Pidgeot, Fearow, or Noctowl?

[Mifune]

Noctowl. Love the hypnosis. Lol

 

[PiPVoda]

Pidgeot. Fearow is IMO ugly and only good for KOing to get exp. points for your pkmn. Noctowl is alright but I prefer Pidgeot over it.

 

[Emlam]

Fearow's got the advantage when it comes to Attack and Speed, so in the game I'll take Fearow over Pidgeot.

In looks, I'll take the falcon/cockatoo over the vulture/chicken any day.

I've never had the opportunity to use Noctowl, but I still think Pidgeot is just a little bit cooler.

 

[Timbjerr]

Noctowl. Access to psychic attacks is just too damn smexy to hate. :D

 

[grey†fish]

1) Fearow
2) Pidgeot
3) Noctowl

…that's just me though :\

 

[Alkaide]

I've always preferred Pidgeot, I advice you the same.

 

[derozio]

I prefer Pidgeot over both Fearow and Nocktowl. It's got a better design, IMO. So yeah. xD;

 

[SiReNzZ]

I think that Pidgeot is the best of the three .
I dont think Fearow looks good at all :/
As for Noctowl I guess I havent used it much to choose it as my favorite of the three :) .

 

[shengar]

Although i'm bored of using Pidgeot as my main Flying pokemon, my vote goes for it

 

[Serene Grace]

Even though this has to deal with what you should choose, I'll move it on over the Pokémon General where threads on comparisons between similar Pokémon are found more suitable. I say I prefer Pidgeot over Fearow and Noctowl though. Personally, I see it with the best design over the other two, and I've always liked it before. If Swellow was one of the options though, then my answer would have been different.

What he said! XD; Pidgeot has the best aesthetics but it's really hard to raise early on. The rest are "meh" for me.

 

[Agent Clank]

I like Noctowl The best cause he is cool and strong.

 

[Elise]

Out of the three choices I would choose Pidgeot. Not super hard to raise and generally a good flyer to have on your team. I usually have one on my team, depending on the game :)

 

[Rapide]

I prefer Pigeot because it can learn many attacks, it has a high speed base stat, and it looks pretty cool.

 

[Dawn Rules]

Noctowl is the best then Fearow then Pidgeot.

 

[KnilShadowLink]

Noctowl it's the best choice, he also has the Psychic Type.
But i awlays prefered Pidgeot :D

Erm you realize that Noctowl isn't Psychic, right?

Anyways I vote Fearow...Pidgeot is okay, but I think Pidgeotto is much cooler...anyways Noctowl is fairly good, but I prefer Fearow out of this trio...

 

[Aether]

Noctowl hands down. Owls are awesome and Noctowl completely wrecks ghosts.

 

[Porygon-Z]

If it's for battling, you should go with Swellow instead of any of these 3, it's much better!!

However of the 3, I prefer Fearow!

 

[Eeohnex]

I don't know why but I prefer Pidgeot, it's maybe because it was one of the first Pokémon to appeared in the anime, and when it evolves into Pidgeot it's a beast.

 

[Dr. Faustus]

When it comes to movepool, I'd choose Noctowl, he learns Hypnosis and Psychic moves, which complement his [mediocre] Sp.Atk.
When it comes to stats, it'd be Fearow. Fearow has higher Speed and Attack, but he has lower defenses than Pidgeot. Pidgeot has more HP and defenses (not that it matters for him, anyway. He can't take a hit. Heck, none of them can.), but less Speed and Attack.

 

[Mumfie]

I'd have to say Pidgeot, for good old sentimental reasons. 1st gen.