Mafia Madness: Guns [Game Over]

[ジュナイパー]

I know that there isn't a bandwagon. I'm just trying to save my own hide by tying the votes against me and the votes against Bac.

 

[Lycanthropy]

Catman stood out. No way this was going wrong, vests didn't seem to exist or simply not work. He aimed his gun for one of those people who always look scummy. But damn...

​

Elektra Heart as ???
Mana as ???
honey as ???
TheCapsFan as ???
Ullion as ???
Superjolt as ???
Nakuzami as ???
Mars™ as ???
JohnnyMustang II as ???
CatmanDaTrainer as ???
GreenLegend56 as ???
JohnnyMustang as a Villager [N0]
Davepetasprite^2 as a Villager [D1]
Zehn as a Villager [D1]
alexkaz61 as Mafia [N2]
Desinishon as a Villager [D2]
Klippy as a Villager [D2]
Twiggy as a Villager [D2]
drewbie411 as a Villager [N2]
jdthebud as Mafia [D3]
gimmepie as Mafia [D3]
Bardothren as a Villager [D3]

FIRST HI

Love me some guns :) in!

I am so in.

yes please

Yeah, I guess I could play. <3

Sight was already great, no way I'm missing this one!

I guess I want to shoot people?

/in

I gotta give Alex his rematch so I'm in :P

Must. Shoot. PEOPLE!

I mean, I can pull the trigger if you want me to? ;) I'm in!

Vote: Twiggy

We'll see if this will let slide, if not feel free to delete it but I dont want to die considering I'm coming back today.

More death, yay!

 

[Mars]

I know that there isn't a bandwagon. I'm just trying to save my own hide by tying the votes against me and the votes against Bac.

What do you mean? Are hammers a thing in this game?

 

[ジュナイパー]

First of all, what the heck just happened.

Second of all, who tried to shoot me?!

 

[Superjolt]

Thanks Lycan! It's funny too because literally not even two minutes after I made my last post, PC went down again for about 10-15 minutes xD

Now I find this a curious post. And when I say curious, I mean in contrast to any other post this day phase, I find it the most scummy.

Kind of agree. Ullion, is there a reason you skipped over my question about Mars? Do you want me to post the reasons for my scum reads?

I know that there isn't a bandwagon. I'm just trying to save my own hide by tying the votes against me and the votes against Bac.

Someone's not paying attention to the votes

But hmmm, that shot on Bard makes me wonder...

 

[ジュナイパー]

What do you mean? Are hammers a thing in this game?

Hammers?

Two people voted for me, and two people (including me) voted for Bac. Therefore no one dies.

I want to believe Catman is scum, I really do. His reasonings are bad and he's supporting Bard's random lynch, but that shot seems like it came from the Illusionist.

And I really don't see Catman making the risky move of shooting and claiming it was the Illusionist; it's just not in his character, especially when he's under fire. He seems genuinely confused and unless he's being directed by the other mafia, his confusion is legitimate as far as I'm concerned.

 

[Superjolt]

Hammers?

Two people voted for me, and two people (including me) voted for Bac. Therefore no one dies.


*image snip*

Johnny changed his vote, so nope :P (and Bard was the other vote and just died anyway)

How about some actual reads Catman?

 

[ジュナイパー]

First things first, [SHOOT] No One.

I do have a minor suspicion on Naku. She's usually making a whole bunch of scum/townreads and speculations, but she's only posted four times this entire game. I don't know if this is just her being a pacifist or what.

 

[Ullion]

Kind of agree. Ullion, is there a reason you skipped over my question about Mars? Do you want me to post the reasons for my scum reads?

Would you kindly direct me to which post you are referring to? <3

Also, I did get a single vest last night. I could always try shooting... but like I said Cat is the only one I find (even slightly) scummy. :/

 

[Nakuzami]

Oh, hey look I was right

I haven't been online much at all, which is why I haven't been posting. I'm the one who shot gimmepie, though, so you're welcome. It was my Sharpshooter shot, which is why I questioned if there could be more than one when Bard shot, but I wasn't dumb enough to shoot him with that as my "evidence."

Anyways, I have to catch up on the last three pages now.

 

[Mana1]

Eep I got a poke.

[lynch] CatmanDaTrainer

I don't think that the mafia would bother taking out a known inno with (now) no role. Seems like a waste of a once-in-a-game ability to me.

 

[TheCapsFan]

[UNVOTE]: Nakuzami

Good enough for me. Also Mars, there are no hammers.

As for Catman...either he did shoot Bard and is trying to cover up (if so he's doing a bad job of it) or the Illusionist happened. Regardless Mana, I don't think I understand your vote.

 

[Nakuzami]

It could have been their way of making sure they didn't hit another vested person, although Bard could have been bluffing about that in the first place. Obviously, he wasn't, but either way . . . it does seem a waste to use the Illusionist's skill just to get rid of him. Unless they assumed that he shot either GP or JD and did it in retaliation, which also would have been a bad play regardless.

But also given the post Catman made immediately before the gunshot went off, I find it unlikely that he would have shot Bard, since that would only increase his chances of being lynched either way.

For now, I'm going to leave that incident be. I'm sure something else will slip regarding it sooner or later.

I do find it a bit suspicious that Ullion keeps mentioning his gun, but has yet to shoot it. Some of his other posts have me put off slightly.

