Just a Mafia Game: No Two the Same [Day 6/Game Over]

I'm suspecting that the cop report isn't real. Chances are that Earth got culted because he's the cop.
Basically for that.
 
I changed my mind. I want everyone to claim. I have a way of finding out who's cult. Almost sure ET's cult

@Mr James your results on laat phase aside from Sparkin and this phase?
 
Sparkin said:
Nice job, doctor.

Seeing that everyone else alive besides Swiftie/CB has either claimed a role or been cleared by cop, I'll [Vote] Swiftie.
And for those who still doubt me, you've bypassed an important post.
Click to expand...

You haven't claimed aside from him? I need your claim as well for my plan
 
N0 - SirDolan. Had the thought that mafia wouldn't go for someone capable because they'd think I'd protect them.
N1 - Mr. James. Apparently mafia didn't try to kill him and I was the one who lessened a report from him.
N2 - KNS27. Mafia's got no killing pattern.
N3 - Pecilia. They wouldn't target the cop because they thought I'd be on them.
N4 - Earth Traveler. Couldn't afford to risk it again.

That's all.
 
Last edited:
I'm the Mayor.
 
KNS27 said:
Anyway so far
Spoiler:
Click to expand...

It's high chance that The Cop would be get culted first since The Cop was a very important role.

Since Sparkin is proved (?)to be innocent
[Vote] Swiftie

Also about Screenshot, I forgot there's a rules where you are not allowed to send PM Screenshot.Even the first image was broken.You can ask Kiyo and Sparkin that I send a broken images first.

and
Quite is Gold
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
Lol nope I'm doc, this is a list of who I've protected:

N2: replaced SirDolan, protected Bard (didn't have time to read up on what happened after I died the first time, so picked a mod bc they're often targets)
N3: protected Earth Traveller, not risking a cop death on the day of reveal
N4: protected Mr. James, to switch things up

Looking through the posts at how Mr James casually cleared Sparkin without saying the other people he dreamt about ("Remove Sparkin from the possible cult leaders. He is innocent."), I'm thinking he was culted at that point by Sparkin. Very subtle and understated way to clear someone imo.
 
M8...
Charlie Brown said:
Lol nope I'm doc, this is a list of who I've protected:

N2: replaced SirDolan, protected Bard (didn't have time to read up on what happened after I died the first time, so picked a mod bc they're often targets)
N3: protected Earth Traveller, not risking a cop death on the day of reveal
N4: protected Mr. James, to switch things up

Looking through the posts at how Mr James casually cleared Sparkin without saying the other people he dreamt about ("Remove Sparkin from the possible cult leaders. He is innocent."), I'm thinking he was culted at that point by Sparkin. Very subtle and understated way to clear someone imo.
Click to expand...

You'll need to think thrice before counterclaiming me next time.
First, even if you replaced someone, you should still have the previous reports. Where are N0 and N1, "doctor"?
And second, you say you protected James last night. Dreamer can't get a report if they are visited. Your theory is plain water.
But I didn't visit him. So unless he's culted, he should have a report ready now.

Unrelated but I have the feeling that you waited for my claim.
 
Last edited:
Kiyotaka Ishimaru said:
Can you publicly reveal as Mayor? I'd like to be sure you're def not cult. I'll place my thoughts and my vote later on who's cult. I need some sleep rn.
Click to expand...

Forgot this was a thing, I sent NK the pm to do it.

EDIT: Also unless the Cult tried to recruit a night kill target it's possible both Earth Traveler and Mr. James have been compromised.
 
Last edited:
So, rechecked past deaths and I assume these are the existing roles including for those who got culted: (Pretty sure it's accurate)

Purplecicada - Jailor (N0)
Swifte - Veteran (N0)
Miah - Lightkeeper (N1)
Abby - Cult Member (N1) [N0 recruit] [Mafia- Janitor?]
Ida - Godfather (D2)
BidoofFTW - Loudmouth (N2)
L'Belle - Cult (N2) [N1 recruit] [Mafia-Hooker?]
Gimmepie - Oracle (N2) - ET is Cop
Home - Silencer (D3)
Kitty - Vigilante (N3)
Ash - Cult (N3) [N2 recruit] [Transporter]
Bardothren - Serial Killer (D4)

Pecilia - Mayor [Culted by Sparkin?]
Swiftie 2.0 - Doctor?
Kiyotaka Ishimaru - Tracker
Earth Traveler - Cop [N3 or N4 recruit]
Sparkin - Doctor?
Mr. James - Dreamer [Culted by Swiftie?]
KNS27 - Bomb

So, I'm the Tracker and here is my record:
N0: Bardothren (No result - Jailed)
N1: No action (forgot)
N2: Home -> Redirected to someone who doesn't visit
N3: Swiftie on Earth Traveler
N4: Sparkin on Earth Traveler

From this, I can say that Swiftie and Sparkin did visit ET on the respective nights, so any statement he says is bogus as he's definitely cult. So, here are reasons to think of both as being cult leaders:

Sparkin
- Being cleared by Mr. James apparently with an ambiguous report on D4 (but if he did visit Pecilia, Mr James couldn't have supported Sparkin)

Swiftie
- Choice of cult members [kinda meta but feels like he'd choose those people for cult rather than Sparkin]
- Makes sense to recruit Cop on N3 when they already knew that all mafia were out of the game
- ET's post today is really weird. The wording is off and he seems to accuse KNS when it's obviously either Sparkin or Swiftie...
- Felt like Swiftie waited for the claim and claim is incomplete

If it isn't clear, I [Vote] Swiftie
 
Sparkin said:
First, even if you replaced someone, you should still have the previous reports. Where are N0 and N1, "doctor"?
Click to expand...

I wasn't given them, just a role PM that's all.

And second, you say you protected James last night. Dreamer can't get a report if they are visited. Your theory is plain water.
Click to expand...
Wait this is a thing?

Unrelated but I have the feeling that you waited for my claim.
Click to expand...

Kiyotaka Ishimaru said:
- Felt like Swiftie waited for the claim and claim is incomplete
Click to expand...

I don't get the 'waited for the claim' argument. I was out all day yesterday (you can check my PC=wide post history to see I wasn't online between the time the phase was posted and the time I made my posts in all my mafia games including this one), and I've been less active in general across PC over the last week (again, post history). I wasn't waiting for anything, I just haven't been online a lot.
 
Also I replaced SirDolan who never posted apart from her signing up post, do you really think she recruited people for the cult on N0 and N1 but then got replaced for inactivity by the end of D2? How does that make any sense? Why would someone be interested enough in the game to do their night action every night but then never post?
 
Charlie Brown said:
Also I replaced SirDolan who never posted apart from her signing up post, do you really think she recruited people for the cult on N0 and N1 but then got replaced for inactivity by the end of D2? How does that make any sense? Why would someone be interested enough in the game to do their night action every night but then never post?
Click to expand...

This is actually a good point. The number of recruits does not add up if SirDolan was the original cult leader.
 
Last edited:
Charlie Brown said:
Also I replaced SirDolan who never posted apart from her signing up post, do you really think she recruited people for the cult on N0 and N1 but then got replaced for inactivity by the end of D2? How does that make any sense? Why would someone be interested enough in the game to do their night action every night but then never post?
Click to expand...

Honestly solid. It seems that ET's post is a bait to lynch you.
[Unvote] Swiftie
[Vote] Sparkin
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top