Map Rating/Review Thread

[Pokepal17]

Map Name: Inshika Town
Game: Pokémon Island Mystery: Torn Shadows
Comments: As you may know, me and Marxvile decided to re-start IM on Ruby. But I have never mapped on Ruby before. So here was my shot it the starter town, enjoy xD

I really like, but there is a bit where it looks bare. Still 8/10

I was just scribbling on paper and made world maps.
This was what I made(just aesthetics, no playability).



Also, no one rated this map either. I would prefer if no one skipped me this time.
https://img132.imageshack.us/img132/589/seran.png

10/10, the world mpa looks great

Map Name: City 2 (Unnamed)

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Just a town/city without a gym

Mapshot: See attachment.

Really like, I'll give it a 9/10

U guys and girls missed me
Map Name: Mushi town
Map Game: Fire red
Comments: This is the second place you visit in my hack

Mapshot: See attachments

Erm I'm gonna give it a 7/10 One of the paths doesn't look right :\

Now please rate my map.
Game: Pokemon Fire Red
Hack: Pokemon Infernal Legend
Map Name: Magma City
Credits: Me, Kyledove, Synyster_Zeikku, Green Charizard and Zel

Spoiler:

 

[Sweet Jasmine]

U guys and girls missed me
Map Name: Mushi town
Map Game: Fire red
Comments: This is the second place you visit in my hack

Mapshot: See attachments
Attached Thumbnails

It's a kinda square and too empty. but i'll give you 6/10.

Now please rate my map.
Game: Pokemon Fire Red
Hack: Pokemon Infernal Legend
Map Name: Magma City
Credits: Me, Kyledove, Synyster_Zeikku, Green Charizard and Zel

Spoiler:

Is this Pokemon Shiny Golds Tiles? Except the others.. Well ontopic~ It's a great city but you overused the lamps :P even it's a city. it still needs working.
So i'll give you 8/10.

 

[Logan]

Now please rate my map.
Game: Pokemon Fire Red
Hack: Pokemon Infernal Legend
Map Name: Magma City
Credits: Me, Kyledove, Synyster_Zeikku, Green Charizard and Zel

Spoiler:

Yeah well, I really like the size of this map. Everything is spaced out well and there really isn't much to improve on xD. Just one more thing, I like the amount of lamps you have put in, It shows that you understand how the lighting is needed in large cities, well done!

9/10

Reminder: I know I may be mini-modding here, but I don't see anyone else saying it. Guys, this is a map rating thread, not a tile or pallete rating thread. There is one of these somewhere else, if you want to rate tiles and pals go there. This is for rating maps!

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

Map Name: City 2 (Unnamed)

Map Game: Fire red

Comments: Just a town/city without a gym

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Great Map i love the tiles u used :) The mountains have a great shape ;) I'll give it 9,5/10

Map Name: Mushi town
Map Game: Fire red
Comments: This is the second place you visit in my hack

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

I like this Map :) It's natural and simple @the same time^^ But i don't like that u used just one tile of the grass... There are five different grass-tiles in FR/LG :/ however i'll give it 7/10 ;)

Now please rate my map.
Game: Pokemon Fire Red
Hack: Pokemon Infernal Legend
Map Name: Magma City
Credits: Me, Kyledove, Synyster_Zeikku, Green Charizard and Zel

Spoiler:

Great Map of a city :D I'm not a fan of making city-maps (I hate it :@) But you did well buddy :D The vegetation and the city-tiles harmonies nearly perfect :) I'll give it 9/10 because you used just one grass-tile, too :/

btw: Put it in a spoiler next time... It's too big

Now I'll show you why i hate this :( here is a city-map of me it's very old!

Map Name: Ville Rachad
Map Game: FireRed (GER)
Comments: Two months ago i made this map and i had no plan how to make it :/ I don't like this one... And i know there's anywhere a mapping-error... So you know this :)
Credits:
-Wesley FG
-Kyledove
-Hackrex

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Logan]

Spoiler:

Map Name: Ville Rachad
Map Game: FireRed (GER)
Comments: Two months ago i made this map and i had no plan how to make it :/ I don't like this one... And i know there's anywhere a mapping-error... So you know this :)
Credits:
-Wesley FG
-Kyledove
-Hackrex

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Okay now, you know I love your mapping and style. Well, it is nowhere near your best xD, everything seems a little too cramped, maybe space it out a bit :P

7.8/10

 

[Vrai]

Map Name: Ville Rachad
Map Game: FireRed (GER)
Comments: Two months ago i made this map and i had no plan how to make it :/ I don't like this one... And i know there's anywhere a mapping-error... So you know this :)
Credits:
-Wesley FG
-Kyledove
-Hackrex

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

I actually really, really like this map. The crowded-ness really gives it the feel of a big city; and, the fact that you basically produce alleyways by simply building placement is wonderful. I also like the general shape of the map, which is pleasing. As for criticism that the map is too crowded.. well, I cannot deny, it is quite crowded. However, there's still enough room for NPCs to walk about, and a big city map should be pretty decently crowded. I want to give an A on it.. so, I guess, 10/10. You've done excellently on this map. ^^

 

[Lightning Sage™]

Map name: Trio path
game name: Pokemon Evolution: Evil Unleashed(FireREd(E))
comments: I just made another route and want to see what everyone thinks
Map shot:

