Pidgeot, Fearow, or Noctowl?

[Chernobyl.112]

I'm having a hard time deciding. Just wanted to know which one you guys/girls prefer and why.

 

[RyanGT]

Noctowl is definitely the coolest looking. As for a battling, I'm not sure.

 

[Porygon Z]

Noctowl it's the best choice, he also has the Psychic Type.
But i awlays prefered Pidgeot :D

 

[bunnyricebowl]

Noctowl! :) Fearow aren't that great and Pidgeot is cool but Noctowl is better.

 

[Weavile1110101]

I like Noctowl best, if just for hypnosis and its special defense.

But Pidgeot is probably better competitively...:knockedou

 

[Sydian]

I like Noctowl because owls are cool.

Spoiler:

 

[Kozoi]

I think Dodrio is better than all of them as a Normal/Flying type in HeartGold/SoulSilver, but since you didn't list it I guess I will say Pidgeot. Pidgeot is pretty darn cool... It's really good for people of all skill levels and has balanced stats.

 

[Butterfree-Charizard]

Well in HG/SS this is the ultimate question, but as far as I'm concerned they all suck. But since you Noctowl is the coolest.

 

[Guy]

Even though this has to deal with what you should choose, I'll move it on over the Pokémon General where threads on comparisons between similar Pokémon are found more suitable. I say I prefer Pidgeot over Fearow and Noctowl though. Personally, I see it with the best design over the other two, and I've always liked it before. If Swellow was one of the options though, then my answer would have been different.

 

[JAK3]

Pshh, Fearow! He is awesome! He is fast, and Strong, problem is, he is very bad in Defense, so he goes down fast! But, he does hit hard, so the Opposing Pokemon may go down.

 

[Hypno]

Noctowl, because it is a Psychic too, then Pidgeot... I just don't like Fearow at all, they should replace Spearow for Doduo for the beginning parts.

 

[EmeraldSerenade]

Noctowl. I love how mysterious it looks... Reminds me of the Tootsie Pop owl xD

 

[Thorns]

Fearow, not only since everybody seems to not like it, but I use it in all my Kanto games. XD

 

[nm legend]

noctowl....because i had a shiny one.... i think it was gold....this was years ago tho

 

[Cid]

I like Noctowl because owls are cool.

Spoiler:

I laughed out loud. xD
I like owls, too, but only my bro likes Noctowl over my fave.

I would have chosen Pidgeot, but Fearow always got me to pick it instead. He was my Flyer whenever he was available in a Pokemon game, and the Pokemon species just holds a lot of memories.

 

[coolcatkim22]

Hm, that's hard... I'm going to go with Noctowl though because he's an owl but epic.
Pidgeot and Fearow are too but Noctowl beats them by a smege.

 

[Crobat]

i had to go with noctowl also.. it knows psychic moves not only flying

 

[Leo™]

I would go with Pidgeot, but because it's one of my personal favorites of the flying Pokemon.

You should go with Noctowl, because it knows psychic moves and it will be helpful against some trainers.

 

[chezhead]

I like Pidgiot. They fly high, are graceful, and generally OWN everything.

 

[SinisterEternity]

I had to say Pidgeot, because they're reminding me of Eagles !