Map Rating/Review Thread

[Likewise]

okay this is the first map of my hack pokemon deep blue/transform


yes i know that there are some errors this is just a rough copy of it
please rate!

 

[Lollypop]

okay this is the first map of my hack pokemon deep blue/transform


yes i know that there are some errors this is just a rough copy of it
please rate!

With errors 4/10
Without caring about errors 8/10.

I like the shape of the map. The shape is pretty good too.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Dude, don't post unfinished maps. Ya know, half of the points are for how the map actually is...
2/10 because you're lazy.

_____________________
Now, this is my map. It's a peninsula...
Oh, by the way, that grass has something special so...yeah.
*image removed*

 

[.Iramet]

name: the final gym leaders house
game:ruby
comments:if i make a hack this will be in it
thanks to vincent for inserting the tiles ^_^

 

[Mr.Fury]

Thank you for the help...I will try to find them.
I made another map, it took a while, i like the outcome, but seeing as this is my second map, im not an expert.
Please rate 1-10 and add constructive critiscm. ^_^

Name: Edmond's Crossing (*shrugs*)
ROM: FireRed
Orginal: The water below pallet town, forgot what the route is called.

 

[.Iramet]

sorry for posting it twice i didnt think the first one worked

 

[Netdot5]

Rating: 6/10
Reason: I like it, Mr.Fury. The way that everything flows on your map. I just don't like how the 2-story house looks. That may just be me, though. Everything else is good, though.
Suggestions: So, just find a way to fix that house. Oh, and when going on that ladder/stairway up the rock the one stairway that is more of at the top of the rock doesn't look so good.

Rating: 4/10
Reason: It just looks boring, emoakt. It's not good to leave empty grass in some places.
Suggestions: Maybe add some flowers or trees or something in some of those empty spaces.

Map Name: Rodiok Island
Game: Fire Red
Comments: This is my second try at making this map. This time I started from scratch, so I could get it too look like the sketch I made. The island revolves around that little PoKeFarm right there.

Spoiler:

 

[.Iramet]

thanks for the comments ill do that netdot5 and i think your map is 6.5/10
because there is a mis map with the fence in back of the two doored house?
and you could probably get rid of one of the docks.
^_^
also the ridges are kinda weird lookin lined up like that

 

[Mr.Fury]

Thank you for the help!
I really didnt like the house either so im gonna fill that space with trees and stuff, but i will leave the pokecenter and mart...and im not sure what you are talking about with the mountain.
When i am finished i will post another pic, but with sprites ^_^

@ your map.
7/10 I really like the flow of it, but it seems to big and there is a lot of open space, so perhaps fill it with more stuff or just make it smaller, and maybe a little less square. other than that its really good.

 

[.Iramet]

I edited the colors and i added a few things please rate ^_^
i also changed the sprites a bit

 

[Austinia]

I give it an 7.7/10 :) (emoakt)

 

[Mr.Fury]

Hello again fellas!
I have edited my two maps to my liking, hope they are to yours as well.
1-10 please. :D

Name: Sequil Village
Rom: Fire Red
Original: Pallet Town


Name: Edmond's Crossing
Rom: Fire Red
Original: Ocean bellow Pallet Town

 

[Austinia]

Route 409 for my hack ^_~ tell me your opinions!

 

[Tyrantrum]

I love the shape! :D
The only problem is, that when u jump down on certain parts, u will jump down on top of the ledges...9/10

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Nah, he can set it so it won't jump.

Anyway, here's another mappy!

 

[Chimchar 9]

here iv just made a map its for pokemon ever night hope you like it



please rate

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Galiel Town (Littelroot Town)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: Just made it
(My II Map) I'm Begginer =/

Mapshot:

 

[Tyrantrum]

here iv just made a map its for pokemon ever night hope you like it



please rate

I do love ur map! :D
The only problem is, u can still get past those rocks and get to the border line. :\
Anyways...9/10

 

[Luck]

Nah, he can set it so it won't jump.

Anyway, here's another mappy!

I don't really like this map.
Its obvious that you either edited pewter city or made it to look like it.
it doesn't have errors, but it is empty but gets really crowded.
at least try to make it look less like pewter city.
6.5/10 for similarity
Suggestions: make the map look less like pewter city, and don't make it so empty in some areas but crowded in others.

here iv just made a map its for pokemon ever night hope you like it



please rate

this map is really empty.
there are few trees other than near the border, the mountains all follow the same exact path and don't even move away from each other at least once, the ledge idea is stupid, as is the fence idea.
5/10 for dullness.

Suggestions: Make more mountains, put trees in more places than the border, don't put all the rocks in a row, the ledges just seem stupid, how they are right next to each other, the huge fence line seems really random, and the ocean line is square.
A lot of it just doesn't seem natural. I'm dissapointed in you riolu 9. You could make much better maps than this.

Map Name: Galiel Town (Littelroot Town)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: Just made it
(My II Map) I'm Begginer =/

Mapshot:

The flowers are in a row, the area seems just plain boring, and the fences just don't seem necessary to me. However, its supposed to be the first town, so emptiness is expected.
7.5/10
suggestions: It seems crowded, so you should take a house out. Spread the flowers out because it doesn't look natural. And don't use unnecessary fences.

 

[Chimchar 9]

yeah i know i can make better maps but i havent had any support from anyone in ages so my maps have gone wrong and nobody supports my hacks the just let me down by saying you have too many hacks and thats what lets me down aw