4th Gen Favourite Starter Pokemon!

[Flareen]

Sinnoh was easy: I don't really like either of them but Turtwig is still quite fine with me!

as for Johto: I pretty much like all of them but particulary Chikorita and Cyndaquil. In the end I voted for Chikorita though cause I had her in my last playthrough :3

 

[The Grubby Pup]

...I guess, I would say Chimchar. I mean, Infernape's pretty badass.

 

[15israellai]

For D/P/Pt: I have tried Empoleon and Infernape. Infernape is pretty strong, but I like the looks of Empoleon more so I re-used it in my second playthrough of Platinum.
For HG/SS: Back in Crystal I tried both Typhlosion and Feraligatr. I didn't like Feraligatr at all frankly, perhaps due to the lack of Physical water moves. And Typhlosion has been my all-time favourite, so I got him again in SS (which I have abandoned). Now I'm starting HG and I've considered both of them. However, I'm not confident in Feraligatr and I like Kingdra so I'm gonna choose Cyndaquil - again.

 

[Loriania]

D/P- Piplup
HG/ SS- Cyndaquil

I tend to favour water starter, and rarely use grass.

 

[Vectron]

Turtwig/Cyndaquill. Turtwig for HP/Def and Cyndaquill for Best type against Johto Gyms.

 

[Runs With Scissors]

turtwig and todidile cause turtwig is EPIC as torterra and cause i used todidile a long time ago when i had a copy of gold. :D

 

[Yoshikko]

Hmm the Chikorita- and Totodile line. I love Meganium, even though I've never used it before, because I like it's design, and the name as well. And I've always used Feraligatr, I like water and grass type the most out of the three, and Feraligatr is pretty strong as well.

 

[Westie7]

Turtwig, Totodile, and Cyndaquil. Turtwig is my favorite design of the Sinnoh starters, and gets Earthquake at evolution, and Cyndaquil and Totodile are just awesome.

 

[PokéSwimmer]

Totodile is by far my favorite. It has awesome evolutions and is a great (in game) water type. If I were to list the starters in the order I liked them though, it would go like this:
Totodile
Cyndaquil
Chikorita
Monferno
Piplup
Turtwig. (Yeah, I really don't like the Sinnoh Starters)

 

[Namehere]

Ah, I'd have to say Turtwig and Chikorita. Turtwig was just awesome for me and my team, and Chikorita has been a favorite of mine since Silver.

 

[Beaute]

Hard choice but I think either Chikorita or Cyndaquil.

2nd runner up would be Pipulp ^.^

 

[cazzler]

Chimchar line since I like its offense stats and attacks, being a fire/fight it has a lot of power. Totodile line is the other one, It became my favourite ever since I used it in Gold...

 

[chella182]

Cyndaquil for sure on HGSS. As for the DPPt starters, I have a bit of a love-hate relationship with them. I tried starting with all three on my Diamond and played until they evolved once and didn't particularly rate any of them. I went with Chimchar eventually because I usually always choose Fire, but I kind of wish I'd stuck with Turtwig now, so Turtwig gets my vote there.

 

[DiabloMask]

Voted for Cyndaquil...
i like Totodile as my starter in silver, but Cyndaquil's line
is very cool.
I didn't like the starters in the 4th generation, Piplup's
evolutions were cool thought, but they can't be compared to
the 1st and 3rd generations' starters.

 

[Zelda]

To be honest, and between the DPPt starter trio alone, they were all really great. Out of all though, I choice Piplup the most (when restarting the games and my first playthrough), so I would have to go with the evolution line for Piplup.

As for HGSS and DPPt starters combined, I'd have to go with Chikorita. Meganium is gorgeous!

 

[vaporeon7]

Mine is the Cyndaquil family (Sorry Twiggy). This is because I love the appearance of all of them. Cyndaquil is super cute and cool. Quilava has an awesome anime voice... well at one point. And Typhlosion is awesome. I almost always start with Cyndaquil in Johto games.