To be honest, I like Paul. He is a new start, and he has more depth then Ash so far (after...I don't know....9 SEASONS!?), and he has potential for lot more. Like, maybe there's, I don't know, a reason for why he treats his pokemon badly?
And, in my honest opinion, Ash isn't too much better then Paul. Don't believe? Read:
Point 1:
Ash: WOWZERS! Another reason!
His pokemon: =D *Yays! More fun and adventure!*
Ash: I'm going to leave all my pokemon to rot in the lab for no real reason whatsoever!
Pokemon: *Wait...what!?*
Ash: I mean, really? Why bring a team of fully evolved pokemon, so I can train them to be stronger and actually win the Pokemon League for once, when I can start with just pikachu and get a team of non-evolved pokemon!
Pikachu: PIKA! *yay* -magically goes from level 242352342 to level 2-
Point 2:
Pidgeot: -Ash, I need to stay in the forest and defend my fellow kin, the pidgey and pidgeotto, untill they can protect themselves from the Fearow-
Ash: Okay. I'll come back for you later.
-A few bajillion seasons later-
Pidgeot: ....You know what? Ash, since when did later mean A QUADRILLION SEASONS! TO THINK I'D ONCE GIVE MY ALL FOR YOU!
------
Pokemon stuck in lab: Tell me about it....
Point 3:
Bulbasuar: *about to faint*
Ash: ZOMG U CAN D0 1T BLBSR!1!
Bulbasuar: *fully revived*
Trainer fighting him: ZOMG! HE HAS THE VOICE! (Note: You'd have to have read Hoenn Insane to get this one line.)
My point:
Ash leaves pokemon to rot and only wins by pep talks that magically revive pokemon.
I'm I an Ash basher? Why, yes, I am.