Map Rating/Review Thread

[Tyrantrum]

Okay, here's some more maps for my hack of Gold Version:
Map Name: Azela Town
Hack Name: Awakened Legends

This is Azela Town, now Azela City! I made it much bigger and better. NOTE: The Radio Tower is an IMPORTANT part in my hack! Here's the other:
Map Name: Blackthorn CityHack Name: Awakened Legends

This is Blackthorn City, just like in Gold. NOTE: The Radio Tower is also important! Just because there's a Radio Tower in both doesn't mean you should lower your score!
I tried to make this town look kind of like the last sanctuary for the 'good' people. You'll understand more when you play my hack!

1. It's very nice, nothing wrong with it in my eyes...10/10
2. I like the simplicity of the map, but the part where there is a lone stair isn't right, so...9.5/10

Map Name: ---
Rom: Fire Red
Credits: Kyledove.
Map Description: Its my starting town, so theres not much too it, im using Kyledoves DP tileset, hopefully Ill change some things around later.

(attachment)

The graphics r beautiful and it's not too square, but it seems empty...9/10

 

[Melash]

Oh, right! Thanks for rating mine Eeveon! Here's two more maps:
Map Name: Saffron City
Map Game: Awakened Legends

This is the secondary main city base of Team Rocket. Whew, long sentance! Here's the other:
Map Name: Underground Train
Map Game: Awakened Legends

pretty sweet and simple, so there's not much to rate about it! Just tell me if you spot any mistakes or anything!

 

[Barker]

Map Name: ---
Rom: Fire Red
Credits: Kyledove.
Map Description: Its my starting town, so theres not much too it, im using Kyledoves DP tileset, hopefully Ill change some things around later.

(attachment)

It's a great tileset. Also a good, simple map. Nothing looks wrong on first glance, but that may be the tileset. It needs something to fill it out, because it's a little empty. Maybe any added people ingame will improve that. I really do like the basic outlay though, and the winding path.

9/10.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Oh, right! Thanks for rating mine Eeveon! Here's two more maps:
Map Name: Saffron City
Map Game: Awakened Legends

This is the secondary main city base of Team Rocket. Whew, long sentance! Here's the other:
Map Name: Underground Train
Map Game: Awakened Legends

pretty sweet and simple, so there's not much to rate about it! Just tell me if you spot any mistakes or anything!

1. Good, but very empty...5/10.
2. Pretty good. but there r too many seats on 1 side...8/10.

 

[Melash]

Here are some more maps: Well, actually, they're the same map, just each of them done in a different tileset! Tell me which one you like better:

That one was the original. Here is the one done in the Jhoto tileset:

 

[Tyrantrum]

Here are some more maps: Well, actually, they're the same map, just each of them done in a different tileset! Tell me which one you like better:

That one was the original. Here is the one done in the Jhoto tileset:

Not in a mean way, but it looks the same...
Make it a little more original, then I'll rate it, K? ^^
(Tomorrow though :P)

 

[Melash]

Oh, okay! Yeah, I'll get it on tomorrow, I have to go now!

 

[Neti]

Map Name: ---
Rom: Fire Red
Credits: Kyledove.
Map Description: Its my starting town, so theres not much too it, im using Kyledoves DP tileset, hopefully Ill change some things around later.

(attachment)

Really good map, the tileset is great, the shape is not squarish, and it really has the feeling of a starter town: not complicated, calm athmosphere...
the path is also really nice
i give it 10/10 mainly because of the tileset

Repost of RuralTown Village without the grid.

i promised you il lrate yours:
the map itsself is really good and has a very original shape, but there are a few things that caught my eye:
the DP Pokecenter has a lil error at it roof at the top left, fix that. the next thing is that there should be a path... it just looks like theres somethiing missing without it. another thing is that the coast is really staright, you dont have to make completely round or sth, but edit it a bit so it looks more natural.
the last things, which is not so improtant, is taht youre using the normal FR Tiles (except for the pkcenter), which are not good in my opinion (mainly the palettes). You should try Partial DP Base or Super DP Base.
Rating: 7.5/10


Its my turn once again:

Map Name: Guaiwan (name of the city)

Hack: Pokemon Legend of Fenju

Hack of: Firered + Partial DP Base + Ice Tileset + Desert Tileset

Credits: dshayabusa for the palettes, fangking Omega for the tiles

Comments: Actually none...

