• Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Gunpowder: Age of Outlaws

Not bad logic Johnny but yesterday Gunner didn't take damage like she said, and if she was Cosma she would have taken a ton.
 
Pecilia said:
At least provide good reasoning in your votes, just going on the initiative with nothing to show is straight up a bad play.
Click to expand...

I went on the initiative to spark this bonkers firestorm. Just wait until you see what I have planned for, oh, the next 5 days.
 
Johnny said:
That's Gunner's description of the role. Like I said, she could be lying. If you ask me, it makes more that two scums know each other roles, rather than two innocents.

About the HP, that makes sense, but... This game is based off a roleplay, a roleplay which I was a part of for a time, and Verelys was an immortal being that inhabited humans looking for the perfect host. Many of the hosts ended deteriorating, but Verelys was never killed. Besides, the description does say that Cosma is just a drawback for Verelys, so maybe Cosma HAS to die and that's why Gunner wanted to take damage, instead of EC. For all we know, Gunner might be a scapegoat/fool kind of role.
Click to expand...

That took no damage. We know from the phase post that Shillace and Achilles are roles in the game and no one has counter claimed Shillace which in all honesty at this point would've been a smart thing to do since they take no damage anyways, numbers aren't adding up to that and The Others could also just be a single person, Shillace and Achilles (and I just know noticed that they're both comprised of the same letters dang it) are shown to be with separate hp/attack.

I'm still not 100% sure on Abby but no one has CC'd yet and you were also cleared by Abby so for now I'm going to leave it as is until further developments that may show otherwise. I doubt EC actually knows because his action looked defensive rather than offensive but it does appear that he saw an outlaw the night prior which is something we should get more information on.
 
Johnny said:
We'll see how much damage I take from EC this phase and we'll narrow it down. I'm still not sold on the idea. I get that people can simply rush into things, but it's been two days in a row in which EC is the first one to attack.
Click to expand...

Day 1 I attacked Seth.
Nobody else attacked Seth.
Seth took 4 damage.

I'd say that narrows it down pretty well, don't you?
 
EvilChameleon said:
Day 1 I attacked Seth.
Nobody else attacked Seth.
Seth took 4 damage.

I'd say that narrows it down pretty well, don't you?
Click to expand...

Beat me too it the only roles who do 4 damage is Achilles, Alex Rose (not Kaz you cheeky individual), Shadow, and Sophia but with Gunner as Shillace I'd say he is what he claims.
 
Last edited:
Shortly before the night phase post, I said some things that were not very polite to EvilChameleon, and it was suggested by one of the GMs that such personal insults were not OK. I would like to apologize to EC for calling him a moron. That was wrong. What I meant to say was that he was making horrible, inexplicable plays and saying and doing things that seem to be actively trying to get himself scumread, and that he should probably knock it off if he wants to stay alive.

Now...

In light of everything that's happened, I actually believe that EC's town - town playing exceptionally poorly, but town nonetheless - and since Gunner didn't take any damage, I'm guessing she's probably telling the truth, but EC is just the trolliest of all time. I mean, sheesh. I tempted to attack him just to get rid of how annoying he is >.> But since that probably isn't the best option, I feel kinda stuck... as I said yesterday, I don't really trust Abby, but at the same time, I don't really want to attack him, since he could be telling the truth (but has inexplicably not been targeted by mafia yet :/). Aside from that, the person acting most suspicious is almost certainly (to me, at this point) town, so there's really nothing more than "the usual suspects", who could easily be town.

So in short, we don't really have any leads (/me flashes back to Illusions)
 
I just went back to read the OP to make sure I didn't miss something, and I guess I did, because I didn't know I was an innocent role until now. >_<
 
EvilChameleon said:
I just went back to read the OP to make sure I didn't miss something, and I guess I did, because I didn't know I was an innocent role until now. >_<
Click to expand...

Don't make me take that apology back, EC...
 
In fairness, this changes absolutely nothing about my playstyle the rest of the way.
 
Welp.

@EvilChameleon: Some people were saying some pretty mean things to you yesterday, I honestly thought it was too much. So on behalf of the UG, we are all sorry. People here are salty. Hope you stay.

I also find it weird how Alex went with Johnny's logic. I think it's pretty obvious now that EC is town.

I'm probably leaning on Alex right now, can't say I'm certain, I'llsee if iIccan come up with something better.
 
