Map Rating/Review Thread

[Mitchman]

Meh there all nice
9/10
9/10
10/10
8/10
7/10- this is for having an invisible gym!

 

[/Circa]

Meh there all nice
9/10
9/10
10/10
8/10
7/10- this is for having an invisible gym!

It would help if you read the descriptions, and actually rated my maps properly as I asked.

 

[Mitchman]

Αha ok um
Evergreen town- 9/10 because although its simple I dont see a river like in the description
Route 1-10/10 because a starting route is supposed to be simple and I love the fact that you cant return to your hometown.
Froma town- 9/10 its nice but meh not to my liking how the houses are placed. As an elder shoudnt he have a house in the middle and the pc in the houses place? Also I dont know if thats a tile error or a secret but 2 trees ar missing.
Route 2- Like you said its simple so not much to rate. 10/10
Rockham city-9/10 I like it but how does a gym get up an leave. Mabye the thing was wreked and all that stands is a platform where battle took place.

That was good enough right?

 

[Dr Gregory House]

could someone rate this route remake please.
i am having a few troubles with the bridges and the level permissions of the ground atm, so it is likely to be modified. tell me wat ya think!

 

[Mitchman]

Perfect! Its really good so 9/10

 

[BigSteve]

Nice map all in all
few errors down the right hand side
lots of the rocks near the edge of the land are cut in half or just have pieces missing
there is also missing bits of darkened water there too
hope that helps :)
will be an 8/10 when you fix that :)

 

[Binary]

Sirwillis04-
Tha map is overall very good except for the errors all over the place. Once you fix them, it should look very good. I would also suggest you to use bridges of two blocks rather than just one block. The map looks very good though.
8/10

 

[Cartmic]

could someone rate this route remake please.
i am having a few troubles with the bridges and the level permissions of the ground atm, so it is likely to be modified. tell me wat ya think!

6/10
Remove the land along the left hand side, put in some rocky tiles around the trees.
Im not a great fan of remakes due to there's very little of peoples own thought gone into it.

 

[Dr Gregory House]

ok, so i implemented a few of those changes. does it look better?

and here's a redo of mount moon! =D you like?
oh and here's part of my hidden cave. i just need to make some stairs which go up and right =D

 

[BigSteve]

ok, so i implemented a few of those changes. does it look better?

and here's a redo of mount moon! =D you like?
oh and here's part of my hidden cave. i just need to make some stairs which go up and right =D

much better on the route 9/10

but i dont like mount moon or the secret cave
trees and grass in a cave?

 

[Dr Gregory House]

much better on the route 9/10

but i dont like mount moon or the secret cave
trees and grass in a cave?

well, my reason there was because i was bored of all the old **** like the cave tiles. it's mount moon, it's full of fairies, and abnormal stuff should happen in the crater, which is what I am working on, therefore, I added trees.

so what about this one? this is route 4 redone, and where that second cave entrance is where you get to the secret cave. it is normally blocked by a guard until you get misty's badge, but i don't know what here flag is yet, so it can't be used yet. the thrid cave entrance is of course the exit.
and i also redid the secret cave.

 

[Mitchman]

Nice job! I like the route 4 and the cave is..meh. 9/10 and 6/10

 

[Dr Gregory House]

Nice job! I like the route 4 and the cave is..meh. 9/10 and 6/10

yeh, that's mainly cause it's the lead up to the crater...where you battle a shiny clefable...which has special moves...but only if you've beaten misty. ;P

 

[Tyrantrum]

I got bored.
So I made a random map.

Plz rate and comment.

 

[Dr Gregory House]

I got bored.
So I made a random map.
Plz rate and comment.

I would rate 7/10.
reason: It's way too square. there's no exit. the small tree tile is wrong. and you don't need a pokemon center and a pokemart in a starting town, as the lab should have a healing machine.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Another boring map made by boring, old me...

Plz rate and comment.

 

[Hiroshi Uwishicarwei]

8/10
But wheres the love...
Here is mine

 

[Dr Gregory House]

Another boring map made by boring, old me...

Plz rate and comment.

Again, the stairs are too...i dunno. perhaps you could add a few ledges so that they aren't just straight up. make it interesting.

8/10
But wheres the love...
Here is mine

it's ok, but the dark blue, in my opinion, stands out too much. perhaps you could make the buildings frosted over instead.

now, whenever i say, improve the squarishness, i mean have something like this: see attatchment
can you rate it also?

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Hmmm....
Back to good ol rating...

Well...Sirwillis04...
Hmmm...8/10...
Well, it's good ...but it's square...
It has a nice mazy feel to it...Hmmm
Well, there's a tile error on the left side...know what I mean?

 

[Dr Gregory House]

Hmmm....
Back to good ol rating...

Well...Sirwillis04...
Hmmm...8/10...
Well, it's good ...but it's square...
It has a nice mazy feel to it...Hmmm
Well, there's a tile error on the left side...know what I mean?

yeh now i only just noticed it. lol.