Map Rating/Review Thread

[Ninja Caterpie]

There's nothing wrong with your Routes!
Just your...cities...
This map isn't the best...
It's FAR too empty. I know you tried to add flowers but...it's just not that good.
You only need 5 houses, why not shrink the map?
4.5/10

Well, this one isn't too bad!
The rock bridge isn't the best idea...
But who gives a damn.
Also, there are tile errors where rock meets grass
Use the tile on the city (above) at the bottom of the pool
7/10

If you don't mind me asking, why is there one WHOLE SIDE of the map open?
Congratz on adding me stair tiles BTW
7/10

Three maps by me (I'm bad at route editing)

So yeah.
I think that's it and all...xD

 

[Austinia]

here is 2 maps which include the starting town and first route. rate please?

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I have two maps... ^.^
Route 1

Spoiler:

And a cave.

Spoiler:

So, rate and stuff.

 

[simplynaruto]

Austinia i think your maps deserve 9.5 and dark lakitu um not to bad. 8.7 for both cause the cave is like one of those zelda caves you bomb open for a treasure.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Better...errors with the paths...8.5/10

Here r my maps:

Spoiler:

Could someone plz rate these maps? :P

 

[Binary]

I have two maps... ^.^
Route 1

Spoiler:

And a cave.

Spoiler:

So, rate and stuff.

1st map:
I like it, it's really simple and nice. But I think it's pretty squarish in some parts. The ledges are used nicely, and I like the way you placed the patches of grass there. The little hill looks nice. Good job!
8.5/10
Try to add some flowers and other greenery.

2nd map:
A pretty tiny cave isn't it? It looks like it has an entrance but no place to really go to. Probably it's a cave of some event maybe? Looks nice and simple though. Good use of the block of rocks.
8.5/10

 

[Amonitas]

I read that mapping tutorial by some random person and I thought I could give it a try too, because you seem to have that in a great imprtance.
This is what I got in 20 minutes lol!
[img=https://img50.imageshack.us/img50/2853/route102gv5.th.png]
=P

 

[Neti]

is that your first map ever? nice! if ild need a mapper ild instantly ask you to join me cause i think with some more practice youll make awesome maps! the only errors i found were at the ends of the ledge ledge (i dont know if theres an ending tile for them in ruby... i normally hack FR)
oh and next time you post a map here turn off the grid before making the map shot, it really disturbs me :P

 

[Amonitas]

is that your first map ever? nice! if ild need a mapper ild instantly ask you to join me cause i think with some more practice youll make awesome maps! the only errors i found were at the ends of the ledge ledge (i dont know if theres an ending tile for them in ruby... i normally hack FR)
oh and next time you post a map here turn off the grid before making the map shot, it really disturbs me :P

And it's all thanks to your awesome guide!
Of course I can make maps if you need, it's just very exhausting...

 

[Neti]

no i dont need a mapper at the moment, i already get help from ZetKa and all in all i could make it alone, but it would take longer that way xD
thx anyway

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

O.o...Spam much...? xD
Well, I'm going to...RATE YOUR MAP AMONITAS!
Hmmm...
Well, it's got good shape!
Grass and trees placed nicely.
No tile errors (except the one Neti pointed out)
Well, that's your first map?
Amazing... .(Yeah, great tut Neti!)
9/10
If the tile error can't be fixed (Or it's not a tile error at all O.o)
I can change it to 9.5

 

[Amonitas]

O.o...Spam much...? xD
Well, I'm going to...RATE YOUR MAP AMONITAS!
Hmmm...
Well, it's got good shape!
Grass and trees placed nicely.
No tile errors (except the one Neti pointed out)
Well, that's your first map?
Amazing... .(Yeah, great tut Neti!)
9/10
If the tile error can't be fixed (Or it's not a tile error at all O.o)
I can change it to 9.5

sry if this is a spam, but I dunno what tile error are you talking about, I don't know how to modify tiles.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

No, I mean a problem with how you place the tiles.
The ledge is meant to have a curved end to it.

 

[Ryousha]

Well I did a simple map trying of the name: NELT TOWN.

(the green item is later for the Shaymin Sky Forme Statue).


please rate it, and give me some advice onto it./Improvements

 

[Cartmic]

Well I did a simple map trying of the name: NELT TOWN.

(the green item is later for the Shaymin Sky Forme Statue).


please rate it, and give me some advice onto it./Improvements

4/10

Remove the "snow" and move the lab and houses. Its clearly derrived from Pallet Town.

 

[Ryousha]

No it doesn't the houses are supposed to be there, I used a custom map button

Well the Lab may look like from pallet town but it's not. ^^


and the snow is my snow hack...

 

[Cartmic]

No it doesn't the houses are supposed to be there, I used a custom map button

Well the Lab may look like from pallet town but it's not. ^^


and the snow is my snow hack(I really dislike ellipsis there is no need for them)

I would modify the tree pallet a bit, also I would wash out the flower's colour a bit, as remember this is a colder climate and it would probably have frost on.

Finally try and add some snow to the roofs' and a little snow on the little green things next to the flower

 

[Tyrantrum]

Better...errors with the paths...8.5/10

Here r my maps:

Spoiler:

Could someone rate these, plz! ^^

 

[Binary]

Well I did a simple map trying of the name: NELT TOWN.

(the green item is later for the Shaymin Sky Forme Statue).


please rate it, and give me some advice onto it./Improvements

I like the map. It looks really nice with a cold touch to it. The map is fairly squarish though, and I don't like the little grass infront in the doorstep of that house. The houses are placed in a sort of congested way. The map looks fairly good though.
7.5/10

 

[Ryousha]

@Eeveon

2nd Map:
5/10 it looks like that one town cept minor edits

3rd map:
7.5/10
You need to make more building without the doors : )