Map Rating/Review Thread

[MudMast]

Here we go:
Map Name: Twinleaf Town
Hack Name: Pokémon Alpha
Hack Of: Pokémon Ruby

Own Comments: Few custom tiles, trees from Firered and inserted by me, not too sure about the extra houses, and I think its a bit too cluttered. (The left side is on the edge of border)

 

[/Circa]

Name: Dorfin Town
Information: It's the first town of my hack, I wanted it to be beachy but not so small aswell. So thats why alot of the trees are scattered etc.
Map:

Spoiler:

 

[Surf]

Name: Azalea Town
Information: This is from a back to the past event from my hack Pokemon Omega
Map:

 

[пзо]

Pokemon Obsidian Starter Town

Its time for my comeback. Presenting Pokemon Obsidian.. Starter Town.
Map of Firered.
Hope this map gives me atleast a 8/10.
Town Name Undecided..

 

[Makorin]

Its time for my comeback. Presenting Pokemon Obsidian.. Starter Town.
Map of Firered.
Hope this map gives me atleast a 8/10.
Town Name Undecided..

Spoiler:

hmm... I think i'll give it...
a 7.9/10 XD

Okay for real this time...
I'll give you;

Spoiler:

Shape: 4/5 Great
Building Placement: 5/5 Awesome
Physical Features Placement: 3/5 Good
Water Shape: 4/5 Great
Playibility: 5/5 Awesome
Tile Errors: 5/5 Awsome
My Feelings 4/5 Great
Total: 8.6/10 86% B- :D

Why?:
Shape can be better it doesnt look to great going on a diagonal [left side]
Building Placement aren't 100% perfect slightly changing it won't be bad.
Physical Features kinda look weird [bushes, trees are fine] Rocks sorta out of place by the stone tower.
Water Shape could be better... don't know how to help
Playibility Is 99.9% perfect [i never give 100% perfect]
I see no Tile Errors
My Feelings are that with Events it may be fun to play on this map!

 

[Braeden23000]

Map Name - Route 24
Map Game - Ruby

 

[Pokepal17]

Map Name: Regi Isle
ROM: Fire Red
Credits to Mew_Ryn, Forgotten Memory, Kyledove for the ROM Base

Note: The two cave entrances near the tower lead to each other. Same goes for two others.



@Braeden2300

It's really good.
However there is a tile error and the waterfall is in the wrong place. It is at the bottom but it should be at the top because water naturally flows downwards.

Overall great - 8/10

 

[пзо]

Hiche Route 1

Hallo. I have another one. The Difference is that this is for Hiche's upcomming hack.
Route 1.
(Fire Red)

Comment how you like. I wanna improve this.

 

[sasquatchd00d]

Hallo. I have another one. The Difference is that this is for Hiche's upcomming hack.
Route 1.
(Fire Red)

Spoiler:

Comment how you like. I wanna improve this.

Natural Sense: 4/5 Good
Use of Tiles: 3/5 Average
Tile Errors: 3/5 Average
Map Shape: 5/5 Great
Playability: 3/5 Average
Map Rating: 72/100 C-

Comments: The first thing I noticed is that the hidden berry grass tile is way overused. There shouldn't be that many hidden items in a map of this size. If you're using them as alternate grass tiles, I'd advise using some of the other tiles provided. I'm not sure that there would be street lamps on a forested route like this. There are numerous tree shading errors. The paths are done nicely and the grass is placed quite well. The map seems to be one way, as you can't go back up the ledge in the left of the map.

 

[Visored]

Hallo. I have another one. The Difference is that this is for Hiche's upcomming hack.
Route 1.
(Fire Red)

Comment how you like. I wanna improve this.

6/10
The map is way too cramped, space it out a little, you bunched a lot of bushes and trees together. and you have used 3 different path tiles. and dont use the hidden grass tiles that much. bunch the grass a little more, it looks patchy and bad. not bad tho.

 

[Makorin]

Hallo. I have another one. The Difference is that this is for Hiche's upcomming hack.
Route 1.
(Fire Red)

Spoiler:

Comment how you like. I wanna improve this.

