Map Rating/Review Thread

[~Hot n' Cold~]

Nytkoi's Map Rating

@Nytkoi

Route 331

~Tile Use - 5/5 - Perfect use of tiles~
~Shape - 5/5 - Perfect shape, completely unsquare, excellent amounts of mountains, rocks, hedges, bushes and flowers~
~Errors - 5/5 - No tile errors whatsoever~
~Space Used - 4/5 - Great use of land~
~Complexity - 5/5 - Very complex, great use of mountains~

Overall Rating:
~24/25 - Perfect~

You used perfect amounts of flowers and bushes, don't worry about it.

 

[Chimchar 9]

Map Name: Twinleaf
Hack: Pokemon Sinnoh Legacy
ROM: Fire red

Comment: i like version of my map so what do you think

Map Name: Meeting room
Hack: Pokemon Sinnoh Legacy
ROM: Fire red

Comment: Rough of the meeting ROM i talked about for our hack

first you could of gave credit !!
there is tile errors on the path,i think that path is alittle to thick apart from that it looks good
6/10
p.s - you could add a little more stuff to it .

 

[Pachel22]

People what about this one:

 

[~Hot n' Cold~]

Pachel's Map Rating

@Pachel

Unknown Village Map

~Tile Use - 5/5 - Perfect use of tiles~
~Shape - 4/5 - Great shape, almost completely unsquare, fair amount of rocks~
~Errors - 3/5 - 5+ Tile errors, likely found in ponds and on trees~
~Space Used - 3/5 - 20+ tiles of plain grass with not many items of interest on map~
~Complexity - 3/5 - Harder than normal villages to get through~

Overall Rating:
~18/25 - Good~

 

[bugsbunny]

Map Name: Battle Frontier Main Island
Hack of FireRed and/or a game
Comments: Made in Photoshop, since I work on a Mac.
Credits go to Forgotten Memory for the Pokemon Center and Pokemart.

 

[~Hot n' Cold~]

@bugsbunny

Battle Frontier Main Island

~Tile Use - 5/5 - Wonderful use and combination of FireRed, Emerald, and D/P Tiles~
~Shape - 5/5 - Beautiful shape on the island, perfect use of trees and tree shadows~
~Errors - 4/5 - I only spot 4 tile errors, and there is proper use of water~
~Space Used - 5/5 - Everywhere there is something interesting~
~Complexity - 5/5 - Everything is spread out, and it takes a while to walk from place to place~

Overall Rating:
~24/25 - Perfect~

 

[bugsbunny]

Map Name: Grand Festival Island
Hack of: FireRed and/or game
Credits go to Forgotten Memory for Pokécenter and Pokémart.
Comments: Made in Photoshop

 

[~Hot n' Cold~]

Bugsbunny's Map Rating

@bugsbunny

Grand Festival Island

~Tile Use - 5/5 - Perfect use of tiles, and mix of FireRed and D/P Sprites~
~Shape - 5/5 - Great shape with the combination of water and trees~
~Errors - 4/5 - I only see 2 tile errors~
~Space Used - 5/5 - Everywhere on the map, there is something interesting to do~
~Complexity - 5/5 - Very complex and hard to get around~

Overall Rating:
~24/25 - Perfect~

 

[Mimey]

Map name: Route 901
Hackname: None (Just a map)
Credits: DarkZeroONE & KyleDove
Comments: If your wondering why all those logs are there, well a (Don't know how to call it) a wood chopper? Hahaha sorry for the bad English xP

 

[thethethethe]

Well a fair amount of boredom + realising I haven't made a map in a fair amount of time led me to this.
Map Name: Don't have one as of yet.
Game: FR, but I don't see why that matters.
Comments: Connection at the top, and I'm too lazy to change tiles for just one map.

Spoiler:

 

[4th Gen Matt]

I really like your map Mimey. I am not good at critiquing though, so I will leave it to the professionals.

Anyway, another map here to rate. Hopefully this time =)

Map Name: Mauve Town

I wasn't sure where to place the flowers. Let me know. =)

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

I will repost my maps...

