Map Rating/Review Thread

[~Areku-San]

Hi n_n.
Is my 1st post in this thread.
I present my 2 best maps of the Second Beta of my Hack, Pokemon Darkblue.

The Fire gym. (With Switches, it changes the lasers)

The Saka-Mizu Falls
Other Map. With a second map variation. (With Water, i do not the map yet)

EDIT:
My 1600th Post. jojo :P

 

[HungryGengar]

Hi n_n.
Is my 1st post in this thread.
I present my 2 best maps of the Second Beta of my Hack, Pokemon Darkblue.

The Fire gym. (With Switches, it changes the lasers)

Wow, lex this map is great! I love how you placed the lasers, and also the lava, but you should change the palettes, of the floor, put it like green or something or gray.
Cool map!
9/10

The Saka-Mizu Falls
Other Map. With a second map variation. (With Water, i do not the map yet)

Cool! Map I love the mazes in it also the placement fo the rocks.
Awesome palettes too, though they look like if it was already filled with water:P
9.5/10

 

[Islander Jon]

Map Name: Route 1 (New)
Game: Pokémon Sunset (Name Pending)

Here's a Map for a New Game I'm working on called Pokémon Sunset, which is supposed to be a Pokémon Orange Islands Remake. Anyone, please rate! :)

P.S. I've realized the tree tile errors. I plan to edit those later :)

Also, the PokéCenter and PokéMart are there just for visual purposes. I've realized that you can't enter them. AND the end of the route leads somewhere...just sayin' ;)

 

[Neti]

Hi n_n.
Is my 1st post in this thread.
I present my 2 best maps of the Second Beta of my Hack, Pokemon Darkblue.

The Fire gym. (With Switches, it changes the lasers)

The Saka-Mizu Falls
Other Map. With a second map variation. (With Water, i do not the map yet)

EDIT:
My 1600th Post. jojo :P

absolutely beuatiful tiles! did you make them on yourself?
and the maps are brilliant as well
goodluck with your hack!

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Gorip Town

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Just made it.
Rate it quickly.
Thanks ^_^

Mapshot:

 

[Chimchar 9]

map name : route 1 duh
gamebase:ruby
comments:iv inserted a few tiles and im trying to get better at mapping ruby cause ruby isnt my game to hack so anyway please rate

map:

 

[Likewise]

map name : route 1 duh
gamebase:ruby
comments:iv inserted a few tiles and im trying to get better at mapping ruby cause ruby isnt my game to hack so anyway please rate

map:

the route itself is good but i don't really like the color of the tiles, with that said...
9/10 just the route
6/10 the tiles.

 

[Osher99]

map name : route 1 duh
gamebase:ruby
comments:iv inserted a few tiles and im trying to get better at mapping ruby cause ruby isnt my game to hack so anyway please rate

map:

Really good map I like the tilles 8/10

BTW:

Some1 can rate my map?

https://www.pokecommunity.com/posts/3839943/

 

[Tyrantrum]

Sentas Village

 

[Blazichu]

Sentas Village

Maybe add an outline to the smaller trees and the shrubs; and use some new houses that suit the DP style. Other then that the map is fine. So I'll give it an 8/10.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Wow!
Thanks for rating my map Blazichu! :D
But, what do you mean by: "Maybe add an outline to the smaller trees and the shrubs"? :\

 

[Blazichu]

Wow!
Thanks for rating my map Blazichu! :D
But, what do you mean by: "Maybe add an outline to the smaller trees and the shrubs"? :\

Add a darker outline to the smaller trees and shrubs to make them stand out more, like the DP style trees.

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Gorip Town

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Any1 Rate it !!

Mapshot:

 

[HungryGengar]

Map Name: Gorip Town

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Any1 Rate it !!

Mapshot:

Well this map is too square, the placement of the buildings is kinda like parallel, the lake is too big but it is good, no tile errors, well, the only bad thing is that is too square, I rate it with 6/10

 

[+Sneasel™]

Sentas Village

I like the map a lot! It's not square, has no tile errors. The only thing I'm wondering is why put the path into the trees? Well, anyway, 9/10 until I find out the reason behind the path into the trees ;)

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanks! :D
-----------------
Well, the ips patch for Emerald finally worked, so I got to make a map with this Rom Base! :D

Does anyone remember this Rom Base? ;)

Spoiler:

 

[maoh4567]

Map Name: (No name) cave
Map Game: FireRed
Comments: This is my first map post, i made this map for my upcoming hack. pls rate this one, i will also accept any comments or suggestions :D

 

[Neti]

this is your first map? wow^^
its better than some peoples 10th map xD
there might be problems with the elevations where the mountains hover each other, i think at the bottom theres a mistake
but you have a lot of details on the map and its not squarish
also youve added an additonal path which you can only go with a hm, most ppl forget about that possibility
you could add more rocks (even big ones that consist of 4 or more mountain tiles) onto the path, to make it a bit more winded
but for a first map its really damn good!
7/10

 

[maoh4567]

this is your first map? wow^^
its better than some peoples 10th map xD
there might be problems with the elevations where the mountains hover each other, i think at the bottom theres a mistake
but you have a lot of details on the map and its not squarish
also youve added an additonal path which you can only go with a hm, most ppl forget about that possibility
you could add more rocks (even big ones that consist of 4 or more mountain tiles) onto the path, to make it a bit more winded
but for a first map its really damn good!
7/10

thnx for ur suggestions Neti XD, ive created another map again...
Map Name: Spring Village
Game:FireRed
Comments: The starter town in my hack... pls rate,comment or suggest

 

[Chimchar 9]

iv made a map but a bit small but oh well

rom map :fire red

map :

please rate