Gonna use my rating system that i used last time!

Spoiler:

Shape: 4.5/5 Super
Building Placement: 0/0 No Buildings
Physical Features Placement: 5/5 Nice
Water Shape: 0/0 No Water
Playibility: 5/5 Awesome
Tile Errors: 4.9/5 Super
My Feelings 4.9/5 Super
Total: 9.7/10 97% A :D

Why?: Shape is nice Tweeking it won't hurt
The bushes and flowers are spaced out nicely and Trees in center have nice spacing
I would like playing this map for i give it 5 for playibility
Tiles Errors None that I see but i think the pathes can be done better and the grass tile that have berrys (atleast in Fr/Lg) well there are to many of them...
I Feel that this map shows nice work of yours i really like the lampposts! :D

 

[Disturbed]

Well, I'm back with a map I made in under 10 minutes. ;D
This isn't for a hack or anything, so up for grabs (make sure you tell me if you are going to use it so there isn't multiple hacks with it)

Spoiler:

It's supposed to be generic, simple, and nice and smooth ;D

 

[~Teh Panda~]

I was bored I had time, I mapped

Oh yes TY visual for rom base

 

[Surf]

I was bored I had time, I mapped

Oh yes TY visual for rom base

Vey good Tehtehtehteh good tree placement and the grass doesn't looked cramped.
The only thing that bugs me is that the grass is used way too much
I'll give a 7/10

Well, I'm back with a map I made in under 10 minutes. ;D
This isn't for a hack or anything, so up for grabs (make sure you tell me if you are going to use it so there isn't multiple hacks with it)

Spoiler:

It's supposed to be generic, simple, and nice and smooth ;D

I like the generic style maps they give a good visual feel when playing a hack.
Okay I'll give a 8\10 because the grass under the trees kinda bugs me
I IZ UZING DAT MAP TANKS LUZ


And now my map:

Obviosly not done yet i still have to rip some more tiles from gold but this is the genneral idea of the map
NOT MAPPED IN GOLD
mapped in Firered

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Vey good Tehtehtehteh good tree placement and the grass doesn't looked cramped.
The only thing that bugs me is that the grass is used way too much
I'll give a 7/10



I like the generic style maps they give a good visual feel when playing a hack.
Okay I'll give a 8\10 because the grass under the trees kinda bugs me
I IZ UZING DAT MAP TANKS LUZ


And now my map:

Obviosly not done yet i still have to rip some more tiles from gold but this is the genneral idea of the map
NOT MAPPED IN GOLD
mapped in Firered

Very nice remake, thx for the rating, I rate your map 8.5/10 looks exact, yet I am still a bit skeptical about people using "past" tiles

 

[Geeked]

Map Game: Fire Red (Crimson)
Map Time: On and off Between 4:18 PM & 10:07 PM Eastern
Comments: Defiantly somewhere in Early Crimson
Map Shot:

 

[/Circa]

Name: Dorfin Town
Information: It's the first town of my hack, I wanted it to be beachy but not so small aswell. So thats why alot of the trees are scattered etc.
Map:

Spoiler:

I got skipped, so i'll put the text in big bold letters >;]

 

[Surf]

I got skipped, so i'll put the text in big bold letters >;]

Sorry
Big TEXT FOR A BIG MAP
NICE PLACEMENT OF TILES BUT IT LOOKS A LITTLE EMPTY

 

[Hiche..]

Map Game: Fire Red (Crimson)
Map Time: On and off Between 4:18 PM & 10:07 PM Eastern
Comments: Defiantly somewhere in Early Crimson
Map Shot:

Very nice map, Xray. However, I see tree-shading errors.
Rating: 9.4/10

 

[Pokepal17]

This is going to be the starting town and Route 1 for my hack. It is my first ever route so please rate both maps and comment.
The starting town also has events showing.

Rom: Fire Red

Starting Town - Wilderbud Town



Route 1



So please comment on them and rate :)