• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Red/Blue remakes on 3DS

NO.

Those games are, simply put, outdated. The only way Gamefreak could get away with creating another Kanto remake is by overhauling the region further than they did in HGSS.

This is why I also hope the new Hoenn games aren't strict remakes.

Also love the people saying Kanto has already been remade while Hoenn hasn't. Kanto's remake is on the same level as the original Hoenn games nowadays: bad. If Hoenn gets an overhaul, and one in 3D, so could Kanto. Besides, of course Kanto gets more spotlight than other regions. It was where Pokémon started after all. That being said, it already got a new anime, so I'm positive they won't remake it in the foreseeable future.

Anyway, I think at this point a Kanto remake would only be feasible if they threw in Johto as well. The two regions are intertwined.
 
Last edited:
Cerberus87 said:
NO.

Those games are, simply put, outdated. The only way Gamefreak could get away with creating another Kanto remake is by overhauling the region further than they did in HGSS.

This is why I also hope the new Hoenn games aren't strict remakes.

Also love the people saying Kanto has already been remade while Hoenn hasn't. Kanto's remake is on the same level as the original Hoenn games nowadays: bad. If Hoenn gets an overhaul, and one in 3D, so could Kanto. Besides, of course Kanto gets more spotlight than other regions. It was where Pokémon started after all. That being said, it already got a new anime, so I'm positive they won't remake it in the foreseeable future.

Anyway, I think at this point a Kanto remake would only be feasible if they threw in Johto as well. The two regions are intertwined.
Click to expand...

Well they are marketing it as a new world so it may not be Hoenn. I also agree, both sets needs to be completely redone now.
 
Khrysta said:
Well they are marketing it as a new world so it may not be Hoenn. I also agree, both sets needs to be completely redone now.
Click to expand...

Now wouldn't that be wonderful. Hoenn remakes that don't take place in Hoenn. The fanboys would rage. ^^
 
Cerberus87 said:
Now wouldn't that be wonderful. Hoenn remakes that don't take place in Hoenn. The fanboys would rage. ^^
Click to expand...

Lol sites like TV tropes actually put the trope Fan Dumb in YMMV under Ruby and Sapphire for those who thought that they wouldn't take place in Hoenn xD.

I think the next in line are DP remakes in terms of remakes, and those are likely next gen, or two from now.
 
I expect Gen 4 remakes on whatever the next portable that can't play DS and below will be. And then Gen 2 and Gen 5 will also get remakes, and maybe Gen 1.

Though, if they remake Gen 2, then there won't be any need to remake Gen 1 since you have Kanto right there - as it is now HGSS has all the dungeons and legendaries from Kanto in the Gen 2 story. So we don't need another Gen 1 remake and I wouldn't mind if they never go that route, ever - Gen 1 is defined, in my opinion, by its bugs and strange design choices. FRLG removed both and Kanto's more than a little boring without them (FRLG did not fix this, which was a mistake IMO, but eh. We know how Nintendo and its partners operate.)
 
A couple of things that would make a 3D Gen 1 Remake AWESOME:

- Have the additional evolutions to the Kanto Pokemon available as HG/SS did.
- Have the first member of your party follow you around like HG/SS did.
- Have a massive post-game including not only the Events on the Sevii Islands, but also the Orange Islands (and Orange League) and Access to the Johto Region to bridge the gap between the Kanto and Johto Games (Johto gyms available with OP Pokemon).

This is, of course, in addition to all of the advancements in graphics and game mechanics introduced between Gens 4 and 6 (that goes without saying).
 
No. I don't want to see Kanto remakes at all. Ever.

What I would like to see is a return to a notably updated Kanto, for an entirely new story. And I actually think that would make sense and be pretty easily justified.

There have been enormous changes to the games since the Kanto originals. Kanto was sort of intended to be a mostly urban area (as contrasted to the more rural setting of Johto), but because of the limitations of the technology, it wasn't possible to make it feel really urban. It was just impossible to include enough buildings and NPCs and such. Now it is possible. And it's perfectly reasonable that in the time since the original stories, the region has grown to being a real metropolis.

