• Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Gunpowder: Age of Outlaws

Seth Rollins said:
What the

@Gunner: forgive me. It is pretty obvious you're Shillace though, not sure why Johnny insists that you aren't. I don't come on computer so to check the stats I have to go to the second page and i dont always do that
I should though. I I forgot. My mistake.

Princess gargelhina what

Shall we kill bard or?
Click to expand...

we shall kill bard . as i have said i am a sherif. and i investigate bard in "night 2" and found that he is not innocent. ya its odd two sherif in a game. i want to (attack) bardothren.
 
Last edited:
Lol people like it wasn't obvious.

Bardothren said:
Because I have nothing to add to this shitstorm of a day.

And suckers, looks like I was right to trust Gunner. Hah!
Click to expand...

This post essentially says I'm scum, though paraphrased. And I still believe Melody is one.
 
I'm in for attacking Bard. If he flips inno then we'll just kill garghelina.

but I shall wait for Bard's response.
 
princess garghelina said:
we shall kill bard . as i have said i am a sherif. and i investigate bard in "night 2" and found that he is not innocent.
Click to expand...

I'm not inclined to believe you unless you tell us your role's name. Saying sheriff doesn't cut it for me.
 
But according to day one post, it said the sheriff found scum right? We cant conpletely rely on it

Okay Johnny but maybe the cop isnt called cop in this game.

Bard did look scum-ish to me as Alex pointed out too so
 
Guys my role play is sherif. to prove it abby you are innocent i have investigate you in night 1. i am afraiding that the mafias will kill me because they know that i am a sherif. bye guys because the mafia are going to chop me up.
 
Johnny said:
I know you dislike reading the OP and like to come up with your own theories of what the GMs do and do not do, but here's what I was talking about a few posts above:



@Seth: Excellent point actually, since this is based off a western roleplay, that makes absolute sense. Remember day 1 post? It said the Sheriff, with the Citizen's colour on it.
Click to expand...

what you want to mean john? I might have to investigate you. I don't like liers. Believe it or not? No matter you will find that i am the real sherif in the last of the game.
 
Johnny said:
I know you dislike reading the OP and like to come up with your own theories of what the GMs do and do not do, but here's what I was talking about a few posts above:
Click to expand...
Salt Much?



@Seth: Excellent point actually, since this is based off a western roleplay, that makes absolute sense. Remember day 1 post? It said the Sheriff, with the Citizen's colour on it.
Click to expand...
You guys are aware that princess said "night 2" is when she investigated Bard, and the sheriff found someone bad on day 1. How the heck is the Day post gonna say that they found scum when they didn't investigate it until the night after? Doesn't makes sense to me.
 
princess garghelina said:
what you want to mean john? I might have to investigate you. I don't like liers. Believe it or not? No matter you will find that i am the real sherif in the last of the game.
Click to expand...

I could be in the wrong here... but isn't Johnny agreeing with Seth on the fact that you are the cop (named sheriff for the theme of this game though), I'm not too sure why you're going after him since it looks to me like he was defending your position? Am I missing something entirely? x_x
 
I get townread from Johnny. Also Ulli, I don't think that'sa good idea because garghelina already visited Abby and found she was inno. Also Pecilia, maybe garghelina got everything mixed up.

As Johnny said, a sheriff in an old west style mafia game could be cop. The OP post says that every citizen got EM like roles, which makes it even better. I do believe garghelina for now.

princess garghelina you should investigate Alex and Abby you should investigate Naku/Nimsy imo

EDIT: Here are my townreads

Johnny Abby and garghelina. I forgot EC whoops (and Gunner)

Pecilia not sure but he does look towny. Cant say.

scumread on Bard obviously.
 
Yeah look at my edit for the town/scumreads

I have absolutely no problem with them investigating Pecilia.

I do think they should investigate those who dont speak because no posts = no reads and that will save us trouble.
 
Johnny said:
Er... I don't believe you. Considering Garghelina's a newbie, she wouldn't pull a bold move like that, and considering your experience, that was a rather poor counterclaim and it's quite convenient that you're the sheriff too.
Click to expand...

Honestly I'm not sure about Bard, he could be telling the truth or he could be lying but I also don't believe Princess and using they're a newbie doesn't really make a good reason because the scum could just tell her what to do and say. Abby should investigate Kaz or Bard, more leaning to Bard because Kaz may very well be inno and Bard just guessed it.

Another thing so far only Nimsy and Princess have voted Bard. If Princess is the Sheriff (Citizen stats) then we can subtract 2 from the total and find out Nimsy's attack. Information like that could be useful and this mess will likely take another night to solve with another few investigations. Oh and there's also a possibility that we have a whole good cop bad cop thing going on but that's really far-fetched right now.
 
We don't have to straight up kill somebody just yet, we could still investigate people. I'm down if ya'll wanna put some damage on so when we do get some conclusive answers will be able to finish him off, if he's scum, quicker but we shouldn't mob attack him just yet.
 
@Alex: Care to explain that unnecessary shade you are throwing at me? I'm not going to waste my vote on an OMGUS but I am finding your pushing to be a little bit scummy.

I'm certainly thinking it's a little bit odd that Bard is now counterclaiming Gargh, and I'm inclined to believe that he would not be so silly as to walk into what is basically a 50% chance to die this phase, and a 100% chance to die the next phase should his counter claim be innocent.

I am more willing to believe that a completely new player to the UG may be more unpredictable than we might anticipate; particularly if they've concealed or not mentioned any past experience with the game from us. Of course there's no way to tell, and they may simply be learning a lot faster than we anticipated. They may also be getting coached; this is completely possible if they are a mafia role and can access mafia or other group chat. But that doesn't mean much. They may be getting their own ideas from reading other games as well. I guess that depends on how much they have studied into other games that are complete or still ongoing.

Regardless if we're still going to be split on who is innocent or not; given the latest development I think I'm going to cave and say that Ullion's idea for Abby and Gargh to investigate each other would be useful. Particularly we may even just have Bard also investigate as well? I know that will likely result in the three of them fingerpointing at one another as scum but we already believe Abby to be clear and can at least lynch on her result; which will reveal her as being legitimate or not as well as revealing the clear or unclear status of the third claimant. No matter who we lynch we find our scum tomorrow or the next day. If we have other more important targets to deal with; I think that they should be considered today. We can also perform other probing attacks to find out who is who as well.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top