Map Rating/Review Thread

[~Teh Panda~]

Hmm 7.5/10
I don't really like the fact you can only go through the town one way, It seems though it might get a bit tedious trekking back around to get to above the town.

But other than that it seems nice.

EDIT:

Just a small island, don't know weather it will be used.

Hmmm.... 4.8
There are some map errors that I caught at first, also it is a bit plane overall and square
Also the stairs are not much appealing

Remember my map is only the first town ;) So you can't go to the town above or route yet, but once you get fly it will be easy to get around, do not fret.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I see someone doesn't know how to put a link.

Anyway, here is my first map in awile. There are a few things I need to fix before going further. This is the starting town in my hack. It is SUPPOSED to be big. So anyone who goes "IT 2 BIG!!1!1!" is a moron.

Taty Town

Good map. I like the shape, the grass and whatnot...:P Not much to say, but the sand is a bit funky mixed with the land...
:P
7/10

And besides, every map made by Nintendo is bad, and we didn't follow that.

Excuse me while I point you to the mountains in R/S/E and the Sevii Islands in FR/LG. >_> And I do. To some extent.

 

[Neti]

View my attachment. It should hopefully clear it up a bit.

@Gundam-Fighter

Who made the rule that a starting town can't be too big? Just because Nintendo does it, doesn't mean we have to follow in their footsteps. And besides, every map made by Nintendo is bad, and we didn't follow that. We kept progressing while Nintendo stayed the same in the making of FireRed.

Not every map by Nintendo is bad, just most of them :p
i like Sevault Canyon a lot, i tried to do something similiar a few times but never suceeded

 

[Gundam-Fighter]

View my attachment. It should hopefully clear it up a bit.

@Gundam-Fighter

Who made the rule that a starting town can't be too big? Just because Nintendo does it, doesn't mean we have to follow in their footsteps. And besides, every map made by Nintendo is bad, and we didn't follow that. We kept progressing while Nintendo stayed the same in the making of FireRed.

The fact that it's TOO big sort of sums it up why it shouldn't be.

 

[Geeked]

Map Name: Nestle Forest
Map Game: Fire Red
Map Time: 2-3 days(on-off)
Map Shot:

 

[Hiche..]

Map Name: Nestle Forest
Map Game: Fire Red
Map Time: 2-3 days(on-off)
Map Shot:

Overall, the map is well-done indeed.
First, I like the placement of the trees; Large trees, and small ones. The grass is also placed good.
Second, the paths' shape, and direction is great, and not straight. However, there aren't so much flowers, scatter more.
Rating: 8.5/10

 

[KING KRIS]

https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3092530373/

 

[Cheesymitten]

https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3092530373/

8.5 liked the creativity and the idea flowing out of this .Question the two supermassieve :P (not that big but still a little harsh on the eye) holes are they for anything to go for if they are you might want to build it on a mountain of some sort keep it up :)

 

[KING KRIS]

thanks chaasy mittens :) new map https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3093926064/

 

[Geeked]

https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3092530373/

OMFG Take that rom and put it out of it's misery!
That map is horrible, the shape is crappy, there's a dozen tile errors! Nothing good to say about this map
0.3/10

thanks chaasy mittens :) new map https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3093926064/

Same goes for this! WTF? The whole map is a tile Error! I've never given this before, but there's a first for everything!
0/10

I'm sorry for being harsh, but constructive criticism will make you a better mapper..

 

[TB Pro]

https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3092530373/

Rating: 0/10
Why the heck? Everything is wrong, with the exception of the houses. The whole entire map is one large tile error. The mountain is completely straight.It's just not good.

thanks chaasy mittens :) new map https://www.flickr.com/photos/31707036@N05/3093926064/

Rating: 0/10
Why the heck? As I said above, exactly the same problems.

 

[~Teh Panda~]

New Map edit

Map Name: Marshell Town, first town in Oblivion

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

View my attachment. It should hopefully clear it up a bit.

ok fixed the waterfall edges and the back a bit.

:edit:
I think I forgot to do the edges on in at the bottom of the middle waterfall

 

[Surf]

Yo all you mappers
Well heres a rare map from me since I'm a scripter

Map name: New Bark Town
Map Game: Pokemon Dusk Gold(ohh a pre-make!)
Comments: Please excuse the tile errors in the trees on the lab it's hard to change the tree

Map:

Credits:
Me for inserting the tiles
Kyledove for the Tiles and Pallets
Punk Rocker for the base

I suck at mapping my own style so I'm making a re-make

Mac_Mini
The worst mapper at PC

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Yo all you mappers
Well heres a rare map from me since I'm a scripter

Map name: New Bark Town
Map Game: Pokemon Dusk Gold(ohh a pre-make!)
Comments: Please excuse the tile errors in the trees on the lab it's hard to change the tree

Map:

Credits:
Me for inserting the tiles
Kyledove for the Tiles and Pallets
Punk Rocker for the base

I suck at mapping my own style so I'm making a re-make

Mac_Mini
The worst mapper at PC

Good but, those little houses are ugly :\ sorry 6.5/10

Final Map Edit

 

[Surf]

Good but, those little houses are ugly :\ sorry 6.5/10

Final Map Edit

Interesting i like the trees and the kyledove trainer school and the paths
8\10

EDIT- The grass has no point really I'd recomend removing it

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Interesting i like the trees and the kyledove trainer school and the paths
8\10

EDIT- The grass has no point really I'd recomend removing it

Regarding my map to Mod's

You cannot see this in game (grass) so I just filled the area up

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I'm sorry for being harsh, but constructive criticism will make you a better mapper..

Very constructive. Yeah, saying to put the ROM out of it's misery is VERY constructive.

King Kris, take a look at R/S/E's original mapping, and at other maps around here. Get a good idea of...well, how NOT to map and how to map. Then, fix up the map and we'll all give you a proper rating. :P

 

[Hiche..]

Good but, those little houses are ugly :\ sorry 6.5/10

Final Map Edit

All in all, the map is outstanding. :D
I really like the new trees you used. Kyedolove tiles are inserted pretty good. I like the street tiles, which I presume, you made, no?

Rating: 8.4/10

 

[Gundam-Fighter]

Sorry for the bold. I just wanted it to stand out, I guess.

Why can't a town have grass? Honestly, it's more of an island than a town, and you would expect it to be uninhabited by people, and to have plenty of wild things. There's also a thing called "people events", and I believe that t.A.T.u. could make like a flying Pokémon that could take you out of that town, or a boat, perhaps. And, honestly, that's about a minutes' walk from one house to another. Don't you spend about that much time in a route or a large city, anyways? I think you're just feeling lazy inside. ^^

And, as another point that I just now noticed, the grass doesn't begin until you get to the lab. There's a single spot to walk through, so one might assume that t.A.T.u. would put in a script to prevent you from getting there until you go through the lab and get your Pokémon.

The place is called Taty Town, therefore it's a town.
It's a town so it will have people.
I said that there was nothing noticeable. I didn't say there was nothing.
One minutes walk in pokemon is too long for a town it's fine for a city just not a town.
That's not my point though. There shouldn't be grass in a Town. It's a social area.