Beginner's Mafia: Trouble in The Guild!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think it's Absol, just a gut feeling. I'm going to stick with yesterday's vote of [KILL] Kiyoshi the Polar Bear even though my vote won't change anything
 
Eros is a lazy bastard, and I'm sick of waiting and hearing "I'll do it tonight, or tomorrow!" So here it is.

NIGHT THREE
Suspicions

​

Aiden walked in, with Eros nowhere to be found, and discovered Absol being backed into a corner by the rest of the Guild. Aiden calmed everyone, wondering where the hell Eros had disappeared to. It didn't matter; another Guild member was about to die, might as well save him the trouble.
"Absol, everyone here seems to find you guilty. Your actions as I've been told do paint you in a very suspicious light. I guess our investigation on you will tell."

The death was settled quickly, and Aiden, as the Disaster Pokémon, quickly began to feel something was up. Two sets of killers were still loose, and Aiden felt something up with the one close to him. He shook off the feeling, becoming ever more worried that the Guild was done for.

Absol Used Bite! is dead. She was Innocent.
​
​

RULES

​

❋ The PokeCommunity Rules apply here
❋ One final vote per day phase
❋ Please use KILL [name] and bold it to confirm your vote
❋ No PM Sharing
❋ All Mafia discussion should be kept here
❋ If you are DEAD, you are DEAD. Don't haunt the thread with your posts
❋ For kills, if there would be a tie, the last player killed will break the tie.
❋ Getting caught posting at the night phase will automatically kill you
❋ Night actions should be sent to me by PM
❋ Abstaining is not allowed
​

CAST LIST

​

eros as the Guildmaster
Ninja Aiden as Second-In-Command
arachnidsGrip as the Guild Secretary

Melody as a Guild Member
gio7sm as a Guild Member
Emboar as a Guild Member
Kiriyuuki Kasuna as a Guild Member
Ash as a Guild Member
Yuta as a Guild Member
Absol used bite! as a Guild Member
Ullion as ???
Nagi as ???
Syn as ???
Kiyoshi the Polar Bear as ???
Lucky Lickitung as ???
Seth Rollins as ???
Infinite as ???
Blurryface as ???
Lawlietta as ???
zevarius kerensky as ???
​
 
"They had missed so many obvious hints it was beginning to get tedious."

well i'm beginning to think that we missed an opportunity to kill kiyoshi.

thats just me tho...

i'll re-read everything wait

EDIT: I really think it's kiyoshi. He's a bear so he can bite right? and "fur in the blood" a polar bear also has fur

now another suspect is lawlietta. she's been hopping in bandwagons for no reason at all and they have been pretty silent in this game.
 
Last edited:
Yuta's dead, how is she a suspect?

Ugh, guys, I'm pretty sure that the last post just proved how I'm not mafia - I hadn't moved from my bed last night, and the footprints aren't mine. Besides, why would the day posts only give hints about one mafia member, when there's multiple - 3, if this post alludes to anything.

[Icy Wind] Nagi

Puppies have teeth, or the fur in question. If I hadn't had my ability wasted, this is who I think is suspect.​
 
Who's hopping on bandwagons now, Seth? You didn't even give a reason to lynch Nagi..

Okay, so it seems we have 3 mafiosos left. If we leave out the possibility of Lucky or Blurryface being mafia, there are only 3 other innocents left.
Going on the clues from all the posts so far, I'd say Kiyoshi fits the bill best: claws, teeth, fur, 'another Ki'... and I've voted for him consistently for two days because of this. But today's post suggests otherwise, so I'd say we should leave him for now.. Though, I'd say the 'another Ki' might be the obvious hint we missed? ;o
I don't think Kiyoshi is innocent. Plus I thought there were at least 4 mafia.. Maybe he was meant to send in a night action but forgot?

I think I will vote [KILL] Seth Rollins for now. He doesn't really seem to care who to vote for- just today he's already changed his vote without explanation. I think that's reasonable. If it's not Seth, I think we should go for Kiyoshi tomorrow.
 
Fletch rocked up into Syn's room, taken aback by the carnage that had just happened in the night. Three sets of footprints were trailing out of the room, and one also went into a certain bear's room, then coming back out, however, on inspection the bear was still in his room with no trace of re-entering later. Fletch shook his head. Today was it. It was kill right, or be killed. They had missed so many obvious hints it was beginning to get tedious.

BEARS. ALL FUCKING BEARS

Honestly Kiyoshi, [KILL] Kiyoshi The Polar Bear

Lawlietta said:
Who's hopping on bandwagons now, Seth? You didn't even give a reason to lynch Nagi..

