Map Rating/Review Thread

[Samike360]

It looks as though some of you skipped my updated map a page or two back, I'm sorry if I seem impatient but I would really appreciate some criticism:

 

[MASTEROFPUPPETS93]

guys you forgot about my map..

Spoiler:

It's a nice map :D But it's too empty :/ Put some more trees in the empty space... And maybe do this huge lake a lil bit smaller... You did well with the path :D Goodies, i know it's a MRT but those path-palettes looks ugly in this dark palette :knockedou I'll give you for this one 7/10

 

[Surf]

Map name = Springvale, Route 1, Route 2.

Hack name = Pokemon Springvale Legacies

Original Hack = Firered

Thanks to shinygold producers for the tiles
all credit for tiles goes to them.

my own maps, made by me with no help. please rate.

You are NOT allowed to use the Shiny Gold tiles!!!!!
6.7\10

 

[Halcyon]

It looks as though some of you skipped my updated map a page or two back, I'm sorry if I seem impatient but I would really appreciate some criticism:

Rating: 6.5/10
Reasons: The beach looks square and the house and has a tile error.
The rock on the left seemed a bit off.

Rate mine pls!

Spoiler:

Map Name: Route 301
Map Game: Pokemon Aerial White (FireRed)
Comments: First route map for the game.


First post in this thread. =x

 

[Vrai]

Rating: 6.5/10
Reasons: The beach looks square and the house and has a tile error.
The rock on the left seemed a bit off.

Rate mine pls!

Spoiler:

Map Name: Route 301
Map Game: Pokemon Aerial White (FireRed)
Comments: First route map for the game.

Actually, it's not half bad. I don't really like how you basically cut off a square block-sort of area in the top left hand corner; you could remove the middle ledge, and make a few bends in the last one (or the first one, I dunno, I'm just going with how you would jump across them [R to L]) to make it look more interesting. The grass is placed in a sort of block-y style, which is nice. Also, the player has to walk through the grass to get through the map; another bonus point.

There seem to be a few aesthetic problems, although it's probably just in my eyes.. but good job, overall.

8.2/10.

 

[sasquatchd00d]

Oh hello Map Rating Thread. What an old friend you are.

Map Name: Forestria Village
ROM Base: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Xiros, Kyledove, rhevarhe_duh, Wesley FG, Saurav
Comments: To be honest, I did this map very quickly and for fun. ^_^

Mapshot:

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Map Name: Forestria Village
ROM Base: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Xiros, Kyledove, rhevarhe_duh, Wesley FG, Saurav
Comments: To be honest, I did this map very quickly and for fun. ^_^

Mapshot:

Like all of your maps it has great vegetation, good placement and nice path shapes.
It looks what a perfect map should look like!
9.5/10
For the same paths infont of houses, that I don't like.

 

[Mana1]

Hydro - 8/10
Its a nice simple route, however I don't like the straightness of the ledges or the path between the middle and right one.

Sas - 10/10
I love it, you put lots (not not too much) into what is essentially a small map and it looks perfect.
(Great choice of tiles too!)

 

[Magneto20]

I got skipped...

Map Name: Refia City
Map Game: Pokemon: WARPED (fire red)

Spoiler:

Please rate and be honest!

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

I got skipped...

Map Name: Refia City
Map Game: Pokemon: WARPED (fire red)

Spoiler:

Please rate and be honest!

Friend's rating:
I like the map!
11/10

Honest rating:
Though I can't spot any visible tile errors, the map is still square.
The paths should be less straight.
Also, why make such a big map when you can make it smaller? ;)
5/10

 

[Disturbed]

Map Name: Forestria Village
ROM Base: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Xiros, Kyledove, rhevarhe_duh, Wesley FG, Saurav
Comments: To be honest, I did this map very quickly and for fun. ^_^

Mapshot:

You're maps are always something I want to keep an eye out for... they never cease to completely amaze me. It's really nice to see that someone out there is still amazing. Unlike 99.9% of the other maps I see on this thread, yours are always absolutely perfect. I'm not going to give you a 9.5 because nothing is perfect... you deserve having a perfect rating for a perfect map.
10/10 <- I can't remember the last time I gave that, and meant it... honestly.

Please continue to be the only one in this thread that surprises me with every map!

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Map Name: Forestria Village
ROM Base: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Xiros, Kyledove, rhevarhe_duh, Wesley FG, Saurav
Comments: To be honest, I did this map very quickly and for fun. ^_^

Mapshot:

sasquatch, you continue to amaze me.

Everything about this map is just..perfect. Even if it was quick, it's great. =D

10/10

 

[PI Hudson]

2nd attempt at getting a rating on my 2nd attempt

2nd attempt

Name-Crescent Town(new name, too)
Game- Pokemon Shale(not listed)
Base- Emerald (U)
Comments-

Spoiler:

I removed the fence thats above the lake of the route below, added custom tiles for paths, added some forestry, gave mountains more detail, moved Waterfall Caves' waterfall entrance into another map, extended river to lake below, changed tiles gym was on, and redid the river.

Should I extend the waterfall in Crescent town?

Also, border is tall grass

Image-Click

 

[Crimson Stardust]

My map

Its been a long time since i last map...llooll..
Name:Greenwood Village
From:Fire Red
Info:This is for fun since i want to try mapping again..
Rate it..:);)

Spoiler:

 

[0m3GA ARS3NAL]

Its been a long time since i last map...llooll..
Name:Greenwood Village
From:Fire Red
Info:This is for fun since i want to try mapping again..
Rate it..:);)

Spoiler:

Not bad, not bad.
I love the placement of the Paths here, and the use of FR tiles is superb. 8/10
Pointer, the small houses look a bit too smal, and the fences are kinda pointless IMO...
Still a GREAT map.

 

[WindBlows]

Its been a long time since i last map...llooll..
Name:Greenwood Village
From:Fire Red
Info:This is for fun since i want to try mapping again..
Rate it..:);)

Spoiler:

Rating: 1/5
Comments: This map is way too square. The trees' shadows are not correct. Also it is a little bit empty. That blue roof house is everywhere. Sorry I didn't like it.

 

[Kyouya]

iceberg

ruby

THe starter town for a hack im trying to make

 

[Master Terrador]

*Sigh*I Decided to post this Ice cave...Which I made a long time ago...

Name-Frozone Cavern 1F
ROM-Ruby
Description-First map I ever made...I lost it in a computer crash...the only one left is in my album...

Spoiler:

 

[Mana1]

Pokecraze -

4/10 The map doesn't have any... direction. What I mean is you could get to it from all sides, so its more some ice field than a cave which I feel it should be. Theres also quite a few tiling errors I can spot, one of the ladders, the ledge down the left isn't consistant...

Shadow -

8/10 - Looks good from what I can see, however I don't like how you can only go one way through the ice puzzle! ;) Haha.

 

[Alice]

Spoiler:

I felt like reposting my ice cave.