and just trying to pass the blame to a non-existent enemy.

 

[Ullion]

You're the one chasing ghosts, we haven't killed a 3rd party player since N5. That means they could have recruited N6, N7 and N8. That would put them at 4 and they'd have obviously won by this point. Unless the player is so inactive they have only in a single night action our of 3 (AND we'd killed all their recruits prior to that), we'd have lost already.

I believe that Lycan is warning that a mislynch now could lead to us losing by the end of the night.

You've been jumping for the cult for a long time. Nagi cleared you from being cult, but I wonder if you're actually mafia, and just trying to pass the blame to a non-existent enemy.

Is this line directed at me, or Johnny?

 

[Mana1]

Is this line directed at me, or Johnny?

Johnny, I edited in the quote to you as you ninja'd me and used the same line of logic as Johnny.

 

[Ullion]

See, I'm still torn on whether or not there is a cult still existing or not. The flavour text kind of supports it - but if the cult is alive then I don't see how more people haven't died and/or turned up as 3rd party OR the game would be over, I think?

On the other hand, if the the cult is already dead then we only have 1 mafia left (coughJDTHEBUDcough) and that would be game over for them. But the flavour text does still hint that a mislynch could end the game. I don't see how it would end when it's 1 mafia left out of 6 players and we mislynched?

5 innos 1 mafia, mislynch: 4 innos 1 mafia
Nightkill plus witch kill: 2 innos 1 mafia
Daytime: would still be alive.

This is the worst-case scenario, imagining that the witch is alive and gets a kill, we would still have 2 townies left and 1 mafia, meaning the day can still extend to the next day.

The last thing I'd like to say is: maybe we should ignore the "flavour text" and consider it as just one of those "purple glow" lines, where we think it's a hint but it actually isn't.

That being said, after some consideration, I'll put my vote back to [kill] JDthebud for now. I'm still horribly undecided as to figuring out what the situation with the 3rd party is. :/

 

[jdthebud]

Yeah that was a stupid action on my part Ullion. Not that it would have mattered anyway, since Mana ended up voting for GB. The main reason I deleted it was because I didn't want the mafia to jump on Johnny's vote and kill me instead. Sorry for the confusion.

So, either Klippy or Golgari was the roleblocker or the roleblocker didn't submit an action, otherwise I can't see why Bact would have been able to kill. The witch is now useless I think so it doesn't really matter if they are dead or not, since there aren't any more visiting roles aside from Bact, and she's a vig anyway.

As for the vote today, if we are in MYLO, there is an option to no lynch and see if Bact can take down another mafia tonight, but that's only viable if we have no idea who to lynch.

In any case, here are the remaining role claims IIRC:

Ullion - vanilla (Clear IMO)
jdthebud - Judge
Elektra Heart - Vig (clear)
Collector Elwood - BP?
JohnnyMustang - Ghoul
Mana - Vanilla

The people who ended up voting for GB last day were Ullion, me, and Mana, with Mana jumping on the BW at the end, when it was pretty much decided. I would say that Ullion is pretty much clear at this point, and if you really think I'm mafia when I voted for GB when the vote was still in doubt, then gg. Mana is not completely clear in my mind since she waited to vote until the end, and has claimed a role that isn't verifiable. Kiyo and Johnny have at least provided some proof for their roleclaim.

If the cult really is still around, then they should have won already I think, so I can see them being dead already, but it's possible they have just been vegging on recruiting, which can happen.

If you want more (kind of) proof that I am innocent, go back to the day we lynched Gunner. The vote was tied between Gunner and Alexkaz61. Gunner died because of my extra vote. I know it's not hard proof but it's the only thing I can state for proof of my role.

The votes that day:
Gunner: Elektra Heart, jdthebud, alexkaz61, Mana, Klippy, Collector Elwood

Alexkaz61: honey, Ullion, KetsuekiR, CatmanDaTrainer, JohnnyMustang, Bardothren

My main FOS in on Mana right now, so that's where my vote's going. The cult situation could still be an issue though, so I will be sure to check back later.

[Kill] Mana

 

[Mana1]

[lynch] JohnnyMustang

After thinking it over some more, I think Johnny is most likely to be mafia. His persistence throughout the game has been up and down and he's targeted so many people in a haphazard manner, with the only mafia he vaguely accused being Bard (who he then decided to start backing).

