• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

Let's talk about Indie games

  • 8,973
    Posts
    20
    Years

    I'm surprised there hasn't been a thread like this, yet!

    With Nintendo putting so much focus into their indie games and basically more or less giving the indie devs far more spotlight than they have been in prior years, it should come as of no surprise that the eshop is flooded with indie games of pretty much all kinds. Some possibly good, some not so much. But, at the end of the day, the judgment of quality does come down to the player after all, right?

    So this thread will pretty much serve as a discussion of what indie games deserve the spotlight, and which indie games to avoid. There are some $15 games out there that are just as enjoyable as a $60 game, so I do want to see some opinions out there!

    What indie games have you played, recently?

    What indie games would you recommend?

    What indie games would you not recommend?

    Let's discuss all things indie!
     
    Last edited:
    Iirc the last indie game I played was Cuphead, and that was a little while after it got released. It had a very unique style compared to other games. I really loved the 30's cartoon artstyle as well as all the references to older cartoons, and it had a really memorable OST. If someone hasn't played it yet, then I truly recommend it.

    Another one I would recommend is OFF. If you like spooky rpgs with hard puzzles, chilling OST and don't care much or anything at all for graphics as long as it has a great story, this one is a really good choice for you.
     
    I'm sorry I told you this was gonna be an essay

    I really like indie games, and I have been so glad to see a lot of my favourites hitting the eShop, as well as games I've been wanting to try! I'm a little sad they always tend to be more expensive on the Switch - it's usually just a couple more bucks but still, not loving that I have to pay an extra $5-10 to play the same game on this console, but I understand it.

    There's a lot of AAA franchises I like too, but over the years I have really grown to appreciate indie games that venture into new territory and do something different - AAA games tend to be very familiar and follow specific formulas, which is comforting and welcome in their own ways too, especially for older, beloved franchises, but a lot of indie games are a real breath of fresh air and do surprisingly fun and cool things.

    What indie games have you played, recently?

    I think most recently, I played Moonlighter - it is very reminiscent of Recettear for those who have played, (shop management + dungeon crawler) and I'm a sucker for the pixelly art style. The music is really beautiful too!

    What indie games would you recommend?

    Too many, just gonna pick a few big ones

    Undertale - I hate to be that "I liked it before it was popular" person but I did play it when it first came out and I fell in love right away. Anyone who doesn't want to play it just because too many people liked it or they don't like the fandom is really missing out

    Don't Starve/Together - I first played this in single player mode and sunk a good 40+ hours in before they released DST, and I've always had a blast playing this with friends

    Papers, Please - this is one of the games I had in mind when I said "something different" earlier, it's just something I never would have thought would be made into a game, and if you just read a description of it it really sounds quite boring. You work as a border crossing immigration officer and your job is to approve or deny people based on what they tell you and the documents they have. And they have a LOT of documents for you to inspect. If you're looking for action this ain't it but it's challenging and so, so addicting in it's own funny way, with quirky characters, a steep learning curve that ramps up quickly and moral choices to make (feed your family at all costs? cut food and heat for the night to save money? let this person's wife through against your job description even though she doesn't have the right documents or send her home and let her die?) - these choices aren't outlined clearly or anything, you are told to do your job and these aren't even presented as choices but once you get into the story you'll start questioning if just "doing your job" is what you should be doing, or if you should show compassion and hear some of these people out even if it means taking a penalty yourself. And there is no right or wrong choice, I feel like every path leads to a satisfying ending (unless you are shit at your job. then you just go to jail. spoilers).

    Hotline Miami - if you're looking for some action, this is a really good top-down shooter with a very compelling story. Again, I really like pixel graphics so that was another plus for me, but it has this 80s vibe to it that's really cool, and the story gets so dark and interesting. Gameplay is very fast-paced and exciting, I usually don't like this kind of game but I had so much fun with this one.

    Prison Architect - I love building/micromanagement games, and this is surprisingly fun despite the lackluster graphics and minimal "art". You have free reign to build a prison, you can run it like a dictator, build a resort, focus on reform or accept only hardened criminals and gang members and watch them fight to the death. It's just really addicting and easy to get sucked into.

