Map Rating/Review Thread

[Makorin]

Map Name: Macneil Village
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Tiles - Nintendo

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

This is just a slight alteration to a map I posted before. I'm not sure if there are too many flowers, tell me what you think.

WOW!
Rating:
Shape: 10/10 100% Awesome
Water Shape: 0/0 No Water!
Physical Features: 5/5 100% Awesome
Building Placement: 5/5 100% Awesome
Tile Errors: 4.5/5 90% Awesome
Playability: 10/10 100% Awesome
My Feelings: 10/10 100% Awesome
Total: 9.8/10 98% A :shocked:

Why?:
Shape: Awesome Shape: No Flaws!
Water Shape: None
Physical Features: Nice placement of Flowers and Bushes! Also the small Trees! :D Also love the paths
Building Placement: Great placement I dont see any problems with it!
Tile Errors: only thing i see is a problem with the Red Roof... The shaded bars arent on it
Playibility: Enough Space to move with events this is awesome!
My Feelings: This is nice work keep it up! I would love to play on this map!

 

[Pokepal17]

A redo of the starter town for my hack. Please note that the Suicune is meant to be there as part of an event and the Snorlax is there for a wildbattle. Please comment and rate.
Game: Fire Red
Map Name: Wilderbud Town
Tiles: Credits to Nintendo

 

[Makorin]

A redo of the starter town for my hack. Please note that the Suicune is meant to be there as part of an event and the Snorlax is there for a wildbattle. Please comment and rate.
Game: Fire Red
Map Name: Wilderbud Town
Tiles: Credits to Nintendo

Spoiler:

Getting better... :\

Spoiler:

Shape: 1/10 10% Bad
Water Shape: 2/5 40% Poor
Physical Features: 4/5 80% Good
Building Placment 4.5/5 90% Good
Tile Errors: 5/5 100% Awesome
Playability: 6/10 60% Poor
My Feelings: 8/10 80% Bad
Total: 6.5/10 65% D :\

Why?:
Shape: Still Square...
Water Shape: nice but how r u supposed to get into the lab? it will mess up and you will land on the door as if its ground... at least have one space...
Physical Features: Pretty spaced out... getting better!
Building Placement: see Water Shape
Tile Errors: None that I see, but, just a suggestion, use different grass tiles... :)
Playibility: Still to easy to play through... (but craming it isnt good either)
My Feelings: Getting better i think your promblem with the shape it that the width is still to skiny (and maybe your copying Nintendo)

 

[пзо]

Worst map?

This has go to be one of my worst maps I will ever post.
Map name: Does it look like a city or town. Dont know.
Map of: Fire Red.
Comments: Any Tile errors, or anything please rate.

 

[negative]

Hi! I have a new map! It's the Starting town of Pokemon Clossal Version!
Map name: Allblues Town
Time:30min(maybe less)
What is What?:The Green arrow:First Path
The Pink arrow:The Path to 7th town via Surf
The Blue arrow: Path back to town via Rock Climb

Credits:
Me
Disturbed-Rombase and all that goes with it
Kyledove-Tiles
Sourav-Tiles
Weasley FG-Tiles

 

[Geeked]

Map Name: Verdanda City (2nd City in Crimson)
Map Game: Fire Red
Map Time: 2 hrs
Comments: You enter the town from the Cave, A Major Event Occurs here.
Map Shot:

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Hi! I have a new map! It's the Starting town of Pokemon Clossal Version!
Map name: Allblues Town
Time:30min(maybe less)
What is What?:The Green arrow:First Path
The Pink arrow:The Path to 7th town via Surf
The Blue arrow: Path back to town via Rock Climb

Credits:
Me
Disturbed-Rombase and all that goes with it
Kyledove-Tiles
Sourav-Tiles
Weasley FG-Tiles

Nice tiles 8)

The map is great, but the sandy path is a little too straight.
And the fence on the upper part makes no sense...

8/10

 

[Makorin]

Map Name: Verdanda City (2nd City in Crimson)
Map Game: Fire Red
Map Time: 2 hrs
Comments: You enter the town from the Cave, A Major Event Occurs here.
Map Shot:

Spoiler:

Nice Map!

Spoiler:

Shape: 10/10 100% Awesome
Water Shape: 0/0 No Water!
Physical Features: 5/5 100% Awesome
Building Placement: 5/5 100% Awesome
Tile Errors: 4.5/5 90% Awesome
Playability: 10/10 100% Awesome
My Feelings: 10/10 100% Awesome
Total: 9.8/10 98% A :shocked:

Why?:
Shape: Awesome Shape: No Flaws! (to my perspective)
Water Shape: None
Physical Features: Nice placement of Flowers and Bushes! Also the Trees! Also love the path placment!
Building Placement: Great placement I dont see any problems with it!
Tile Errors: only thing i see is a small tree's top takin out by a flower (house left hand top corner)
Playibility: Enough Space to move I bet with events its awesome!
My Feelings: This is nice work keep it up! It makes me want to play your hack!

 

[Larsie13]

Well, since nobody rated my previous map, I'm reposting, with more edits than last time.