New map!
Game: Pokemon Turquoise
Base rom: Firered English (BPRE)
Name: Flower Hills
Mapshot:

Comments: I guess nothing; You come from up to down
Credits: Nintendo for flowers and small trees

Map name: Tropiscent City
Base rom: Firered English (BPRE)
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Mapshot:

Notes: You come out from a canyon. There is a boat pier on the right and a beach too. The palms are just for decoration. The "special house" is a coctail bar.
Credits: WAH for palm trees

 

[Mimey]

@ thethethe:

Great map, perhaps you could fill up the empty space at the top of the map.

 

[Binary]

I really like your map Mimey. I am not good at critiquing though, so I will leave it to the professionals.

Anyway, another map here to rate. Hopefully this time =)

Map Name: Mauve Town

I wasn't sure where to place the flowers. Let me know. =)

Rating: 8/10
Reason: It's a pleasant map. But what I don't like about it is that the trees on the left are in a straight line and not spread out. Try to spread out the trees more. There is some emptiness in the map. And I don't like the joint PC and mart. Besides that, the map looks pretty good.
Suggestions: Just take care of what I said above.

Well a fair amount of boredom + realising I haven't made a map in a fair amount of time led me to this.
Map Name: Don't have one as of yet.
Game: FR, but I don't see why that matters.
Comments: Connection at the top, and I'm too lazy to change tiles for just one map.

Spoiler:

Rating:9.5/10
Reason: As always, you always make good maps. I can't say anything bad about your map. I like the hill-like structure, it looks really nice. But there is one thing I'd like to point out. Notice the big trees? the ground/grass or whatever you call it under the tree has a darker pallete compared to the original grass. But your map is really nice.

I will repost my maps...

Flower hills-
Rating: 9/10
Reason: I like the map, the structure of the map and the placement of the trees, grass and paths. Everything counts when you're looking at a map. But I don't like the vertical ledges at the bottom of the map. It doesn't look that good. And another thing, not relative to the map but the pallete of the tree is abit too light, don't you think? Well maybe it's just me. Nice map though.
Suggestions: read the "reason" and take in mind..

Tropiscent City
Rating: 8.5/10
Reason: Yeah it really does look tropical and I like the name XD. I like the idea of the gym in the middle. And overall the map is pretty nice.
Suggestions: Hmm add some more layers of mountains on top of the original ones. I think it will come out a bit more canyon-like. I don't like the pallete of the Palm tree. It should have a real tropical pallete.

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Well a fair amount of boredom + realising I haven't made a map in a fair amount of time led me to this.
Map Name: Don't have one as of yet.
Game: FR, but I don't see why that matters.
Comments: Connection at the top, and I'm too lazy to change tiles for just one map.

Spoiler:

Well as everybody seems to love your map, I have to be honest I don't like it so much..
Here's my rating: The placement of the trees is pretty blocky, you should change it a little so it lookd more natural, the same goes for the rock walls, it is just to blocky.. And the fences are a bit unnececary, but I don't care about that I do it myself to sometimes ;) The grass is placed neatly and I like how you have to go up and down the stairs to go further :) Further I like the overall.. My rating: 7/10

 

[Team Magic Tyson]

The trop city looks very neat.

How to improve: Take them rocks out of sea, they don't look right.

/Tyson

 

[Mimey]

Map name: Route 901
Hackname: None (Just a map)
Credits: DarkZeroONE & KyleDove
Comments: If your wondering why all those logs are there, well a (Don't know how to call it) a wood chopper? Hahaha sorry for the bad English xP Oh and the bridges still need work :P

Reposting my map :P
Please, rate and comment.. C+C is welcome

 

[Hiche..]

Well a fair amount of boredom + realising I haven't made a map in a fair amount of time led me to this.
Map Name: Don't have one as of yet.
Game: FR, but I don't see why that matters.
Comments: Connection at the top, and I'm too lazy to change tiles for just one map.

Spoiler:

Well, the mountain border is parallel to each other, which is not nice. The house bothers me. I like the placement of grass, and the shape of the beach looks very good. The safari trees, don't really like them.
Rating: 7.4/10

 

[Likewise]

okay before i get destroyed by comments saying the tiles are really overused, i made this map because its snowing outside xD and that i haven't seen many snow maps posted here lately

credit to Neti for the rom base

 

[DarkShadow]

Map: Sandgem
Rom: Fired red
Commets: this is a rough of my sandgem i dont have the proper tiles right now but thats my temp