Map Rating/Review Thread

[Tyrantrum]

Siro Village

Plz rate and comment.

 

[Dr Gregory House]

Siro Village

Plz rate and comment.

7/10
mainly because it looks too crowded. that's the only problem i have with it.
the bottom house is over the path, so you could get rid of the hedge and put it back behind the path.
notice how you have moss rocks up against the water? why is that? i see no reason why there couldn't be an item on the ground in the bottom right corner?

 

[Binary]

Siro Village

Plz rate and comment.

Nice, I like the map. It looks nice and simple. The map does look alittle crowded though...you shouldn't make the map too crowded. The map looks very nice with the bridges and all. You should've used the other type of houses. But I like the map 8D
9/10

 

[v1tje]

My first map it's not totally finished but i like it a bit. I've got advanced map since an hour:

View attachment 41272

 

[Melash]

^Hmm, not bad... I give it a 4/10. Reasons? Well, don't add so many flower boxes in a row, fix the trees, get rid of the lighthouse thing, and clear the space in the bottom right corner. It's to empty...

 

[Tony the Awesome]

My first map it's not totally finished but i like it a bit. I've got advanced map since an hour:

View attachment 41272

A lot of tile errors. Some empty space...
I'll give it a 1/10...
Try reading some tutorials in the tutorial section.

 

[v1tje]

Okay, i had an hour advanced map so a little mistakes are not bad i think.

 

[Wiro]

Hi!

here's my green route, where you start the game:

and here's evergreen ville: (eeveon i got the name b4 i saw your post)

 

[Barker]

Hi!

here's my green route, where you start the game:

Looks good, especially if you've just started recently. I like the use of "mountain" tiles, because it shows you've really got a sense of depth behind your mapping. Overall, however, it seems a little empty and "short" for a "route". Also, there's no grass; I don't remember there being a route without at least some wild grass.

8/10

and here's evergreen ville: (eeveon i got the name b4 i saw your post)

Again, here, I like the concept. (The Gym being right there, and you're forced to pass it.) I don't like the use of just that particular house; I would expand the map a little, eliminate one of the houses, and re-arrange the others. Again though, nice sense of depth.

8/10

 

[Wiro]

Looks good, especially if you've just started recently. I like the use of "mountain" tiles, because it shows you've really got a sense of depth behind your mapping. Overall, however, it seems a little empty and "short" for a "route". Also, there's no grass; I don't remember there being a route without at least some wild grass.

8/10

it's like where you start the game, when you go through the house the route continues and there's no grass because you can't fight without pokemon

Again, here, I like the concept. (The Gym being right there, and you're forced to pass it.) I don't like the use of just that particular house; I would expand the map a little, eliminate one of the houses, and re-arrange the others. Again though, nice sense of depth.

8/10

yeah, it's going to be a way up to a mountain somewhere, but i dunno yet where...

but 8/10 is pretty good anyway :) thx

 

[Tyrantrum]

Hi!

here's my green route, where you start the game:

and here's evergreen ville: (eeveon i got the name b4 i saw your post)

Map 1:
I really like the map.
But there is too much empty space, u should fix that...8/10

Map 2:
Again, another very good map, but too much empty space.
U should be careful of that, that's a mistake a lot of people make....9/10

(For the name, u could use whatever name u like, that map of mine was just a random map and felt like renaming it. So don't worry, it's OK if u use the names that u want, even if they r the same as someone else. I try to make the names fit in with the town. ^^)

 

[Neti]

Map 1:
I really like the map.
But there is too much empty space, u should fix that...8/10

Map 2:
Again, another very good map, but too much empty space.
U should be careful of that, that's a mistake a lot of people make....9/10

(For the name, u could use whatever name u like, that map of mine was just a random map and felt like renaming it. So don't worry, it's OK if u use the names that u want, even if they r the same as someone else. I try to make the names fit in with the town. ^^)

the second map has a bit too mcuch empyt space at the elft, but where do you find empty space at the first one? maybe theres some unsued space, but maps do need those places that dont serve a real purpose or they look unnatural
i think thats one thing i critisized at your maps: you dont give the player any opportunity to leave the path

 

[Tyrantrum]

Well, in some hacks, some places that have no exits, maybe it's a place to get warped to and from.

