Harry Potter chat

I have a theory about that...
Dumbledore might have been asking Snape to kill him. Stupid though it may seem, think about it. Dumbledore was already dying, and remember that Dumbledore said he wanted Snape, not Madam Pomfrey. He could have been trying to spare Malfoy from becoming a murderer. I dunno, just a thought. One of those spur-of-the-moment things...
 
Last edited:
pika-mew said:
I have a theory about that...
I think that Dumbledore might have been asking Snape to kill him. Stupid though it may seem, think about it. Dumbledore was already dying, and remember that Dumbledore said he wanted Snape, not Madam Pomfrey. I think he was trying to spare Malfoy from becoming a murderer. I dunno, just a thought...
Click to expand...

You know what, that might have some truth to it. We never know.
 
pika-mew said:
I have a theory about that...
I think that Dumbledore might have been asking Snape to kill him. Stupid though it may seem, think about it. Dumbledore was already dying, and remember that Dumbledore said he wanted Snape, not Madam Pomfrey. I think he was trying to spare Malfoy from becoming a murderer. I dunno, just a thought...
Click to expand...

kinda what I said (or at least the part of him asking Snape to kill him) but I never thought you was for Malfoy O.o
 
Malfoy hesitated when he tried to kill Dumbledore. Doubt he would have killed him if he hadn't have been interupted.
 
Steeleon said:
You know what, that might have some truth to it. We never know.
Click to expand...
We might never know until the next book anyway, should the author choose to enlighten us.
 
saul said:
kinda what I said (or at least the part of him asking Snape to kill him) but I never thought you was for Malfoy O.o
Click to expand...
Me? For Malfoy? Naw, I hate Malfoy. Or did I misinterpret what you meant?
 
I hated Malfoy fromthe very beginning. But since book six, dare I say it, I began to feel sorry for Malfoy. o.O
 
ya, malfoy was a sympathetic character to a degree. even hary said he felt some sympathy towards him. what with all his crying, getting owned by harry's hex, being threatened that mr. v would kill him and his family... it all sounds very stressful. i think i said this earlier, but i heard a rumor that malfoy and harry fight on the same side in book 7. when malfoy was talking to dumbledore, it sounded as though malfoy was intrigued (to a degree) of joining the good side, even though he kinda tried to cover it up.
 
I would indeed be a delightful twist if Malfoy were to come to the side of justice. I think that it's entirely plausible because I've always had the feeling that Malfoy cares deeply for his family and friends if nothing else, and he very well may become disillusioned with the prospect of becoming a Death Eater if he things Voldemort will kill his family.

And about Harry being a Horcrux, here's just one of many quotes from the books that could back this presumtion up:


Page 815-816 of OotP said:
-
Click to expand...

"And then Harry's scar burst open. He knew he was dead: it was bain beyond imagining, pain past endurance--
He was gone from the hall, he was locked in the coils of a creature with red eyes, so tightly bound that Harry did not know where is body ended and the creature's began. They were fused together, bound by pain, and there was no escape--
And when the creature spoke, it used Harry's mouth, so that in his agony he felt his jaw move. . . .
"Kill me now, Dumbledore. . . ."
Blinded and dying, every part of him screaming for release, Harry felt the creature use him again. . . .
If death is nothing, Dunbledore, kill the boy. . . ."
Let the pain stop, thought Harry. Let him kill us. . . . End it. Dumbledore. . . . Death is nothing compared to this. . . ."

----------------------------------------------------------------------

I feel that the only way that this scene could have happened (since no Imperius Curse was uttered and Voldemort had already gone) is if Harry was a Horcrux. It was clever of Voldemort to take possession of Harry's Horcrux at this point in time--he thought at the cost of a mere seventh of his soul, he could have ended the life of what he believes is the only person who can rise to defeat him if he could only trick Dumbledore in that moment of terror into thinking that he had some necessity in killing Harry.

Though, as we all know, Dumbledore is not that foolish and he would have never killed Harry under the given circumstances. It does make me wonder whether Dumbledore knew of Voldemort's seven Horcruxes during this time--only a couple of weeks after this incident does Harry see Dumbledore with his blackened and withered arm, so I'm leaning toward Dumbledore knowing of them but believing that the quoted incident occured because of a non-Horcrux related link between Harry and Voldemort. My point being, it makes me wonder if Dumbledore would have spared Harry's life in that moment if he had had the realization that Harry contained a Horcrux.
 
Last edited:
Kaga I love what you've just posted. Very good explanation on why Harry could indeed be a Horcrux.
 
*applause* way to be thorough (that word is hard to spell)! i agree wholeheartedly. except i think that possibly the only bond that they share is through the horcrux... but that is a great theory.
 
*cheers* That's an excellent theory! I think it entirely possible. Like you say, there's a lot of evidence all throughout the books that supports it.
 
i cant see them making this book into a movie. the movies they make are aimed toward younger kids and i cant imagine them expressing all the darkness in HBP on tv.
but they probably will make a movie but totally slaughter the orginal effect of the book like they did for books 1-3....
i was really happy when remus and tonks got together :D they deserve each other. i wonder what the 7th book will be like now that harry's quiting hogwarts and leaving his friends behind.
 
Twilight this book probobly wasn't best for younger kids. On Good Morning Amreican tomarrow they will be talking about the whole big plot twist and stuff about younger kids. I hope when they make this movie they don't make it too kid friendly, they need to stay true to the book.
 
But still, if you started from the beginning, the readers grow with the characters too. Harry was older than me at first, but now we're about the same. <<;

The GoF movie has a PG13 rating though. xD;
 
when i direct HBP i'll make sure it's not aimed at little kids, don't worry. and i will not "slaughter the original effect of the book" (just fyi). i've got some rad ideas for how to shoot the order fighting the death eaters part. you won't be disapointed!
 
I look forward to your rendition of HBP :D

Just don't dumb it down. Don't make balloons and candy come out of Malfoy's chest when he gets sectumsempra'd.

And thanks for the compliments, everyone ^^ I didn't know I could make a post that would be appreciated by hardcore Harry Potter fans o_o;
 
Chairman Kaga said:
I look forward to your rendition of HBP :D

Just don't dumb it down. Don't make balloons and candy come out of Malfoy's chest when he gets sectumsempra'd.
Click to expand...
it'll definatly be tarantino style when this happens, don't worry... or at the very least, guilty gear style:
[PokeCommunity.com] Harry Potter chat
 
You know rsgh5 when you direct HBP you'll have to let all your friends on PC be extras. You promised.
 
quite right. if i ever get the highest honor that could possibly be bestowed upon a HP fan (directing one of the films), i would invite HP/PC nerds to play student extras. the chances of this happening are like.... zero, but it's fun to talk about. i made a little banner/icon thingy that i've stuffed in my sig. if any of you want to use it, feel welcome to and don't feel obliged to site me as the creator or anything... it would ruin the somberness. the SHC will be upset that i've removed my card...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top