    This War of Mine - If it's not obvious I have a soft spot for base-building, craft-and-collect survival games and this was a really good one. I don't play a lot of these that have an "ending" but it does, and it doesn't take as long as some of the endless ones to finish, but I believe the games are always randomly generated so there's a lot of replay value.

    Stardew Valley - I don't think this needs introduction

    Kynseed - pretty similar to Stardew Valley in what it is, but this is still in development and the twist is it's going to be generational - your original character is going to die, their children will continue your legacy, the villagers will also reproduce and have their children carry on their legacy, etc. I think it's a really cool concept and I'm excited to see how it develops.

    Some good/silly multiplayer games - Ultimate Chicken Horse, Golf With Your Friends, Battleblock Theatre

    What indie games have you not recommend?

    There aren't a lot of games I played that I'm just like "this is straight trash" aside from one, and it was called Always Sometimes Monsters. It's a very cheap game, like 2 bucks on Steam so maybe worth trying just based on that alone and the apparently 1000+ positive reviews (I am honestly SHOCKED this is so well received, I hated it). It was supposed to be a choose your own adventure, "your choices matter"-type game, back when those were really popular, but the story was bad and ridiculous, the dialogue was bad and pretentious, the music was bad and repetitive, and the characters are bad and unlikeable. So so so shocked this has this many positive reviews.

    And lastly, there are currently 2 games I have my eye on, Graveyard Keeper and VA-11 HALL-A - got a gift card from my coworkers on my birthday so I'm excited to pick these up when I have the time to try them :fufu:
     
    i don't have too much experience w indie games tbh. i really enjoy five nights at freddy's but i don't play them bc i'm a wuss, i just really like the figuring out the story and stuff. it's a great game to watch people play or play like WITH someone, though. i can't do it alone, personally.

    child of light also comes to mind. it's an excellent rpg and i've still yet to buy the physical copy for collection purposes, even though it's downloaded on my wii u. it's just something i feel like i gotta OWN and it is available on the vita, which i have one now so it just feels even more so like i gotta get it.

    i have stardew valley on my switch, but i haven't been able to get into it as much as i have with harvest moon titles...i think i'll be able to once i just. get into the groove and figure things out. it's popular for a reason, i just gotta give it time.

    i have undertale on my lonely steam account and started it and IMMEDIATELY messed up the uhhh what's it called. the no beating people up route lol. and i haven't touched it since then bc i was too mad, but isn't this releasing (or released?) physically now? i'll throw money at it and give it a proper shot tbh. it's got great music, too. i've hella listened to the soundtrack for someone that ain't played it lmfao.

    shovel knight is another one that's like. i did have it on the 3ds at one point, but idk what i was thinking. i'm not good at platformers and shovel knight can be like nes hard at times. i don't have it anymore unfortunately, but in my brief time playing it, i enjoyed it and all the deaths i got were of my own accord. as in.....i suck at platformers. lol

    if you can't tell, i really like having physical games, so that's probably part of why i don't partake in many indie titles. which i know is not a good reason really, i just like to have things be tangible.
     
    Papers, Please - this is one of the games I had in mind when I said "something different" earlier, it's just something I never would have thought would be made into a game, and if you just read a description of it it really sounds quite boring. You work as a border crossing immigration officer and your job is to approve or deny people based on what they tell you and the documents they have. And they have a LOT of documents for you to inspect. If you're looking for action this ain't it but it's challenging and so, so addicting in it's own funny way, with quirky characters, a steep learning curve that ramps up quickly and moral choices to make (feed your family at all costs? cut food and heat for the night to save money? let this person's wife through against your job description even though she doesn't have the right documents or send her home and let her die?) - these choices aren't outlined clearly or anything, you are told to do your job and these aren't even presented as choices but once you get into the story you'll start questioning if just "doing your job" is what you should be doing, or if you should show compassion and hear some of these people out even if it means taking a penalty yourself. And there is no right or wrong choice, I feel like every path leads to a satisfying ending (unless you are shit at your job. then you just go to jail. spoilers).
    .
    .
    .
    And lastly, there are currently 2 games I have my eye on, Graveyard Keeper and VA-11 HALL-A - got a gift card from my coworkers on my birthday so I'm excited to pick these up when I have the time to try them :fufu:

    Man, really forgot about Papers, Please and VA-11 HALL-A.