 

[Melash]

Okay, here are some of my new maps:
Hack Name: Awakened Legends
Hack of: Gold
Map Name: New Bark Town

Description: Although I have already posted this map before, this one is a little differenent.

Map Name: Cave ? ? ?

Description: This is just some cave in the game. Tell me how you like it.

Hack Name: Ancient Ruby
Hack Of: Gold
Map Name: Littleroot Town

Description: This is a map of Littleroot Town. Sound familar? Well, this game is a remake of Ruby with 2nd Gen graphics. Tell me if it sounds like a good idea.

On this one just tell me which row is better. Top or bottom?

 

[.:God:.]

Map Name: Faelniwt Town (fail-new-ta)

Map Game: Firered

Comments: First for the new hack Pokemon- The Lost Kingdom: War Lords

Mapshot: Check Attachments


@Melash

Rating:
Map 1: 7/10
Map 2: 8.5-9.9/10
Map 3: 6/10

Reason:
Map 1: What happened? It looks like a meteor hit! It's a mess! And also, how many stories does the lab have? Like 24?
Map 2: This depends on when the map shows up in the game. I mean. you need surf to get through it, so... halfway decent. What's the point of the rocks?
Map 3: Extremely boring and empty. But.... it does look a lot like Rooty.

Suggestions:
Map 1: Give it a more spicy look and not a funeral-looking type of city like Lavender Town.
Map 2: Not really a lot... just change the storyline like getting Surf after the 1st gym or something.
Map 3: Fill it up, if you want it to be intresting.

 

[Momoko]

Sorry i have no time for rating right now X_X as im mapping at this very instant,but just checking to see what the hack is looking like so far.
Map Name: HERATIO TOWN.

Map Game: Fire Red



Comments: Uhh, not much, used a tileset i found in the hackers resource (forgot name X_X) and uhh it'll be where you start for my hack (I'm redoing all maps with this tileset).

 

[Mitchman]

Aha cool. Its sergios by the way. I say it is a map worthy of.....9.5/10!

 

[Binary]

Sorry i have no time for rating right now X_X as im mapping at this very instant,but just checking to see what the hack is looking like so far.
Map Name: HERATIO TOWN.

Map Game: Fire Red



Comments: Uhh, not much, used a tileset i found in the hackers resource (forgot name X_X) and uhh it'll be where you start for my hack (I'm redoing all maps with this tileset).

Ow Mannn, you used my rombase T_T
Anyways, the map doesn't look so good to me. Plenty of errors I could see there. The houses and some other stuff. The map is empty and you should not have added the grass all over the place. You're border has also got a problem.
5/10

 

[Melash]

Okay, here are some more maps:
Hack Name: Awakened Legends
Hack of: Gold
Map Name: Cove Island

Okay, in my hack, Awakened Legends, instead of the Kanto Region, (Which got destroyed! Yes! Wait, how good of an idea is that...?) there's a different region (no name yet) that is made up of islands. This is an island that is more of a...er...comfty one. You know? Well, anyway, there are two legendaries here. The bottom path leads to Celebi's Forest (not the name!) and the bridge leads to Moltrase's Cave (no name yet!)

Map Name: Reef Island

Okay, this is the first city you arrive after you take the boat from Jhoto. Nothing else to say about it!

Map Name: Mewtwo Cave

This is the cave where Mewtwo resides. NOTE: There is supposed to be a cave entrance in the right corner. I forgot to put it in!

Enjoy!

 

[Tyrantrum]

Here's my map:

Spoiler:

Plz rate and comment! ^^