Map Name: Docksville
Map Game: Emerald
Comments: None
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Mortar]

Map Name: Verdanda City (2nd City in Crimson)
Map Game: Fire Red
Map Time: 2 hrs
Comments: You enter the town from the Cave, A Major Event Occurs here.
Map Shot:

Very nice, but I'd use more variety in the paths, like adding some grass paths.

ROM: Fire Red
Map time: About 1 hour
Comments: Entrance to a big ass mountain called MT. CHERBA. You can see it'll be a large mountain by the amount of doors/stairs.
Map:

 

[Disturbed]

Well everyone, I made a Neti Styled Map!
This isn't gonna be used in anything, so it's up for grabs.
Anyways, credits to X-Buster for the base.

Spoiler:

Edit: Better Quality

 

[Makorin]

Well everyone, I made a Neti Styled Map!
This isn't gonna be used in anything, so it's up for grabs.
Anyways, credits to X-Buster for the base.

Spoiler:

Edit: Better Quality

How is it a Neti Styled map?
Anyway I will take that! Thank-you very much! XD
Rating

Spoiler:

Shape: 10/10 100% Awesome
Water Shape: 0/0 No Water!
Physical Features: 5/5 100% Awesome
Building Placement: 0/0 No Buildings
Tile Errors: 5/5 100% Awesome
Playability: 10/10 100% Awesome
My Feelings: 10/10 100% Awesome
Total: 10/10 100% A :D

Why?:
Shape: Awesome Shape: No Flaws! (to my perspective)
Water Shape: None
Physical Features: Nice placement of Flowers and Bushes! Also the Trees!
Building Placement: None
Tile Errors: None
Playibility: Enough Space to move I bet with events it could be awesome!
My Feelings: This is nice work keep it up! Again I'm taking this!

 

[Geeked]

Map Name: Mt. Crookar Floor 1
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: First Cave in Crimson, Just the First Floor.. I wont show the Second & Third to prevent too much from being spoiled..
Map Shot:

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Map Name: Mt. Crookar Floor 1
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: First Cave in Crimson, Just the First Floor.. I wont show the Second & Third to prevent too much from being spoiled..
Map Shot:

I think there's a bit too much sand.

It's got wonderful shape, however, and it's quite mazy, like a mountain cavern should be. :D

9/10.

I'm getting confused now, between you and Disturbed. >.<

 

[Sean Visinoni]

Name: Lamia
Edited by: Me ^^
Rom: Pkmn Destiny - Mycenaean Prince
what? First City

i'm sorry for the quality that is not best...

 

[Disturbed]

Map Name: Mt. Crookar Floor 1
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: First Cave in Crimson, Just the First Floor.. I wont show the Second & Third to prevent too much from being spoiled..
Map Shot:

Well, Xray, I'm impressed. Some of the stuff seems a tad too repetitive (i.e. the 4 blocked boulders) and can easily be expanded or replaced. One other thing, there seems to be a tad too much sand. Also, a couple tile errors spotted as well. ><
Congrats, the highest rating I've ever given ya 8.7/10

Name: Lamia
Edited by: Me ^^
Rom: Pkmn Destiny - Mycenaean Prince
what? First City

I'm sorry for the quality that is not best...

Well, I'll quickly give this a 6.1, because of empty space.
Also, the main reason I'm rating this is to tell you a trick on how to get flawless quality. When saving the map picture (tools > Save Map Picture) just write down it's name without any suffixes (i.e. .png, .jpeg)
It will be saved in .DIB quality. Now, photobucket doesn't allow this form, so now we need to change it to a png. Simply open it up in Paint, and do a regular File > Save As, and it would automatically be a jpeg. Click the thing that says jpeg to change the file type to png.
There ya go, perfect image quality. ^^

 

[TB Pro]

Name: Lamia
Edited by: Me ^^
Rom: Pkmn Destiny - Mycenaean Prince
what? First City

i'm sorry for the quality that is not best...

Rating 4/10
Why the Heck? First off, the path is utterly straight...that's a no-no, that sort of straightness is used for the paths in big cities, not natural ones. The map is almost entirely square...which is bad. All the corners(except one) are right angles...besides that, there is one straight row of trees on all sides but one. There is a ton of empty space...bad. The mountain looks as if it was only placed there as a space-filler, it dosen't blend with the map at all.
Comments 80% of the tiles you used are Kyledove's unusable tiles...do not use them.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Please rate this map:

Map name: Tripletwig Town
Base ROM: Firered English (BPRE)
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Mapshot:

Comments: Red house - your house, Blue house - rival's house, upper building - gallery
Credits: rhevarhe_duh, Wesley FG for tiles

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Please rate this map:

Map name: Tripletwig Town
Base ROM: Firered English (BPRE)
Hack: Pokemon Turquoise
Mapshot:

Comments: Red house - your house, Blue house - rival's house, upper building - gallery
Credits: rhevarhe_duh, Wesley FG for tiles

Interesting...

I give it 8/10. I like the shape, and the trees are well placed. However, saying that, are you meant to be able to get to the left of the map below the mountain ridge?
There is also a bit of free space, but not too much.

 

[Disturbed]

Birolis City

I found this map today, which I believe I made sometime in early December. I guess back then I had a use for it so I didn't post it... and now I don't see any need to keep a map made in like 20 minutes.

Birolis City
Status: Up for grabs :P
Credits to Punk Rocker for rombase

Spoiler: