Mafia Madness: Guns [Game Over]

Ok, well I got back to be greeted by Pokecommunity being a potato (nothing new here). Now its back, I can give some more insight. Again, like mentioned many other times, Bac seems quite scummy, like super quick to think Bard was mafia (which he still very well may be, there could be 2 snipers). Mars seems town to me, giving reads and communicating quite well. Also, TheCapsFan seems quite suss, especially since his only (?) post was really weird. Don't know how I feel about Green yet, seems awfully passive. Anyway, that's what I have so far. Also, Ullion, I think you shoot Bac, but again, lets see what other people think about that as well, don't want to go too aggressive.
 
geez i'm really sorry, thanks for extending the day ulli. the only opinion i have (as of where i'm caught up to) is on the bardwagon. i quite honestly don't think he'd pull the same stunt klippy pulled in B2B mafia since it literally just ended. but as the same time what if this is double reverse psychology???? mafia makes me paranoid tbh.
[vote] no one , not too sure what's going on right now
 
Mars? said:
I doubt that they would shoot a normal gun early tbh. They would probably wait until they can find a good justification for shooting. As for the vote, I'm not really suspicious of anyone else atm, but I wanted to give Twiggy a chance to defend himself. However, it doesn't look like he'll be here at this point...
[Kill] Twiggy
Click to expand...
Well, with Twiggy, it seems like his reaction to pressure is always different and he doesn't always defend himself. I feel like Bac would be more likely to provide a defense, so maybe the pressure would have been better off going in that direction instead...
Ullion said:
Since I have offered to shoot my gun as an option I'm willing to risk; no one has really given me much input. We do have two targets (in my eyes) of whom I could attempt to kill: Twiggy and Bac. Twiggy would be pointless because the BW on him is too large by now. on the other hand, a few of us seem to agree Bac seems more suss than others at this early point, and no one is voting for him yet.

I'm never sure about JD during the early game stages (and going by BttB mafia, even late game) so it's hard for me to say. I don't think he's at wording things to his advantage though, so we could always keep that in mind for the future when we get more info out publicly.

This is my first time playing with Green so I don't know their playstyle. They seem to want to play very safe with two straight days of NLing, which I think a lot of people know that I disagree with. But I learned in BttB that some townies just go to NL the first few days regardless if it's a good idea or not. :(
Click to expand...
I don't think hitting Bac would be a bad shot. Part of me wants to say that this might be a bad idea after we lost two townies to fabbed guns, but if you're town and have an unused gun going into the night you'll probably be night killed... I do want to see what Bac has to say before you do anything though. I am kind of surprised that Bac hasn't said anything yet, even without votes there's still the looming pressure of possibly getting shot. And as I was typing this, Bac finally responded lol
honey said:
geez i'm really sorry, thanks for extending the day ulli. the only opinion i have (as of where i'm caught up to) is on the bardwagon. i quite honestly don't think he'd pull the same stunt klippy pulled in B2B mafia since it literally just ended. but as the same time what if this is double reverse psychology???? mafia makes me paranoid tbh.
[vote] no one , not too sure what's going on right now
Click to expand...
I think you need to catch up all the way. I'm pretty sure we've moved on from the Bard thing (and if he were a second sniper or anything else, game balance would be highly questionable anyway).
Elektra Heart said:
You guys should remember that my comment about Bardothren was a hunch, nothing more. Heck, I didn't even vote him. That bandwagon that started wasn't my doing- not my fault you guys vote to kill someone at the drop of a hat.

If you want me to keep my hunches to myself, that's fine, I can do that. Your loss when I come up with an ingenious theory
[PokeCommunity.com] Mafia Madness: Guns [Game Over]


[vote] Twiggy
Click to expand...
Is this vote a "Better him than me" sort of thing or do you actually think Twiggy is scummy? Tell me who else you find scummy plz
TheCapsFan said:
snip
Click to expand...
Let's start forcefully dragging some inactives in here too.

Hello CapsFan! Nice day we're having, isn't it? Could you give us some actual content to work with please?
 
*sigh*

Well, getting me yanked out of the game would surely make the game a lot less interesting, if you catch my drift. It's all in the name of the game.
 
Soooo...is that a Gunsmith claim by Twiggy? We could lynch someone else so he can pass out another gun, but he will get NK'd most likely. Could be a good move though since it gets another real gun out there.

Of course, that assumes we believe his claim, which I'm not sure of. I am voting for him based on his play so far.

@Superjolt:
Drewbie - seems townish to me as he has provided some pretty good reasoning for his flip-flop vote onto Zehn, but waiting until the EoD seems to suggest he was biding his time a bit, which I think is scummy.
Bact - She never actually voted for Bard, but that seemed to give herself a way to pull back on the FOS if no one else went along with it. Plus I don't like her reluctance to share her "hunches". I wouldn't mind her being shot.
Ullion - He claimed to have a gun early on in D1, which I like, although Alex did the same. In any case, he's still acting townie to me.
GP - He's been posting a lot, and did cast the first vote for Twiggy, which I like. Slight town lean.
Ullion said:
I mean let's be real here - am I ever maf? :P
Click to expand...
DotA mafia comes to mind :P
 
I'm changing the no one vote I made before going to bed last night, sorry for inactivity today had to sleep then pre season sport training then had lunch with the bois and just got home

[vote] Twiggy I just find all the voting with even less explaining than I've done ( which I didn't think was possible lol) as more than a little suss, understanding I also seem suss. Fire away any questions you'd like to at me
 
jdthebud said:
Drewbie - seems townish to me as he has provided some pretty good reasoning for his flip-flop vote onto Zehn, but waiting until the EoD seems to suggest he was biding his time a bit, which I think is scummy.
Click to expand...

drewbie411 said:
Wait, is every suspicious of me because I switched votes from Bard to Zehn? If so, here is what I was thinking. At the beginning, I wasn't really sure if Bard was mafia or not. The more I thought about it, the more I was getting town and thinking he was sharpshooter instead. So I switched to the other FOS that people had, Zehn. I didn't really know who else to vote, and I didn't want to nl because we need to be aggressive. And Superjolt, I'll tell you what I think in a bit. I have somewhere to go IRL for now.
Click to expand...

