- 10,682
- Posts
- 15
- Years
- California
- Seen Jun 30, 2018
When (if ever) is it okay to leave a dog (or other animal) inside a car? What should happen to people who leave animals inside? Is it okay to break open a car window to rescue an animal?
-
Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
Leaving dogs in cars
- Thread starter Esper
- Start date
- 16,129
- Posts
- 11
- Years
- Age 32
- she/her, they/them
- Online now
It's one thing if you're going to be gone for just a bit. But like with little children, you're not supposed to leave them alone in a vehicle (in an unsafe manner) for long stretches of time, as said child or pet is likely to sustain injury/death or be kidnapped since they basically are totally dependent on people to....like basically live really, and the owner of the child/pet is responsible for them.
Breaking open the car is a bit of a sticky situation in some ways, as you're destroying or damaging someone else's personal property, and what constitutes the child/pet being in danger will vary between people or it may be difficult to prove that there was a real danger. But, y'know, at the same time there's the potential that something may be dying in there.
Breaking open the car is a bit of a sticky situation in some ways, as you're destroying or damaging someone else's personal property, and what constitutes the child/pet being in danger will vary between people or it may be difficult to prove that there was a real danger. But, y'know, at the same time there's the potential that something may be dying in there.
Frozocrone
Fighting a bigger fight
- 1,472
- Posts
- 11
- Years
- Derby, England
- Seen Sep 8, 2019
In the UK the law states that:
You have a lawful excuse to commit damage if you believe that the owner of the property that you damage would consent to the damage if they knew the circumstances.
The first course of action would be to call the RSPCA and let them inspect it, if necessary they will call the police. If it's life or death call the police. If neither can arrive quickly enough it's up to you to decide whether or not to break the car. Taking photos can help your case though, as it can be classed under criminal damage.
You have a lawful excuse to commit damage if you believe that the owner of the property that you damage would consent to the damage if they knew the circumstances.
The first course of action would be to call the RSPCA and let them inspect it, if necessary they will call the police. If it's life or death call the police. If neither can arrive quickly enough it's up to you to decide whether or not to break the car. Taking photos can help your case though, as it can be classed under criminal damage.
- 1,505
- Posts
- 13
- Years
- Age 28
- he/him/she/her
- Seen Jan 27, 2025
My answer to this question is, "if you have a choice to take them, take them." As an owner of a 6-pound Chihuahua, I rarely ever leave him in the car, and if I do, the windows are cracked, and if it's really hot, the air conditioner is on and I keep an emergency water bowl on hand so he doesn't dehydrate. This may not be necessary with bigger dogs, but at the same time, it's generally just not advisable to leave them in the car. Like babies, they can overheat and dehydrate very quickly.
Tricky question. Their punishment would be based on whether or not they intended to do it (or whether or not prosecution can prove they intended to), the severity of damage to the dog, and the animal abuse laws in the country/state.
I will pretty much always say yes. If you see a dog that is clearly dehydrated or physically in pain or crying out in a car, break the window open and break it wide. To me, I'd be willing to face the charges if it meant I saved a dog's life.
Somewhere_
i don't know where
- 4,493
- Posts
- 9
- Years
- somewhere (duh)
- Seen Jun 5, 2019
In Florida this can be an issue I've heard of a few cases of fathers leaving their kids in their car going to work and forgetting about them. Its really sad. I wouldnt say its abuse unless its intentional of course because its just a mistake and I think its justified to break into someone's car to save the kid. For a pet, I dont know.