Hardest Choice?

[BenjiTheKid]

The only gen I ever had trouble with was the first one. I liked them all, so I didn't know who to pick. I ended up with Charmander and have picked the fire Pokemon ever since. Save for Platinum where I tried Piplup. Didn't like him, so going back to picking the fire type.

 

[Morgnarok]

The hardest one for me was sinnoh region caz they were all so dang cute.

 

[Haberdasher]

I have difficulty choosing in all generations, really. It all depends the mood I'm in, which Pokemon I haven't used in a while, and whether I want to breeze through the game or get more of a challenge.

 

[zoo3891]

My hardest choice was HG/SS because i didn't rfeally care which starter i got in that game, and it was my first adventure in Jhoto

 

[King Gumball]

Johto starters. It was such a tough decision between Totodile and Chikorita >.<

 

[PaxAmericana]

Every starter desicion can be difficult at times, so i voted every group!

 

[Tiimme]

The hardest choice for me was with the R/B/Y games.
I really like both 3 pokémon, and I never know which one to pick...

for the other games it is quite easy for me ^^

 

[Lana.]

It's always the Johto starters for me. I adore both Chikorita and Cyndaquil, so it's always between them. For the other regions, I grew up always picking water starters: Squirtle, Mudkip, and Piplup. Then I grew fond of Bulbasaur and Turtwig, so I pick them.

 

[PlatniumPiano]

GSC for sure, especially between Chikorita and Totodile. Feraligatr was my first lvl 100, and Chikorita makes the game nice and difficult... Sometimes I got all three using that glitch :p Cyndaquil really made the game too easy. Typhlosion is cool but I've never cared for the fire starters... 2nd gen ftw!

 

[jakeconstable]

totodile or cyndaquil was by far the hardest choice, always go for fire though :D

 

[Ofruck]

From 1st to 4th gen I've always ALWAYS picked the fire starter. Not only because they're cute, but I just love fire-pokemon. Wasn't a hard choice.
However BW Unova starter, I'm in a dilemma. The pig's last evo is repulsive. A fighting warrior man-pig doesn't suit my taste. On the other hand, snivvy looks just too cute to not choose, even though I don't like grass pokemons.
Eh I still cant make a desicion.

 

[Alakazam17]

Every generation had me choosing the Fire-type, as it had become a sort of tradition for me. But in my White Version, I was really tempted to choose Tsutarja over Pokabu. But in the end tradition won over and I chose the Fire-type.

Thus, I voted for the Isshu starters.

 

[Lethal-Llama]

It'd have to be Fire Red. I still don't know between Squirtle or Charmander....

 

[Manaphy.10]

For me it was Kanto and Hoenn. All of the starters in both of those regions are good.

 

[Meganium]

It's hard to decide on which Kanto starter I should go for. I mean, Bulbasaur, Charmander, and Squirtle are really, really good. I wish I could have all three (and no that doesn't mean I want a cheat. :P)

Johto, Hoenn, and Sinnoh are relatively easy. I always choose Chikorita, Torchic and Piplup.

For Unova, it was not that easy to decide on either. Snivy and Oshawott are both... cute. xD

 

[Otherworld9)]

My Starters

On the Kanto region- I chose either Charmander or Bulbasaur. Charmander was way better for an Epic team, so I chose Charmander.
On the Johto region- Cyndaquil, all the way. Totodile, eh, neutral feeling. Chikorita, to plain and the weakest(or doesn't appeal to me).
On the Hoenn region-MUDKIP. I love that thing. So darn cute and I loved the final evo. I just got off that grass weakness of Swampert and loved him. Justt had to have a fire or flying type on my team and done.
On the Sinnoh region-Quite hard, but I chose Piplup since everybody chose Chimchar in my family and relatives. I was the first to try Piplup, and loved the water thing. Very cute indeed and kind of better than Infernape. Can't believe they did the fire/fighting match again.
On the Isshu region-Very hard, the hardest of them all since it is new and I haven't seen the three starters on action. I might pick either grass or water...hmmm.

 

[Rainbow-Sasuke]

For me, I don't find hard for any gens. I establish what starter I will choose before I start the game, making it easy for me knowing that I have a set starter! I've used every starter for Gen I and II! Emulators love me(and vice versa).

 

[Kitrigar]

I say G/S/C/HG/SS for choosing a starter. It's either Totodile or Cyndaquil, I can never choose.

Recently though, I was restarting my Pokemon White and I couldn't decide with the starters. I wanted to choose Pokabu/Tepig, but I have already chosen the piggy the last game. My second choice was Snivy/Tsutarja, but I had already chose that one on my Pokemon Black. I honestly didn't want Oshawatt/Mijumaru, but chose it anyway.

 

[mikey]

I have a hard time picking my starter when playing G/S/C & HG/SS. I can never choose between Totodile and Cyndaquil.

 

[Drekin]

The BW starters. I still haven't decided yet because I like all of their final forms so I'm probably going to look at what moves they learn and pick the best one to me.