• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • It's time to vote for your favorite Pokémon Battle Revolution protagonist in our new weekly protagonist poll! Click here to cast your vote and let us know which PBR protagonist you like most.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by suoert
Hi guys Here's a new route from me!

rating: 8/10
reason: I like the tiles, and the poke center. The only thing I don't like is the normal grass and the small trees. The trees look like they have small gaps in the middle of them.The grass looks like it has to many bumps in it. all and all good map.
 
sab said:
Originally Posted by Poke-Roy
Map name: Harmony of the earth
Mapped ROM: Fire Red

nice map, I really like it. My personal opinion, but I think you should have made a map connection (or at least a cave)so that it's not a dead-end map.
Rating: 8/10
Click to expand...
Thanks but there is a cave right at the bottom:P

¿TB Pro™ said:
Suggestions:Try to make some of it less symmetrical(like Fire said), other than thta, It's a nice map!
Rating: 8/10
Comments: I know this isn't part of the grading scale, but maybe try to change up the palettes. The mountain palettes are freaky, the darkest color of brown dosen't go with the othr colors of brown. The trees are that way too. I liek the colors, just try to make them flow better.
Click to expand...
Yeaa I kinda have to get into mapping again didn't do it for a long time..
And thanks for your comment ill try and change it ;)

~Fire said:
the trees are in a normal military like order, the flowers and dirt path are disturbing with its symmetry, the flowers are all bunched up, and the mountain just looks to disturbing with its symmetry, like before.
However, the shape of the lake is pretty nice, i like it.
rating:6/10
suggestions: Make it much less symmetrical, whether or not its supposed to be natural.
and i know this doesn't matter, but i think you should change the palettes into something more subtle.
Click to expand...
Thanks I will take a look at it and you gotta keep in the back of yout mind this is my 2nd map since a long time:P

Tamerhaidar said:
Nice map, but I think that the map is too square. That's just me.
There are empty spaces. I like the placement of the grass.
Rating: 7/10
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
Click to expand...
idd I noticed it when I read your post had to see it earlierXD but thanks ;)
 
hey guys heres a new map i made for a new hack
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

please post any criticism
 
Hackimon12 said:
hey guys heres a new map i made for a new hack
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

please post any criticism
Click to expand...
Tip one:
Grid Off
The grid makes it harder to evaluate. And it is annoying (heh, same thing basically)
Tiles are a nice touch, but the map is a bit square, and the water... moving water at that, in the middle of this town. I suggest using non-moving water, and making it a bit less square. both the water and town, less square... plus the empty space behind the house in the upper left corner... eww...
I'll give it a 5 screaming donkeys... out of 10
 
Hackimon12 said:
hey guys heres a new map i made for a new hack
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

please post any criticism
Click to expand...

Rating: 4/10
Reason: Hmm..yes, it would be better to remove the grid as said by omega arsenal. The map is pretty squarish and it is pretty empty, don't you think? I don't like the shape of the little lake there.
Suggestions: Try to add some more greenery and don't make the map a square. It pretty much ruins the map. Try to fill up the empty spaces and fix up the shape of that little lake.
 
Originally Posted by Hackimon12
hey guys heres a new map i made for a new hack

Take the grid off.The map looks kind of empty. You have good tiles.
put more greenery, make the hero have to work his way through the town.
rating 6/10
 
Poke-Roy said:
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

Map Name: Valencia Town
Made on ROM Base from Xiderwong & Kyledove & Zel.
Comment: As you can see there is a little Palette error on one of the tree kinds, wil fix it asap.
Click to expand...

Hm...A realy nice map..but go easy on the grass tiles behind the houses, connect the water ponds OR get rid of the little water pond and make there some trees so the map isn't so square!
RATING: 8,5
P.s: But its a nice map!
 
after seeing the maps you posted here and in the rom reaverz thread i have to say you really gott good mapping skills
i hope youll find a talented team that needs a mapper

about your latest map:
i really dunno what to complain about... i love that rombase and thee trees youve inserted.
the double house is a bit strange though and the general shape is a bit squarish, what isnt souch a big problem cause youve made the way thorugh the map really nice
rating: 9.5/10
 
Neti said:
after seeing the maps you posted here and in the rom reaverz thread i have to say you really gott good mapping skills
i hope youll find a talented team that needs a mapper

about your latest map:
i really dunno what to complain about... i love that rombase and thee trees youve inserted.
the double house is a bit strange though and the general shape is a bit squarish, what isnt souch a big problem cause youve made the way thorugh the map really nice
rating: 9.5/10
Click to expand...
Thanks :D Wanted to make it less squarish at the end but there wasn't enough space :P
Here is my Valencia revision 2
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
 
Tamerhaidar said:
Rating: 8.5/10
you fixed it up a bit.
Even though, I like this map.
Great mapping.
Click to expand...

thats what i meant, Pokecommunity gained a new brilliant mapper^^
you just have to deal with the squarishness/squairity (dunno whcih is right... or maybe both words are worng)
@All teams who are in need of mapper: invite him before somebody else does xD
 
Tamerhaidar said:
Rating: 8.5/10
you fixed it up a bit.
Even though, I like this map.
Great mapping.
Click to expand...
Thank you :D

Neti said:
thats what i meant, Pokecommunity gained a new brilliant mapper^^
you just have to deal with the squarishness/squairity (dunno whcih is right... or maybe both words are worng)
@All teams who are in need of mapper: invite him before somebody else does xD
Click to expand...
Thanks to you to :D:D But I made my comeback :P if you search this thread oyu will find alot of my old maps to ;)

Heres a little route..
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

lolz and now I'm gonna play GRAW 2 :P
 
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread


My new map.
It may seem bad, I just did it.
Please rate.
Thank you

Don't mind the tile error. I will fix it now. It's between the small tree and mountain(near the icy water).
Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Tamerhaidar said:
My new map.
It may seem bad, I just fixed it.
Please rate.
Thank you

Don't mind the tile error. I will fix it now. It's between the small tree and mountain(near the icy water).
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Looks very nice.. But the open spaces between the trees on the mountians are to open maybe a suggestion to place some small mountains or something on it and in the upper area you should make use of the space and not to put so many trees in it in my opinion...
I'll rate this a 8.5 :)
 
Poke-Roy said:
Looks very nice.. But the open spaces between the trees on the mountians are to open maybe a suggestion to place some small mountains or something on it and in the upper area you should make use of the space and not to put so many trees in it in my opinion...
I'll rate this a 8.5 :)
Click to expand...

Thank you so much for the rate, Poke-Roy
I will try and fix it.
As for your last map, I give you a 8.8/10.
Because I like the map's shape, the grass is placed neatly, and the trees are great.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top