Additionally, GreenLegend suggested that the Illusionist could be dead, voted Catman, and then those two things apparently seem to have crossed over. If Catman is innocent, it's possible Green is not, but that could also have been a setup.

I have to go, and likely won't be on until after the phase has already ended, so for now I'm going to go with that slight theory against Green. I don't expect anyone to follow me on this right now, and I would prefer that people come up with other marks in the meantime anyways.

Kill GreenLegend56

 

[dad]

is there a chance that bard was fabbed and tried to shoot at cat but it backfired? jokes, i think i read that wrong

 

[Ullion]

I do find it a bit suspicious that Ullion keeps mentioning his gun, but has yet to shoot it. Some of his other posts have me put off slightly.

So to be honest, whenever I have a gun I LOVE to shoot someone. However I don't want to:
a) Hit an innocent (and possible cause situation b)
b) Come off as suss and get lynched

I'm also always bringing up the idea of shooting someone to get different signs and reads and responses from different players. :) For example, as soon as you posted that I shouldn't shoot Bac, I got a good town feel from you - which is usually opposite as to how I usually end up perceiving you in games.

 

[Superjolt]

[UNVOTE]: Nakuzami

Good enough for me. Also Mars, there are no hammers.

As for Catman...either he did shoot Bard and is trying to cover up (if so he's doing a bad job of it) or the Illusionist happened. Regardless Mana, I don't think I understand your vote.

CapsFan, I want to hear your thoughts on other players now

Would you kindly direct me to which post you are referring to? <3

Also, I did get a single vest last night. I could always try shooting... but like I said Cat is the only one I find (even slightly) scummy. :/

I asked here. I just want your general thoughts on Mars right now?

Eep I got a poke.

[lynch] CatmanDaTrainer

I don't think that the mafia would bother taking out a known inno with (now) no role. Seems like a waste of a once-in-a-game ability to me.

Mana what do you think about CapsFan?

If you're gonna shoot someone, shoot honey or Mana. And I'd suggest we lynch one of those two, no one else seems scummy at this point, plus we know for a fact that those two just lay low during the game.

Johnny what do you think about GreenLegend and CapsFan?

Spoiler:

It could have been their way of making sure they didn't hit another vested person, although Bard could have been bluffing about that in the first place. Obviously, he wasn't, but either way . . . it does seem a waste to use the Illusionist's skill just to get rid of him. Unless they assumed that he shot either GP or JD and did it in retaliation, which also would have been a bad play regardless.

But also given the post Catman made immediately before the gunshot went off, I find it unlikely that he would have shot Bard, since that would only increase his chances of being lynched either way.

For now, I'm going to leave that incident be. I'm sure something else will slip regarding it sooner or later.

I do find it a bit suspicious that Ullion keeps mentioning his gun, but has yet to shoot it. Some of his other posts have me put off slightly.

Additionally, GreenLegend suggested that the Illusionist could be dead, voted Catman, and then those two things apparently seem to have crossed over. If Catman is innocent, it's possible Green is not, but that could also have been a setup.

I have to go, and likely won't be on until after the phase has already ended, so for now I'm going to go with that slight theory against Green. I don't expect anyone to follow me on this right now, and I would prefer that people come up with other marks in the meantime anyways.

Kill GreenLegend56

I've been suspicious of GreenLegend too. I think he's scummy for other reasons though. I know you said you might not be on before the day ends, but if you get the chance, I'd like to know what you think about CapsFan and Mars

 

[Ullion]

I said it at some earlier point, but I don't have many scum reads on anyone. If I have town reads - I usually state them pretty early (I believe I mentioned town reading naku and johnny already - if I haven't... well I have now). If I don't mention someone specifically, it's probably because i'm 50/50 on them and don't know. Tbh I'm leaning towards Bac being town as well.

My biggest doubts (atm) are on Catman. Mars and Green I'm unsure of - but I'll try keeping a closer eye on them. :)

 

[Mars]

I have mixed feelings about Catman tbh. The illusionist would be more likely to pin a shot on someone with a confirmed gun rather than someone who already had the risk of getting lynched. On the other hand, Catman wasn't the first person to mention the illusionist, which is a good sign imo.

 

[Superjolt]

...almost 12 hours went by without a post?

At this point, I want to lynch somewhere in CapsFan, honey and Mana. I could lynch Green if it came down to it.

CapsFan hasn't done anything to make me think he's town. Literally the most he's done this game is vote for Twiggy (who was inno) and express suspicion of Naku (who claimed to shoot GP). I understand if he's busy, but I feel like he's intentionally trying to stay under the radar

Honey is in the same boat, but she's done even less than CapsFan, so yeah... That's not the only thing that bothers me though - part of me thinks she's playing dumb or something with a few things she has said, and I don't like the way GP talked about her.

Mana is kind of the same too... he hasn't done anything to make me think he's town either. I know he's not usually the most vocal player, but I get the same feeling from him that I get from CapsFan - he's intentionally staying under the radar

snip

Mars, who is in your lynch pool for today?

I'm null on Green right now, but Naku is making sense about him. I've got a slight scum read on Caps though. That move about trying to put pressure on Naku doesn't sound like him at all, more like, "I need an excuse before I get thrown onto suspicious"

Johnny you mentioned suspicion of Mana, honey and CapsFan but you're still voting for Catman. Why haven't you changed your vote?

 

[Mars]

is there a chance that bard was fabbed and tried to shoot at cat but it backfired? jokes, i think i read that wrong

...Do you have any thoughts on the current issue?