With his fear-mongering about the cult still going on, even when the chances are slim to none, I think he's the most obvious cause to lynch. Bac and Kiyo are clear, in my books, unless witch decided to kill a mafia member last night. Ullion seems to be a helpful villager and I'm alright with JD's roleclaim despite the pretty flimsy evidence. It might even be proven tonight if the vote remains split.

 

[Ullion]

[kill] no one

I am A-OK with JD's post/claim. Not 100% convinced, of course. :d I keep switching my votes around, I know, I'm sorry. But I am seriously so unsure of who is maf now. JD's idea on no lynching and letting Bac decide between different options could be a good idea - however if the mafia targets him he'll die without killing (I believe thats how vig works in em?).

Making a personal note here, last day's votes:
Johnny: Jdthebud
Ullion: Grey Bidoof
Bard: Ullion
Jdthebud: Grey Bidoof
Mana: Grey Bidoof

If Johnny was mafia, I think him and Bard would have co-ordinated more together to vote a single target off (myself, probably) in an attempt to end the game. By the time Mana voted (right before day's end) he voted off Grey Bidoof because even if he tried to vote me off, the votes would have been tied and jd's judge powers would have overruled it anyways. Meaning Mana's vote meant nothing by the time he voted, so he went for GB to make himself look inno.

Going by that, I do think Mana may be the most likely mafia out of the rest of us. What is everyone else's thoughts?

 

[Ullion]

[kill] no one

I am A-OK with JD's post/claim. Not 100% convinced, of course. :d I keep switching my votes around, I know, I'm sorry. But I am seriously so unsure of who is maf now. JD's idea on no lynching and letting Bac decide between different options could be a good idea - however if the mafia targets him he'll die without killing (I believe thats how vig works in em?).

Making a personal note here, last day's votes:
Johnny: Jdthebud
Ullion: Grey Bidoof
Bard: Ullion
Jdthebud: Grey Bidoof
Mana: Grey Bidoof

If Johnny was mafia, I think him and Bard would have co-ordinated more together to vote a single target off (myself, probably) in an attempt to end the game. By the time Mana voted (right before day's end) he voted off Grey Bidoof because even if he tried to vote me off, the votes would have been tied and jd's judge powers would have overruled it anyways. Meaning Mana's vote meant nothing by the time he voted, so he went for GB to make himself look inno.

Going by that, I do think Mana may be the most likely mafia out of the rest of us. What is everyone else's thoughts?

 

[Ullion]

[kill] Mana

Mmmm I'll leave my vote here. I feel like there isn't much left to say, although I am wondering where Kiyo is...

 

[Mana1]

By the time Mana voted (right before day's end) he voted off Grey Bidoof because even if he tried to vote me off, the votes would have been tied and jd's judge powers would have overruled it anyways. Meaning Mana's vote meant nothing by the time he voted, so he went for GB to make himself look inno.

And two people didn't vote at all, so their votes didn't count. Where is the logic here?

Going by that, I do think Mana may be the most likely mafia out of the rest of us. What is everyone else's thoughts?

I've stated my thoughts about the cult, and about Johnny, and once again he ignores them - somehow you think he's making sense though? You've been jumping on my lynch repeatedly for the last two days.

I think you're right, Ullion. I've been confirmed by Nagi, the snoop right after proving my innocence hundreds of times with many different arguments and Mana (during very late game) chooses to ignore all this just with a post in which he's trying to win some sympathy by townreading everyone else. I can tell now that he's not a part of the cult because nobody's backing him up.

This makes no sense.

You say you're confirmed by Nagi - you're confirmed non-cult leader and nothing else. As I've said above the cult is dead, so you're not 'confirmed' anything really.

Then you said I'm "not cult", still suggesting the cult exists and then you vote for me despite your whole point being "the cult will win MYLO MYLO".

 

[Mana1]

How do you explain my early knowledge of non-fabricator role in this setup, how do you explain my also early role claim, how do you explain no counter claim? Where is exactly the logic when you say I am mafia? How did you figure this out? Because if you're gonna OMGUS like that you better have a damn good explanation, something that you're currently lacking.

There are a number of roles that are in non-fab games - or, it could be a bluff. If you were a member of the mafia you'd know whether there was a fab or not afterall. Your early roleclaim wasn't that early, and having no counter claim doesn't necessarily prove you innocent when we have x-many dead inno roles.

How do you explain me pointing fingers at Klippy right after Charlie Brown suss him out?