    The first ending I got in Papers, Please was the jail one lmao. But ye you're right, part of the fun in that game are all the questions you do to yourself when it comes to the way you do your job. The main theme is also quite good.

    As for VA-11 HALL-A it's a really good game to spend some time, it has a really chill OST and the interactions with the characters are really fun, so I would recommend it, too.
     
    Some huge comments here 👀

    There aren't many indie games I've recently played that weren't listed here already. I've really enjoyed Cuphead (although that Robot level got me pretty frustrated) and did play a little bit of Papers Please too! I've also played Undertale in the past but I didn't find it very good tbh, the battle system is boring. Haven't even touched Deltarune.

    There is another one that I can't remember the name right now, and not sure if it's indeed an indie game, but it did catch my attention. It's about a prison break or something. I never went very far in it though.
     
    There is another one that I can't remember the name right now, and not sure if it's indeed an indie game, but it did catch my attention. It's about a prison break or something. I never went very far in it though.
    Ooh, is it The Escapists? That one's kind of an 8-bit prison escape game, otherwise the other one I can think of is A Way Out, which had more realistic graphics and is a co-op prison break game!

    Man, really forgot about Papers, Please and VA-11 HALL-A.

    The first ending I got in Papers, Please was the jail one lmao. But ye you're right, part of the fun in that game are all the questions you do to yourself when it comes to the way you do your job. The main theme is also quite good.

    As for VA-11 HALL-A it's a really good game to spend some time, it has a really chill OST and the interactions with the characters are really fun, so I would recommend it, too.
    glory to arstotzka
    I am definitely liking what I see for VA-11 HALL-A! That I don't have a lot of time to sink into a deep rpg or anything like that at the moment made me more interested in this too, it seems like a chill game with a good but not that long story to keep me hooked and entertaining characters (and I hear I can customize my apartment with my bartending money, that is always appreciated).
     
    btw as far as indie games go Hollow Knight is definitely on my to-get list. I feel ashamed that I haven't delved a whole lot into the indie scene, but I really want to!!

    also on my to-get list is I am Setsuna and Lost Sphear. Eventually I'm going to get Oninaki too. I'm a sucker for classic JRPGs, so...
     
    h o l l o w k n i g h t
     
    It's a little on the edge, but it's been confirmed as not DLC. From what I know it's a sequel, but there still exists the possibility of being a prequel, iirc! :)
     
    ok when i get my new switch im going to play it ASAP because I just love the visuals and looking at the gameplay. ;__;
     
    Last edited:
    Hope any of you have played Cadence of Hyrule if you like rhythm games. It's absolutely wonderful.
     
    Yes yes yes I still need to get it CoH looks like so much fun!!
     
    s l i m e r a n c h e r
     
    Last edited:
    What indie games have you played, recently?
    Undertale, Deltarune, Stardew Valley

    What indie games would you recommend?
    Undertale, Stardew Valley

    What indie games would you not recommend?
    None so far. They've all been great, thankfully.

    I loved Undertale. I feel like a lot has been said about the game, but it really did deserve the praise that it got. Even when the Game Grumps revisited it recently, I still found myself watching, just to see how they'd react to all of the significant events of the pacifist run. I honestly hope Toby Fox manages to assemble a team soon so that Deltarune actually comes out. It'd be a shame to not see it come alive.

    Stardew Valley was my first and currently only game on Steam, and damn did it set the bar high. Harvest Moon was my childhood, and playing this game just took me back in ways I never thought an indie game could do. I've talked to Sophie a lot about it but Eric Barone's love for his own game clearly shows. And I cannot thank him enough for giving us the option to, unlike Harvest Moon and Story of Seasons, date bachelors and bachelorettes of the same gender as our player character. It's the best game I've played in recent years, and is a solid #5 in my best games ever. If you haven't played it, you are freaking missing out. Every penny spent was worth it.
     
    Back
    Top