Okay, so it seems we have 3 mafiosos left. If we leave out the possibility of Lucky or Blurryface being mafia, there are only 3 other innocents left.
Going on the clues from all the posts so far, I'd say Kiyoshi fits the bill best: claws, teeth, fur, 'another Ki'... and I've voted for him consistently for two days because of this. But today's post suggests otherwise, so I'd say we should leave him for now.. Though, I'd say the 'another Ki' might be the obvious hint we missed? ;o
I don't think Kiyoshi is innocent. Plus I thought there were at least 4 mafia.. Maybe he was meant to send in a night action but forgot?

I think I will vote [KILL] Seth Rollins for now. He doesn't really seem to care who to vote for- just today he's already changed his vote without explanation. I think that's reasonable. If it's not Seth, I think we should go for Kiyoshi tomorrow.
Click to expand...

Really? I just made a post of all the suspects I think are mafia and you ignore all that and vote for me??

Okay, If Im correct, Kiyoshi said this:

Puppies have teeth, or the fur in question. If I hadn't had my ability wasted, this is who I think is suspect. (Nagi)

That means he's the cop and why not believe him I mean no counter claims, and I am a friggin townie I can't do shit

Plus I clearly said: If you are lying, you will die tomorrow. Hope I explained myself.

The clues are too obvious that it is Kiyoshi, but we did the same thing with Gio and Absol, they ended up being innocent.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I'll admit, I am something. I've a role.

I don't understand how you guys don't see that I was roleblocked last night (footprints leading into and out of my room but no evidence that I moved out of my bed?) and couldn't properly decipher what Nagi was, but I'm one-hundred percent sure the only reason I'm alive is so the mafia have a scapegoat and win today.

But if you guys want to lose be my guest I mean.

I can however state that Seth is innocent, so I wouldn't recommend killing him either.​
 
well... there's something interesting i've noticed as well though. this was Night 3, meaning that we should have had another double kill tonight, because the Serial Killer was allowed to kill again. but we didn't. and seeing as how Kiyoshi just explained that he is 1. something and 2. roleblocked... could it be?

[KILL] Kiyoshi the Polar Bear
 
I don't think Kiyoshi is the cop. It seems clear to me that both the cop and the vigilante are dead from the hints when Emboar and Ash died.
He could however be the serial killer... But if Kiyoshi is the serial killer, how can he be certain that Seth is innocent? >> I see no logic in this.
I'm more convinced he is mafia now- this way he would know who is innocent. They could both be mafia and be conspiring to kill Nagi o:
Or maybe I'm just being really paranoid and Nagi actually is mafia ._.
asdfghjkl who should I vote for?
 
Meh, okay, I'll bite. Not gonna lie my way out of this, I don't think.

[PokeCommunity.com] Beginner's Mafia: Trouble in The Guild!


I am the Serial Killer.​

And actually, it was my plan to work with the innocents until we eradicated the mafia. But since y'all are so trigger-happy, I might as well disprove some things and give you a fighting chance - you wouldn't want my previous lies to convince you to believe in the wrong people, right?

On Night One, I killed Kiriyuuki Kasuna after suspicion that Emboar was the investigator - he said "my reasons are hard to explain," which I thought actually meant "I'm the investigator and I found mafia but I don't want to role reveal." Apparently the mafia thought so too, since they killed him. Too bad I was wrong about Kiriyuuki. :/

So yeah, that "fur" hint was me. I'm too messy for my own good. :3

I asked about Gunner's "another ki" hint - since I was reasonably like "what the hell, you can't just role reveal me like that, that's unfair" - and, when she said it, she actually had no idea what role I was. Moral of the story, don't ever listen to Gunner, she's a bad influence and don't eat any of the candies she gives you.

But every other hint? That's not me. Those teeth are not mine, and everybody else's death was Cubchoo-free. I'm not quite sure why you guys are mixing all the hints together into one theory, because, well, there's more than just one mafia member. But since I was able to brush off the "fur" hint, I really began looking at the teeth hint. Unfortunately, it wasn't Absol like I expected, so what Pokemon would primarily use biting to kill someone?

Would it be Piplup (Ullion), Lillipup (Nagi), Lickitung (Lucky), Bidoof (Seth), Chingling (Infinite), Charmander (Blurry), Shinx (Lawli), or Riolu (Zevarius)?