See? There's a lot that you're not explaining, or rather choosing to ignore. The only reason one would do such a thing is because they're scum :)

EDIT: How do you explain Nimsy dying instead of me? There's so much more you should be explaining, instead of throwing wild and baseless accussations you should be defending yourself. Why shouldn't we lynch you?

Klippy is prime candidate for the sniper, as he's the only person in the entire game to shoot a gun, so maybe you pointing fingers was a mistake that got your own team mate killed. Following someone else's suspicion is hardly an alibi though, lmao.

Finally, how do we know Nimsy actually died because of you? We know Bac tried to kill you and that nimsy died on that same night, but that sounds like a good claim to make after a lucky hook+witch manoever.

Why shouldn't you lynch me? Because I'm not mafia (or cult! ;)) and have been working to scum hunt with the actual facts rather than relying on other people and baseless allegations. Above I've queried all your evidence of your roleclaim, yet you'll still be adamant that it confirms you above everyone else.

 

[Mana1]

And yet, the fact you live in the face of your supposed excellent playing flies in the wind of everything you're saying. The mafia haven't seemed to kill you, and the cult never recruited you. What are the chances a loud mouth, useful innocent managed to be ignored?

 

[jdthebud]

Mana, I would think that since the mafia know that Johnny is vested, they are leaving Johnny alone since they can't afford a wasted kill in this phase of the game.

 

[Lycanthropy]

Just a couple of hours left.

 

[Lycanthropy]

Nightfall! Time's up.

 

[Lycanthropy]

Back to the Basics

GAME OVER

​

The scout had seen a lot, but didn't see a way he could talk himself out of this situation. Two nights ago all of them still sat around a table, scheming their plans an now... all dead.

Mana is dead! He was mafia!

Victory! Town wins!​

I kind of should have done some additional inactivity kills today, but praise yourselves lucky the game has ended. :D

Players

Ullion as the Villager
jdthebud as the Judge
Elektra Heart as the Vigilante
Collector Elwood as the Bulletproof
JohnnyMustang as the Ghoul
Hibikaze as the Town Crier [N0]
Nina as the Villager [N0]
Kaneki!!! as the Cultist [D1]
Nimsy as the Party Host [N2]
Superjolt as the Autocrat [N2]
Lisia as the Gunsmith [D3]
Candy as the Miller [N3]
Golgari as the Survivor [N3]
Davepetasprite^2 as the Hunter [D4]
Lost as the Loudmouth [D4]
TheCapsFan as the Cop [D4]
alexkaz61 as the Survivor [D5]
[g="daily"]Charlie Brown[/g] as the Angel [N5]
NightKrow as the Bleeder [D6]
Desinishon as the Villager [D6]
honey as the Doctor [N6]
KetsuekiR as the Drunk [N6]
Klippy as the Sniper [D7]
CatmanDaTrainer as the Blacksmith [N7]
GreyBidoof as the Hooker [D8]
Bardothren as the Witch [N8]
Nagi as the Snoop [N8]
Mana as the Scout [D9]

A vanilla game for once, cool! Add me in Lycan!

You know I'm in :)

#RIPme

In in in in Finally...

omg this is the best thing ever. And here I was wondering if it would be chill for someone with dozens of games under their belt to pop by and say 'hey, can I play with the beginners?' and then this happened. HOORAY! Count me in.

I'll play :D

Yes, for sure. 100%

Me please.

In it to win it.

WHAT MORE DO I HAVE TO SAY LYCAN SIGN ME UP BABY

Since you all killed me in everything else, in!

Sign me upppp fam

excellent

Yes please!

Might as well sign up.

Sup, let's go.

Hi

Okay yeah, I think I can handle one more. Especially since it's simple. In.

Yesss in for this

Okay, I've been convinced into joining this one instead.

IN

NILLA?

HECK YEAH

f yes let's get jiggy with some 'nilla

I'm in.

vanilla's my favorite flavor

I've never really understood the term "vanilla". Are all of the other mafias and stuff we do here chocolate? Or strawberry?

And I'm in 'cuz why not.

No, they're all salt flavoured. c:

/in. I really need this rn
hopefully i'm not too late to sign up

Hi I'm moving to the big kids game let me in xD

in please

In guys

o/ meeee?

can i still join?

BOOM! Game over!

 

[Alex Kaz]

>Called out Klippy d1
>Constantly argued with Bard
>Told y'all kaneki was the cultist but was ignored

I feel like a freaking martyr atm

 

[Salzorrah]

shoulda killed johnny instead smh >.>