Map Rating/Review Thread

[Mages4ever]

https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/2988184076/ important an event happens in the bottom part of the map

Same as before , but a little better.
The tiles don't match.
2.5/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

Just a random map for rating.

Map: Clicky
Map of: Fire Red
Map Name: N/A - just a little route.
Comments: N/A

 

[4th Gen Matt]

Ivory Town, the first town in the game. The Upper path leads to Route 1 and the path to the right will be blocked off by police until you beat the game, which then will lead to a route, which leads to a cave, which leads to a legendary Pokemon. Rate it please.

Route 1. I need to add a bit of flowers here. Otherwise, how does it look?

 

[-DarK-]

Map name: RouteX2

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Map name: Tropiscent City
Base rom: Firered English (BPRE)
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Mapshot:

Notes: You come out from a canyon. There is a boat pier on the right and a beach too. The palms are just for decoration. The "special house" is a coctail bar.
Credits: WAH for palm trees

 

[Nytkoi]

Map name: Tropiscent City
Base rom: Firered English (BPRE)
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Notes: You come out from a canyon. There is a boat pier on the right and a beach too. The palms are just for decoration. The "special house" is a coctail bar.
Credits: WAH for palm trees

Quite good, I like the new mountian pallete and mountain, but There's something about having a ton of small houses that make it averge, but the mountain, gym place, and beaches/sand are great.

8.5/10 - Good

Map Name: Oakwood Town

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: The first town =D Sorry for grid thing =[

 

[lanon12]

Map name: Tropiscent City
Base rom: Firered English (BPRE)
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Mapshot:
I cant post :(
Notes: You come out from a canyon. There is a boat pier on the right and a beach too. The palms are just for decoration. The "special house" is a coctail bar.
Credits: WAH for palm trees

This map is very good, because I like the gym,sand,bridge,sea is quite beautiful

9-10

 

[Likewise]

nytkoi

hmm....
5/10 i like the shape of the map but it is a bit over........well detailed there are also a few tile errors
also you put in little useless things like those bushes the flowers etc.

Okay so this is cratora town, it is a major mining landmark and because of the gold here so decades ago mining families migrated here thus the great population.


credit to mitchel1 for the rom base!

 

[Disturbed]

nytkoi

hmm....
5/10 i like the shape of the map but it is a bit over........well detailed there are also a few tile errors
also you put in little useless things like those bushes the flowers etc.

Okay so this is cratora town, it is a major mining landmark and because of the gold here so decades ago mining families migrated here thus the great population.


credit to mitchel1 for the rom base!

Map rating form:
Tiles: 1/1 -Good use of tiles
Shape: 1/2 - Poor shape
Errors: 0/3 -More than 10 tile errors spotted
Space Used: 2/3 Some empty areas throughout the map
Complexity: 0/1
Total: 4/10 Poor

 

[Tyrantrum]

Just a random map for rating.

Map: Clicky
Map of: Fire Red
Map Name: N/A - just a little route.
Comments: N/A

I'm gonna repost my map. :D
I knew I'd get skipped though, but oh well~

 

[Disturbed]

@ Wind~

Map rating form:
Tiles: 1 /1 Good use of tiles
Shape: 2/2 Original Shape
Errors: 3/3 0 Tile errors spotted
Space Used: 3/3 Filled completely
Complexity: 0/1 Needs elements besides trees and grass.

Total: 9/10 -Fantastic

Find the Map Rating Form in my sig.

 

[DarkShadow]

Map Name: Twinleaf
Hack: Pokemon Sinnoh Legacy
ROM: Fire red

Comment: i like version of my map so what do you think

Map Name: Meeting room
Hack: Pokemon Sinnoh Legacy
ROM: Fire red

Comment: Rough of the meeting ROM i talked about for our hack

 

[Disturbed]

Map Name: Twinleaf
Hack: Pokemon Sinnoh Legacy
ROM: Fire red

Comment: i like version of my map so what do you think

Map Name: Meeting room
Hack: Pokemon Sinnoh Legacy
ROM: Fire red

Comment: Rough of the meeting ROM i talked about for our hack

Tiles: 1 /1
Shape: 2/2 since it is a remake, the shape works
Errors: 1/3 6 errors spotted
Space Used: 3/3 Remake map: the space is the same as DP one
Complexity: 0/1 You could have added different features.

Near flawless remake map. Great job!
7/10 Good

Map 2:

Tiles: 1/1 Used well in this environment
Shape: 1/2 Could use decent walls
Errors: 1/3 5 errors spotted
Space Used: 1/3 Filled space in the middle would really help
Complexity: 1/1 Nice for a meeting room

5/10 Mediocre

 

[Pachel22]

Well time to come with a map XD.

Tiles are not changed because i'm not sure wich tiles I want in my hack XD.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Well time to come with a map XD.

Tiles are not changed because i'm not sure wich tiles I want in my hack XD.

The map is fairly poor.

There is no path, sometimes it's square and sometimes things repeat.

4/10 for placement of trees

 

[Pachel22]

Okay here is the adjusted one:

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Okay here is the adjusted one:

A little better.

Make the paths bigger and less straight.
Remove the number of rocks and bushes.
Make some tileset 2 houses!

6/10

 

[The Exorcist]

Feedback...

Feedback on this map...



Unusually unique, it's appearance is excellent, the tileset modifications were really well made and compiled, if I were to rate this out of 10, it would be a 10! I'd love to see more work like this from you!

 

[~Hot n' Cold~]

DarkShadow's Map Rating

Note: I WILL BE RATING EVERY MAP!
Well, at least the ones I can see.
@DarkShadow:

Twinleaf Town:

~Tile Use - 4/5 - Even less tile errors, almost perfect use of tiles~
~Shape - 2/5 - Very ugly shape, less square though, almost consistent border~
~Errors - 5/5 - No tile errors whatsoever, perfect use of water, mountains and grass~
~Space Used - 1/5 - 30+ Tiles of plain grass with no tiles on it, very empty with slim to none of anything interesting~
~Complexity - 1/5 - Easy to get through~

Overall Rating:
~13/25 - Unacceptable~

Meeting Room:

~Tile Use - 3/5 - Average amount of tile errors, no water errors, much better use of tiles~
~Shape - 1/5 - Very bad shape, completely square, no consistent border~
~Errors - 4/5 - 1+ Tile errors~
~Space Used - 1/5 - 30+ Tiles of plain flooring, with no tiles, slim to none of anything interesting~
~Complexity - 1/5 - Easy to get through~

Overall Rating:
~10/25 - Lackluster~

 

[Nytkoi]

^
I Thinkthere's a little too much going on in you map, and the mountain and waterfall aren't 'needed.'
5.5/10 Mediocore

Map Name: Route 331
Map Game: Firered

Comments; I think this map looks pretty well done, but Im not sure about how much flowers and bushes I should put... Mabye you guys can help out? Thanks.