And there has to be a way to fit in and explain away all of the new pokemon, since there are over four times as many of them now as there were then, and who better to investigate and/or explain away such staggering growth than Professor Oak? And it'd be great to revisit the old characters in updated forms.

So - a return to Kanto? Sure. A remake? No way. The originals (both the story and the region) were just too simple and they've already been faithfully remade once. If there's ever a time that GF should do an entirely new story in an old region, this is it.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I don't want to see another Kanto remake.

If they do decide to use the region again, I'd like another premise. I think that's the only thing that would justify using that again. Kanto's been in almost all generations except Gen 5. (RBGY,GSC,FRLG,HGSS)

But hey, if they do decide to do that, I'd like to see what's in it. But I really don't think another Kanto remake is necessary.
 
I wouldn't mind a remake of R/B, and I'll probably be disappointed if they don't come out with one eventually. FR/LG won't last forever, and they are starting to seem pretty dated, so another remake could be in order. I would prefer to have something a little more expanded, though, as I do feel like I've played through R/B a lot.

Kanto is one of my favorite regions (Johto is probably my favorite, with Kanto in second), and though we've been there a lot, I wouldn't mind revisiting. But I would like more of an expansion than the Sevii Islands this time around. Perhaps they could incorporate the Orange Islands from the anime, with new badges and things to do.
 
Imperator161 said:
I wouldn't mind a remake of R/B, and I'll probably be disappointed if they don't come out with one eventually. FR/LG won't last forever, and they are starting to seem pretty dated, so another remake could be in order. I would prefer to have something a little more expanded, though, as I do feel like I've played through R/B a lot.

Kanto is one of my favorite regions (Johto is probably my favorite, with Kanto in second), and though we've been there a lot, I wouldn't mind revisiting. But I would like more of an expansion than the Sevii Islands this time around. Perhaps they could incorporate the Orange Islands from the anime, with new badges and things to do.
Click to expand...


Maybe in the post-game they can open up a gateway to Johto and give us an opportunity to play out the events in the years leading up to the Johto games.
 
RoreyG said:
Maybe in the post-game they can open up a gateway to Johto and give us an opportunity to play out the events in the years leading up to the Johto games.
Click to expand...
I actually really like that idea. We've seen Kanto in multiple eras, but we've only seen Johto once (well, once plus a remake), and I think that there's a lot more that could be done with that region. Plus, since the two regions are already connected, it definitely wouldn't be unreasonable for GameFreak to allow access to Johto. We've been to Kanto after seeing Johto; why not the reverse?
 
We've already seen how Kanto looks on the DS (via HG/SS), so no need for a remake in that respect. There is the addition of the Fairy type to consider.

But in the end, we already have remakes of those games. R/B/Y was what started me on Pokemon; I absolutely love those games and the remakes of them. But I would not buy a 3DS remake of R/B. I'm happy with the remake I already have.

What I would buy is:
- a remake of Yellow version
- a sequel to R/B or an entirely new game set in Kanto
 
Maybe a sequel to R/B like many have said. Honestly, I'm pretty sick of Kanto. Just hearing the region name no longer brings nostalgia, but the "I'm so done with this" look upon my face.
 
I doubt we will get any more remakes after ORAS period. Sort of sequels or prequels, perhaps, but I doubt we will have any more remakes. If we do, when will we stop? Ten R/B/Y remakes? Sounds boring.


Hell, if anything, they'll release the original games on the Nintendo 3DS store with compatibility to PokeBank.
 
I've just finished another play through of Soul Silver and I have to admit, I am boreeeeeed senseless of Kanto! I love a remake as much as the next guy (Hoenn confirmmmmmmmmmmmmmed!!) but a remake of a remake is a bit silly...
 
I was thinking about this, again.


We've been able to go to Kanto from gen one to four. Only gen five and six have not allowed us to go back to Kanto. Considering gen one and three take place around the same time, what do you think the odds are that we will be able to visit Kanto in ORAS?
 
Wouldn't it be then a remake of Fire Red/Leaf Green? I mean, it would be pretty silly to remake games that already have a remake. However, remake the remake sounds really stupid too xD

Nope, I don't want more remakes at all, less remakes of already remaked games.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top