Harry Potter chat

I wouldnt. She should stop at book 7. Going on is just a waste.
 
Yes, I too believe she should stop at book 7 like she plans to. She will be leaving on top.
 
Why does everybody think she should stop at Book 7? Sure, It'll be ok to end the tale of Harry, but why abandon the huge wizarding world she has created?
 
GodofPH, J. K. Rowling will not be abandoning the huge wizarding world with which she created. J.K.R. knew there would be only 7 books, I mean 7 years at Hogwarts means 7 books.

Btw, check this out. I found this on www.mugglenet.com. It's a video of some guy spoiling the ending of Half-Blood Prince.

Potter Crash (Man spoils Harry Potter ending) I would be pissed if I was one of those people in the crowd, but then again, it is kinda funny. :P :P
 
I just don't see how he could have died so easily. He was basically pleading for his life.... On top of that, I was expecting it to be an all out duel or something(someone accidently told me he died.)
 
Have you heard the theory, that Snape and Dumbledore could have made Unbreakable Vow? About something. That's why they we're arguing in the forest.

And I think, that Dumbledore was pleading Severus to save Draco. If Draco could killed Dumbledore, there would be many more dangers in his life. Dumbledore knew, that Harry would be angry whoever kills him, and thinked that Severus has a point. And Severus's Vow was to protect Draco.
And wouldn't Dumbledore die however to that potion? He said, that it wouldn't kill him immediatly. 'Cause Harry wouldn't make Dumbledore drink it, if he would be sure that Dumbledore is gonna die to it.

Really ignore this, if you can't understand. English isn't my motherlanguage, and my english generally sucks. I just can read it, not write. x)
 
Well he was very weak due to the potion.
 
Sunrise's Dragon said:
Have you heard the theory, that Snape and Dumbledore could have made Unbreakable Vow? About something. That's why they we're arguing in the forest.

And I think, that Dumbledore was pleading Severus to save Draco. If Draco could killed Dumbledore, there would be many more dangers in his life. Dumbledore knew, that Harry would be angry whoever kills him, and thinked that Severus has a point. And Severus's Vow was to protect Draco.
And wouldn't Dumbledore die however to that potion? He said, that it wouldn't kill him immediatly. 'Cause Harry wouldn't make Dumbledore drink it, if he would be sure that Dumbledore is gonna die to it.

Really ignore this, if you can't understand. English isn't my motherlanguage, and my english generally sucks. I just can read it, not write. x)
Click to expand...

I had not heard any of that, but it does make sense. At least some of what you say must be true, because the way things seemed to turn out just doesnt make alot of sense to me.
 
I heard a theory on Godric's Hollow that Snape Is Draco's Father... This is possible i will post what it says:

This may exist somewhere - I didn't see it. Feel free to lock this topic if needed.

Crazy theory time!

I think Draco is Snape's son. JK said on her website that Snape doesn't have a "daughter". We all know how careful she is about how she words things. Why else would Narcissa go to Snape with her request? And why would Snape make the Unbreakable vow?

I'm not sure if I think Lucius knows or not. I know he did not want Draco to go to Hogwarts, he wanted him at Durmstrang (sp?). Narcissa refused. Perhaps if Lucius does know, he keeps up the farce so everyone will not know his wife had an affair with a half-blood.

Snape has aways had a liking for Draco. I think it's more than just the fact that he's so perfectly Slytherin.

For those of you who think, "No way! Draco looks like Lucius!" Well, Narcissa is also pale, blond, with a pointy face. If Snape had a recessive blond gene, it is very possible for a child between he and Narcissa to be blond.


Some good points have been brought up. My husband and sister-in-law have mentioned the same ones to me. The most compelling being why would she discuss it with Bellatrix and Wormtail there?

I think she set off to ask on her own, but Bellatrix followed her. I don't think she wanted Bellatrix there, but was determined. I don't know if she was aware of Wormtail being at Snape's house at that point either, but, as I said, I think she was desperate.

What is interesting to me is when Narcissa and Bellatrix enter Snape's house at Spinners End Bellatrix addresses him as "Snape" and Narcissa as "Severus". Narcissa, to my knowledge, is not a DE, but, she is a devoted mother. If she is not a DE how did she, whose family, as well as her husband, despise "half-bloods" become on a first name basis with Snape. I believe in one of her interviews JKR said or intimated that someone had loved Snape. Could it be that Narcissa once loved Snape and for reasons of the Black family's overwhelming disdain for anyone who wasn't "pure-blood" was unable to pursue a romantic attachment? JKR has only said that Snape had no daughter. She never said that he had no children.

These are good points in my opionio (sp)
 
TheOnly, those are good opinions and I could see where you are going. But for me I just can't see Snape actually being Draco's father. *Shrugs*But only JKR knows, we'll have to wait to find out.
 
i know. But i hope he is that would be a huge change.
 
Wow, that can't be right! So, did neone else hear that Percy ends up dying? something to do with sacrificing himself for Ginny or Ron or something. Sounds liek a bunch of hoo-hah to me.
 
Miyu-chan said:
Before the 6th book came out, there were also some fanfictions saying that Snape was Harry's father - that left me convinced also. xD; But who knows, that'll make it more interesting. =3
Click to expand...

xD Wow, you were convinced Snape was Harry's father. No offense but that's sad. xD
 
erm... i'm back. this last week i took it upon myself to read goblet of fire and half blood prince. i believe that this officially throws me into the category of "loser." i spend a week on an island off the coast of southern california that is almost completely full of pretty girls wearing not very much, and i stay indoors reading a book that i read earlier this month... but o well. i dun care. i've formulated an opinion of the post dumbledore snape. it is my opinion that he was acting upon dumbledore's orders (reluctantly) to kill him so that malfoy might be spared. there is a passage or two that backs this up, but right now i'm gonna go play a game. i may site it later.
 
ok

1. snape is not arrys father, voldemort is not harrys father. jkrowling said that JAMES is harrys dad.

2. youre not a loser.
 
how, the last book hasnt come out yet. but it is a huge possiblity. read my version so far. it is really good.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top