Map Rating/Review Thread

[Haku.]

There's a border error at the signpost.
my rating is 7/10.
It's pretty nice and playable.

 

[amoliski]

It is two maps put together. The city and a park with three 'objectives.' What tile errors are you referring to? I made the map, so I probably can't even see them. I didn't want required grass in the first area so I could keep the paths in tact, but I will probably change it now.

As I said, I'm not an artist, so how can I get better?
Thanks for your feedback.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Kinsbaile Town.

If you play MTG...

Shh!

Yes, I was trying for the symmetry.

 

[/Circa]

Kinsbaile Town.

If you play MTG...

Shh!

Yes, I was trying for the symmetry.

If you want it to be simple and beautiful i'd ditch the symmetry, make the left house normal and put it up one tile, then your map is perfect.

But atm 7.5/10.

Fix the door please.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

If you want it to be simple and beautiful i'd ditch the symmetry, make the left house normal and put it up one tile, then your map is perfect.

But atm 7.5/10.

Fix the door please.

Oh, pssh.

I was thinking of fixing up the symmetry too, because it suddenly doesn't look right.

Spoiler:

Fixed it up a bit.

 

[/Circa]

Oh, pssh.

I was thinking of fixing up the symmetry too, because it suddenly doesn't look right.

Spoiler:

Fixed it up a bit.

Now that deserves a 10/10.

 

[DreadWaffle]

Now that deserves a 10/10.

well i have to agree on that note
but seriously kinsbaile, did you have to bring up kithkin

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

well i have to agree on that note
but seriously kinsbaile, did you have to bring up kithkin

Shhhh. >=[

Spoiler:

A new map, Viridian Meadow

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Shhhh. >=[

Spoiler:

A new map, Viridian Meadow

That's a great map, but I don't get it. Is the west side going to be filled with Trainers or what?
Also I disagree with the width of the map. It could be 2 tiles less wide, to save space.
That is why I am giving you a 8.5/10.

 

[-Omega-]

Okay, I tried to improve the map, so here is the result.
View attachment 51334

 

[amoliski]

I tried to improve my map too, though it was pretty tough to improve it without actually knowing what needs to be fixed.
I put grass in the players way, which was the only constructive criticism I actually got.

 

[→goon]

Map Name: Palmcoast Lagoon
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Credits: kyledove, Wesley FG, zein
Comments: I thought I'd try my hand at water route mapping, since I've heard it's difficult to make them interesting to play.

Spoiler:

 

[colcolstyles]

Map Name: Palmcoast Lagoon
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Credits: kyledove, Wesley FG, zein
Comments: I thought I'd try my hand at water route mapping, since I've heard it's difficult to make them interesting to play.

Spoiler:

It looks great but what I'm really interested in is how you managed to create this block:

It seems to me that you would need either three layers or an entire palette dedicated to only that block.

 

[→goon]

It looks great but what I'm really interested in is how you managed to create this block:

It seems to me that you would need either three layers or an entire palette dedicated to only that block.

It has an entire palette for that block. I couldn't find a way around it and I'm only making this map for fun/practice, so it won't be in game.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

That's a great map, but I don't get it. Is the west side going to be filled with Trainers or what?
Also I disagree with the width of the map. It could be 2 tiles less wide, to save space.
That is why I am giving you a 8.5/10.

Oh, I forgot. You don't have a Pokemon the first time you go through this map.

Repost!

Viridian Meadows.

You don't have a Pokemon when you first go into this route, thus the path.

Spoiler:

 

[Hohoo]

Rom: Gold and HMM, I WONDER (FireRed)
Map name: Loosestrife City
Hack name: Gold: Pineapple, FireRed: none (yet?)
Comments: Here are two versions of a port city in Pineapple. The FireRed version is the same city but after a few years in the future. It's also my first Gen III map.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Why does it shrink after a few years? o_o

 

[Hohoo]

Why does it shrink after a few years? o_o

Oops. Somehow I managed to post an older version. Here is the correct one.

It was originally planned to be much bigger but then I decided to "shrink" it.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Oops. Somehow I managed to post an older version. Here is the correct one.

Ah, I see.

Uh, just want to point out that you can use one of the Sevii Island tilesets and get an actual port thing in your FR map.

 

[Hohoo]

Ah, I see.

Uh, just want to point out that you can use one of the Sevii Island tilesets and get an actual port thing.

The port is like in GSC, so there is a short tunnel before the actual port area.

And besides, I already have the normal and Cerulean tilesets in use so I don't really know how I could add a Sevii tileset.