Spoiler:

 

[Sparkcaster]

Map name: ROUTE 1038
game name: Pokemon Death Spawn
comments: Just tell me how it looks and leave a rating
credits:Keyldove,WesleyFG and Alistar for tiles
Map shot:

Spoiler:

 

[NTA]

9/10
it looks pretty good i spotted a tile error the bottom right moutnain and another ight above where it overlaps the top of a tree

 

[Vrai]

Map name: ROUTE 1038
game name: Pokemon Death Spawn
comments: Just tell me how it looks
Map shot:

First of all, the grass is a big no-no. You've got it so the player only has to walk through two. The purpose of grass is to force the player to walk through it.. He'll never walk through it all if you don't force him into it. Secondly, vegetation doesn't grow sporadically. Most of the time, flowers and grass grow in groups, not in little sprinkles all across the meadow. The mountains aren't half bad, although I suggest some more action in the walls, and put less rocks in it.

If you work a little harder at it, this map could get better. For now, however, you get a 4/10 from me.

 

[Lightning Sage™]

I was skipped
Map name: Trio path
game name: Pokemon Evolution: Evil Unleashed(FireREd(E))
comments: I just made another route and want to see what everyone thinks
Map shot:

Spoiler:

 

[Sweet Jasmine]

I was skipped
Map name: Trio path
game name: Pokemon Evolution: Evil Unleashed(FireREd(E))
comments: I just made another route and want to see what everyone thinks
Map shot:

Spoiler:

This was a great map :3... But it's too empty 6/10

 

[Magneto20]

Map Name: Refia City
Map Game: Pokemon: WARPED (fire red)

Spoiler:

Please rate and be honest!

 

[thedootmaster]

map name LUDICOLSO TOWN
hack of Fire Red
This is my first map ever done and i could not get the pallette exact...
attatchment
https://img189.imageshack.us/my.php?image=ludicolsotown.png

 

[Samike360]

map name LUDICOLSO TOWN
hack of Fire Red
This is my first map ever done and i could not get the pallette exact...
attatchment
https://img189.imageshack.us/my.php?image=ludicolsotown.png

I'm going to give this town a 4/10. Basically, it might look pretty, but it needs some work. First of all it looks very square, fill in the corners and add some more trees here and there (the only trees are in lined up in rows in the border). Also, the window things on the bottom-right house look very off, I would suggest remaking that entire house. Last, the flowers look bad arranged in just one area, put them scattered throughout the map.

 

[kingfisher309]

Heres a quick route, bad tileset
i want to get hold of a D/P tileset for FR/LG
but ah well :)

name = Route 1
Game = None
Original Game = Firered
only a quick map
please rate

 

[kingfisher309]

Springvale

Map name = Springvale, Route 1, Route 2.

Hack name = Pokemon Springvale Legacies

Original Hack = Firered

Thanks to shinygold producers for the tiles
all credit for tiles goes to them.

my own maps, made by me with no help. please rate.

 

[Sparkcaster]

Map name: ZILCH TOWN
game name: Pokemon Death Spawn
comments: Just tell me how it looks and leave a rating
credits:Keyldove,WesleyFG and Alistar for tiles
Map shot:

Spoiler:

map name LUDICOLSO TOWN
hack of Fire Red
This is my first map ever done and i could not get the pallette exact...
attatchment
https://img189.imageshack.us/my.php?image=ludicolsotown.png

3/10
Reason:Its a plain map, its too square,a map full of empty spaces

Map name = Springvale, Route 1, Route 2.

Hack name = Pokemon Springvale Legacies

Original Hack = Firered

Thanks to shinygold producers for the tiles
all credit for tiles goes to them.

my own maps, made by me with no help. please rate.

6/10
Reason:Alot of empty spaces, its unnatural

 

[Spherical Ice]

Name: Camp Atoa - May Change
Game: FireRed
Notes: The stones bisecting the lake are stepping stones, and are passable. The pillar at the bottom of the map is a placeholder until I get a tile for a well. The only exit leads to woodlands:

Name: Atoa Woodlands
Game: FireRed
Notes: One question (which I'll post in the Map help thread as well), why are their connection problems ingame? When I go to exit, all I see the tile that has the top left tile of an ordinary tree above those yellow paths. Any help?

 

[Logan]

Map name = Springvale, Route 1, Route 2.

Hack name = Pokemon Springvale Legacies

Original Hack = Firered

Thanks to shinygold producers for the tiles
all credit for tiles goes to them.

my own maps, made by me with no help. please rate.

You've been told time and time again. STOP HACKING SHINYGOLD! 0/10.

Name: Camp Atoa - May Change
Game: FireRed
Notes: The stones bisecting the lake are stepping stones, and are passable. The pillar at the bottom of the map is a placeholder until I get a tile for a well. The only exit leads to woodlands:

Hmm... Everything seems just too squashed. Also, the placement of things just seems too un-natural, you should look at a few tuts ;) 5/10

Name: Atoa Woodlands
Game: FireRed
Notes: One question (which I'll post in the Map help thread as well), why are their connection problems ingame? When I go to exit, all I see the tile that has the top left tile of an ordinary tree above those yellow paths. Any help?

Same here really, everything is too squashed and very un-natural 5/10