Earth Traveler said:
In light of everything that's happened, I actually believe that EC's town - town playing exceptionally poorly, but town nonetheless - and since Gunner didn't take any damage, I'm guessing she's probably telling the truth, but EC is just the trolliest of all time. I mean, sheesh. I tempted to attack him just to get rid of how annoying he is >.> But since that probably isn't the best option, I feel kinda stuck... as I said yesterday, I don't really trust Abby, but at the same time, I don't really want to attack him, since he could be telling the truth (but has inexplicably not been targeted by mafia yet :/). Aside from that, the person acting most suspicious is almost certainly (to me, at this point) town, so there's really nothing more than "the usual suspects", who could easily be town.
Click to expand...
They all went after EC this is shown when both gangs try to ambush him but ended up getting jumped themselves as he vanishes.

EvilChameleon said:
I just went back to read the OP to make sure I didn't miss something, and I guess I did, because I didn't know I was an innocent role until now. >_<
Click to expand...

EvilChameleon said:
In fairness, this changes absolutely nothing about my playstyle the rest of the way.
Click to expand...

(image no longer exists)
 
  • Like
Reactions: EC
Honestly we just need to see if anyone has anything to share but we're probably not going to end up attacking anyone. I'll be voting Gunner again since she takes no damage if there's nothing else.
 
^ Sounds like a good strat, since there isn't really much to go on here...
 
I gues we'll just have to see how alex flips!
Let's just hope I don't die.

Also, I'll probably just throw my vote at gunner if nothing better comes up.
 
I must have missed the part where gunner takes no damage

I need to go back and read the previous day, despite it apparently being a shit show
 
I am so confused.
I missed day one, because I didn't have internet access.
But now I have bath tub internet.

I tried reading D1, but There's so much and I got lost.
Can someone give me a brief summary of events?
I think that may also help others.
 
Nimsy said:
I am so confused.
I missed day one, because I didn't have internet access.
But now I have bath tub internet.

I tried reading D1, but There's so much and I got lost.
Can someone give me a brief summary of events?
I think that may also help others.
Click to expand...
Gotchu fam.

[Abby] I'm done getting scumread I'm Janet
[Everyone] WTF WHY U ROLE CLAIM IMPORTANT ROLE SO EARLY
[Johnny] Memes
[EvilChameleon(EC)] I'm shooting Seth cuz I'm not falling for Abby bait
[SethRollins] ;-;
[Johnny] Memes
[Everyone Else] WTF WHY U ATTACKING PEOPLE
[EC] Cuz reasons
[Johnny] Memes
[Some People] EC IS ACTING SCUMMY, KILLING HIM
[Gunner] EC WTF U TRYNA KILL ME????
[Everyone] Wat
[Gunner] stop shooting him, shoot me instead
[Some other people] k, votes gunner
[Johnny] Memes
[Even more people] I'm shooting EC anyways bcuz gunner might be baiting and EC still looking super scummy
[GP] k guys day's over, also stop insulting EC mmk
[Day 1 Tally] EC takes 44 damage, Gunner takes none, Seth takes 4
EC and Gunner pretty much confirmed Achilles and Shillace
[Night 1] Some people got shot, then GP went overboard on the day post
[EC] DIE JOHNNY!!!
[Johnny] WTF NO U
[Everyone] He's inno tho, even if he does play bad as town
RANDOM ASSASSINATION (don't know what it meant actually)
[Johnny] Tries to through reasons why EC and Gunner could be bad... day 1 votes pretty much set it in stone.
[Some people] Kinda suspect tryna convince us otherwise
[Abby] I'm relevant again, and Johnny is innocent i investigated him N0. I can only investigate on even nights.
[Everyone] k, we're not 100% sure about you being Janet right now buuuuut no has claimed otherwise so we'll give you the benefit of the doubt
[Abby] Also investigating Alex Kaz tonight
[EC] I'm going to keep attacking random people for the next few days
[EC literally 5 minutes later] Oh wait, I'm a good guy?
[Everyone] -Facepalms-
[Me] Well we really don't have anything to go on so let's wait to see if anything new happens, otherwise shoot Gunner cuz no damage.
[...] Nothing new developments, thread dies
[You] wtf happened?
[Me] This post

That's the tl;dr from what I've found. Did I miss anything?
 
^This is way too accurate.

Abby said:
I gues we'll just have to see how alex flips!
Let's just hope I don't die.

Also, I'll probably just throw my vote at gunner if nothing better comes up.
Click to expand...

Pls no me good guy I swear
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top