Map Image:
*image removed*

 

[Tyrantrum]

Here are some more maps: Well, actually, they're the same map, just each of them done in a different tileset! Tell me which one you like better:

That one was the original. Here is the one done in the Jhoto tileset:

I see u changed it, but not a lot...4/10

Really good map, the tileset is great, the shape is not squarish, and it really has the feeling of a starter town: not complicated, calm athmosphere...
the path is also really nice
i give it 10/10 mainly because of the tileset



i promised you il lrate yours:
the map itsself is really good and has a very original shape, but there are a few things that caught my eye:
the DP Pokecenter has a lil error at it roof at the top left, fix that. the next thing is that there should be a path... it just looks like theres somethiing missing without it. another thing is that the coast is really staright, you dont have to make completely round or sth, but edit it a bit so it looks more natural.
the last things, which is not so improtant, is taht youre using the normal FR Tiles (except for the pkcenter), which are not good in my opinion (mainly the palettes). You should try Partial DP Base or Super DP Base.
Rating: 7.5/10


Its my turn once again:

Map Name: Guaiwan (name of the city)

Hack: Pokemon Legend of Fenju

Hack of: Firered + Partial DP Base + Ice Tileset + Desert Tileset

Credits: dshayabusa for the palettes, fangking Omega for the tiles

Comments: Actually none...

Map Image:
*image removed*

Very nice.
I also like the hole in the frozen lake.
Also an excellent mixture of snow covered mountains and trees...10/10

 

[garra911]

I posted this map earlier and didn't get a rating or much feedback, so I'm reposting it

Map Name: Aurum Town (Aurum is Latin for gold)
Hack of: Fire Red with Super D/P rom base
Hack name: Pokemon Dragon Flame (follow my sig)

 

[PikachuEX]

Map Name: Cherrygrove City
Hack of: LeafGreen
Comments: Just a map for a Silver remake.
Mapshot:

 

[armii8877]

I really Like It, 10/10! I think you should put a lil' island with a rock on it in the middle of the water!

 

[Neti]

i think its cool too, but ther are some heavey tile errors where the rocks meet the land and the one rock between the ebach and the trees at the top left, which could have easily been fixed with the block editor. you should spend some time learning how it (the block eidtor) works.
the rest is cool to me, really looks like cherrygrove!
rating: 8/10

 

[Melash]

All right, here are some more maps! They're all Gold maps for my hack, Awakened Legends. Some of these have already been posted by me, but I've changed the way the look:
Map Name: Olivine City

Comments: This is Team Rocket's new base in Awakened Legends. NOTE: The mountain on the bottom and right sides are important! You have to sneak around them in part of the game!

Map Name: Whirl Caves

Comments: I have already posted this before, but this oen is a little different! Do you think it looks better with mountains along the edges or water 'walls'?

 

[Neti]

dont have much time, but i can tell you one thing: if it is not possible for th player to get into the water at the qhirl island map there shouldnt be a border/wall . it just doesnt look as good as if there is just water... and wow... many cave entrances^^

 

[Melash]

^I know, they got off of the cliffs on Route...uh...39, I think! I'll post that map in after a few people rate the above ones!

 

[Tyrantrum]

All right, here are some more maps! They're all Gold maps for my hack, Awakened Legends. Some of these have already been posted by me, but I've changed the way the look:
Map Name: Olivine City

Comments: This is Team Rocket's new base in Awakened Legends. NOTE: The mountain on the bottom and right sides are important! You have to sneak around them in part of the game!
Not very edited...3/10

Map Name: Whirl Caves

Comments: I have already posted this before, but this oen is a little different! Do you think it looks better with mountains along the edges or water 'walls'?

Pretty good.
Very maze-like...7.5/10

 

[Melash]

Yeah, I wanted to make it like a maze and really complicated! Here are some more maps, same game:
Map Name: New Bark Town

Comments: I've already posted this map, but I changed it a little, so just tell me what you think of it! Should I keep the grass? It does make it look more destroyed,

Map Name: Route 40

Comments: This is the Route right before the Whirl Caves, where Lugia resides. The caves are a major part of the storyline in Awakened Legends. I put a lot of mountains to make it look like you were getting closer and closer to the final scene in the game!

Map Name: Route 39

This is the Route that leads to Olivine City. You know, where the Miltank farms are? Anyway, I wanted to look it make a little ruined and have a lot of mountains!

 

[Tyrantrum]

Yeah, I wanted to make it like a maze and really complicated! Here are some more maps, same game:
Map Name: New Bark Town

Comments: I've already posted this map, but I changed it a little, so just tell me what you think of it! Should I keep the grass? It does make it look more destroyed,

Map Name: Route 40

Comments: This is the Route right before the Whirl Caves, where Lugia resides. The caves are a major part of the storyline in Awakened Legends. I put a lot of mountains to make it look like you were getting closer and closer to the final scene in the game!

Map Name: Route 39

This is the Route that leads to Olivine City. You know, where the Miltank farms are? Anyway, I wanted to look it make a little ruined and have a lot of mountains!

1. 5/10
2. 4/10
3. 6.5/10
They're pretty good...

 

[/Circa]

Map 2
Thanks to Kyledove for the main tileset.
This is the first route in my hack.

Map 3
Thanks to Kyledove for the main tileset, Peyi for the PC & Mart.
The second town in my hack, Gym is relocated somewhere else :).

Maps are in attachments.