One more thing, just to add, I never really keep track of when the phases end, so sorry about that, I will pay more attention to that next time :)
 
Neither Twiggy nor Elektra Heart seem to have been defending themselves much, other than Twiggy's heavy softing.

I get the impression Twiggy is innocent though, and since this is D2 and I don't want to forever no-vote.

[lynch] Elektra Heart

Hopefully will be more active now school is finished and my birthday weekend is out the way! :)
 
Oh look, the phase isn't over and I can finally get on pc! Guess I'm not dying today, at least from inactivity.

I just skimmed the three pages of this day. From what I see, no one has anything particularly powerful on or against anyone, but we've decided on killing Twiggy, who has "heavily softed" an "interesting" role.

Problem is, his soft came so late in the phase. At that point, either reveal or accept your death. Otherwise you look like a maf trying to bluff your way out of a lynch. So

Kill Twiggy

I doubt I'll have any more input before the phase ends, but I'll see what I can do
 
Just want to say that I like Drewbie's response further up on this page. I like how he brought up other players without being asked about them.
jdthebud said:
@Superjolt:
Drewbie - seems townish to me as he has provided some pretty good reasoning for his flip-flop vote onto Zehn, but waiting until the EoD seems to suggest he was biding his time a bit, which I think is scummy.
Bact - She never actually voted for Bard, but that seemed to give herself a way to pull back on the FOS if no one else went along with it. Plus I don't like her reluctance to share her "hunches". I wouldn't mind her being shot.
Ullion - He claimed to have a gun early on in D1, which I like, although Alex did the same. In any case, he's still acting townie to me.
GP - He's been posting a lot, and did cast the first vote for Twiggy, which I like. Slight town lean.
Click to expand...
Totally agree about Bact, I mean what kind of townie goes and says "oh you're killing me maybe? guess I just won't help you then"?
Anything else from GP you've liked so far? Who else are you scum reading now? Thoughts on Mars?
Mars? said:
I doubt that they would shoot a normal gun early tbh. They would probably wait until they can find a good justification for shooting. As for the vote, I'm not really suspicious of anyone else atm, but I wanted to give Twiggy a chance to defend himself. However, it doesn't look like he'll be here at this point...
[Kill] Twiggy
Click to expand...
Mars, what do you think about Green, Elektra Heart and jd?
Nakuzami said:
snip
Click to expand...
Naku, what do you think about Bac and her response further up on this page?
CatmanDaTrainer said:
[SHOOT] Twiggy

Noi noi vern...
Click to expand...
Catman, who else do you find suspicious?
 
Superjolt said:
Mars, what do you think about Green, Elektra Heart and jd?
Click to expand...
Green: I'm not sure about him tbh. His lack of content was suspicious, but he acknowledged that fact and said that he was available for questioning, which is a good sign (I have no idea what to ask him though).

jd: Hasn't said much recently, but he did diverge from the Bartwagon and ask for scum reads. (Note: He also made an interesting proposal about sparing Twiggy, but I'm not sure if we can trust the claim.)

Elektra Heart: I didn't see anything wrong with her recent defense...except for that last part. It looked like she's giving herself an excuse to stay silent.
 
drewbie411 said:
Ok, here we go guys. Ullion, please follow up on this. (if you want to of course)

https://www.strawpoll.me/10716990
Click to expand...
A strawpoll? The effort is definitely appreciated, but-
> Voting on strawpoll is anonymous
> People can make multiple votes iirc

Basically, a single scum can manipulate the results in their favor. Voting should be kept in the thread.
 
Mars? said:
A strawpoll? The effort is definitely appreciated, but-
> Voting on strawpoll is anonymous
> People can make multiple votes iirc

Basically, a single scum can manipulate the results in their favor. Voting should be kept in the thread.
Click to expand...

First point is true, but I changed it so you can only vote once.
 
Anon voting is OK, and getting rid of multiple votes per person fixes any other issue.
Now whether we're allowed to make strawpolls in game I have no idea. XD

If I have a real gun, I'm quite worried I'll be killed tonight. :/

Also, I had an idea last day phase - but I'm pretty sure now I know who gave me my gun (whether it's FAB'd or not is another story...)
 
Ullion said:
Anon voting is OK, and getting rid of multiple votes per person fixes any other issue.
Now whether we're allowed to make strawpolls in game I have no idea. XD

If I have a real gun, I'm quite worried I'll be killed tonight. :/

Also, I had an idea last day phase - but I'm pretty sure now I know who gave me my gun (whether it's FAB'd or not is another story...)
Click to expand...
True...but it'd be better if people could provide the reasoning behind their vote in the thread.
Strawpolls definitely aren't allowed. Prepare to get modkilled, Drewbie

And you made a good point there, Alex claimed to have a gun and got killed N1, so assuming that yours is legit, you might be the next target.

Interesting...please explain, any lead would be appreciated.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top