Maybe Lillipup, maaaaybe Shinx, or, and I'm not sure why anyone (including myself) didn't really think of this before but Bidoof? Yes I was totally fibbing about knowing that Seth was innocent. I have no idea what he is. Since he's the one mixing all the hints together to point at me, yeah, now that I really think about it, he's probably mafia. I was only trying to insinuate I was the investigator to see if it would save my hide.

The only reason I'm alive right now is because the mafia wanted a scapegoat. Why kill me at night when you can just spare yourself facing death during the day phase?

To explain my vote on Nagi, I'm suspicious of her since she is a teeth suspect and she "happened to notice" it was serial killer night - she would know if she blocked me herself. I'm starting to get a little shaky on my resolve that she's apart of this, but whatever. She'd be dead if I wasn't roleblocked last night is all I know.

My third guess on mafia is Ullion, I never trusted that horny penguin. There was never any evidence, so I couldn't get him lynched. Curious he was quick to back up Seth in the way he did.

I don't expect you to spare me considering and the mafia will probably kill me tonight anyway if I do live (not the case if the doctor is still alive and would protect me - odd thought, yeah, but I am still trying to kill the mafia; it's not like I've wanted to kill innocents at any point during this game intentionally before the mafia was out of the way.) Nevertheless, go forth and prosper my lovelies, in the spirit of your friendly neighborhood murderer. ^w^

[Blizzard] Seth Rollins​
 
I'm inclined to believe Kiyoshi that he's the Serial Killer, and notice how he did not kill any of us for 2 nights[PokeCommunity.com] Beginner's Mafia: Trouble in The Guild!. He's probably with us. So yeah,

[kill] Nagi

Sorry Nagi but you are another teeth suspect!

Also come on I'm a Bidoof I am nice :( I'm just a simple normal Pokemon in the guild with no Night Actions ;_;

PLEASE DONT DO THIS TO ME

I tried my best to help you all but you do this?!

Shaking

My

Head
 
Kiyoshi the Polar Bear said:

My third guess on mafia is Ullion, I never trusted that horny penguin. There was never any evidence, so I couldn't get him lynched. Curious he was quick to back up Seth in the way he did.​
Click to expand...

So I was quick to backup Seth not because you were mafia but because I thought you were the serial killer. I mean its bloody obvious in the day post saying that someone visited your room and you did nothing - and funny that tonight only 1 kill happened when there should have been two.

But now that you mention it, if we lynch the serial killer, we lose. And if we ever do feel threatened by you, at least we know who you are and can lynch you later when needbe. :3

But this leaves two prime suspects: Nagi and Seth. Mind you both could also be mafia. I'm just gunna flip a coin on this one ><"

Okay.... [Lynch] Seth Rollins. I hope to Arceus we're right this time
 
Flip a coin?!

Last time we did that we killed an innocent!

I'm a guild member, A BIDOOF ;_;

HOW CAN YOU KILL A BIDOOF?!

BIDOOF IS NOT EVIL
 
Ullion said:
So I was quick to backup Seth not because you were mafia but because I thought you were the serial killer. I mean its bloody obvious in the day post saying that someone visited your room and you did nothing - and funny that tonight only 1 kill happened when there should have been two.

But now that you mention it, if we lynch the serial killer, we lose. And if we ever do feel threatened by you, at least we know who you are and can lynch you later when needbe. :3

But this leaves two prime suspects: Nagi and Seth. Mind you both could also be mafia. I'm just gunna flip a coin on this one ><"

Okay.... [Lynch] Seth Rollins. I hope to Arceus we're right this time
Click to expand...

I mean, the whole reason for my reveal is, so long a third party is alive in the game, the mafia can't win, right? We both want to get rid of them, so I'm totally willing to cooperate. To boot they know who I am so I'm essentially useless as long as the Roleblocker is around if you feel threatened. Basically, you guys can win through me.

If we can get rid of that nasty Roleblocker before my night I'll even be your vigilante if you need it, and then you can lynch me. I just want those pests to lose. Killing people is supposed to be my job. >:C​

Seth Rollins said:
Flip a coin?!

Last time we did that we killed an innocent!

I'm a guild member, A BIDOOF ;_;

HOW CAN YOU KILL A BIDOOF?!

BIDOOF IS NOT EVIL
Click to expand...

this is essentially how I felt the entire game

I'm super sorry if you are innocent.

But sir may I inquire if your profession provides dental insurance.

Quite the choppers you have there.​
 
Spoiler:


Explain to me how can a bidoof kill someone?!

See I'm a guild member, I can't even defend myself because I cant do shit in this game!

kill me, and it's game over. hope you're right.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top