Reviewing Challenge - December 2012

Astinus

Astinus

  • Cherish Ball
    • 10,282
    Posts
    19
    Years
    • Seen today
    how has it been a year since this happened last

    FF&W has been lacking in reviews, and a fun way to get members to review is by having a challenge! This is a "up-to-you" challenge. The minimum amounts of reviews expected is ten, and the maximum expected is twenty.

    How does it work?
    Interested in taking part? All you have to do is sign up in this thread using the form posted below. Then, starting on December 1st (your time zone, whatever that may be), you can begin reviewing any story or poem posted here in FF&W. Just be sure to keep the section's rules in mind.

    This means that your reviews need to be constructive. Don't just post "like ur story! it was good!" Point out specifics about the story you're reviewing, mentioning what you liked or didn't like. If your review can be posted to every story in this forum and make sense, it won't count for this challenge.

    Use your post in this thread to keep track of your reviews. Just link to them so we can double-check everything.

    Authors, if you would like a particular reviewer to read your story, check out their profile to find out how to contact them and ask them nicely. If we find out that you're pestering for reviews, it will be noted and no one will review your story for the challenge.

    The challenge ends: December 21 31, 2012

    How Many Reviews?
    It's up to you! You can do ten if that's all you can handle, and still get an emblem. If you want, you can do twenty, and still get an emblem.

    Either way...

    What do you get?
    Aside from the satisfaction of bringing activity to FF&W and reviews to the authors here, you also get this emblem:

    [PokeCommunity.com] Reviewing Challenge - December 2012


    The Form
    [b]Name:[/b]
    [b]Best Way to Contact:[/b]
    [b]Review Style:[/b]
    [b]Reviews:[/b]

    Reviewers
    Cutlerine
    bobandbill
    Khawill
    dudebot
    psyanic
     
    Last edited:
    With regret, I have withdrawn.

    What's that you say, real life? I don't have time? What a ridiculous excuse to not do this.

    Name: Cutlerine
    Best Way to Contact: VM, I guess.
    Review Style: A bit of everything, from grammar to plotholery to whatever... Essentially, whatever catches my eye. I do have a tendency to get fixated on good style, though. Oh, and most times you can expect at least one joke, too, though whether it's any good remains to be seen.
    Reviews: None yet, but hey! Give me a chance.

    F.A.B.
     
    Last edited:
    Not much time for reviews first few days but certainly still have time off this month to at least get some done!

    Name: bobandbill
    Best Way to Contact: VM, but PM is also cool.
    Review Style: I'll just mention what parts I like and what parts I feel could use improvement, including any spelling/grammar issues.
    Reviews:
    1. Story of Benki
    2. Red Eyes Don't Lie
    3. Marowak: The Avenger
    4. Top Gun
    5. Here We Go Again
    6. The Silver Cup Championship Battle
    7. Faded Saffron
    8. Giovani Destroys the World and Everything In It
    9. The Rise of Vee
    10. Long Road to Ruin
     
    Last edited:
    I'll join for sure, nothing like a good challenge to keep myself occupied.

    Name: Khalil, Khawill, just K
    Best Way to Contact:I check the forums everyday, simply VM or PM me
    Review Style: I pay more attention to plot, character dev, and spelling
    Reviews: *blank*
     
    I must make up with NaNo by make-up reviewing. She hasn't talked to me since yesterday.

    Name: psyanic
    Best Way to Contact: Shoot me a VM/PM, just not directly at me, or I might bleed to death. I'd hate to write reviews in a hospital bed.
    Review Style: I'll just go with I like nitpicking first then go really broad towards the end. I'd like to say I'm comprehensive in most of my reviews, but I also go on about how I think about the story itself that's not entirely a review but more of an opinion as in, "I didn't like this story, because I freaking hate talking lamps." That's a very extreme example, though. Basically, I like to look at whatever seems to need some improvement or at least I think needs some improvement.
    Reviews: Give me ten hours and I'll give you three horses and a review. Maybe.
    1. Story of Benki
    2. Scars and Cuts
     
    Last edited:
    I think I should be able to fit something in.

    Name: Astinus
    Best Way to Contact: VM, PM, or messenger bird
    Review Style: If I have the time, I go through really in-depth and point out what I like and what could use improvements in terms of characterization, description, logic, and maybe a little of grammar. If I don't have the time, you just get more of a summary of those same points. Also, if I'm tired, I just don't notice everything that I could, so!
    Reviews: Nada.
     
    Last edited:
    What better way to get back into the swing of things than doing a bit of reviewing, eh? I haven't reviewed a story in ages and I'm willing to do a few (up to three) on a first come first serve basis. It's winter break so I have ample time to do a bit of reading.

    Name: TurtleKing or TK
    Best Way to Contact: PM and VM
    Review Style: I'm a plot based reviewer, so I get into the nitty gritty of your story. I, of course, look for grammatical errors, but that gets the best of us. Plus, reviewing the plot is always fun.
    Reviews: None yet!
     
    I'm, uh, going to have to retire from this challenge, regrettably. A month ago I would have said that there is nothing more important in life than reviewing stories, but as it turns out, there is. So. Hey hum. I suppose I'll try again next time, assuming no other crises rear their heads.

    F.A.B.
     
    I'm regretfully going to have to do the same. There are other things on my to-do list that I'd like to concentrate on, leaving me little time/mental energy to review.

    Still, I'm going to get to the request I received. It'll just be next month.
     
    Um, with bobandbill as the only winner? (One more review, buddy. One more! :D)

    Don't worry about not reaching the goal this time around. I'm going to think a few things over and come up with a schedule so that a reviewing challenge happens every couple of months instead of once a year.

    There will be other things as well to keep activity going and to give chances to earn emblems.

    Right now, I'd say that December 2012 was a very busy month for people.
     
    Um, with bobandbill as the only winner? (One more review, buddy. One more! :D)
    Click to expand...
    And I've done that. \o/

    Ah well, hopefully next time around it will not be so busy for everyone. I too am for more frequent occurrences of this at any rate. =p
     
    bobandbill said:
    I too am for more frequent occurrences of this at any rate. =p
    Click to expand...

    This is what is known as a Good Idea. Wasn't there a system by which the Reviewing Challenge was supposed to be held every two months or something at one point? The more I think about it, the more I think there was... Does anyone with a memory less like a string bag than mine remember why it disappeared?

    F.A.B.
     
    I got too busy to remember it? :D?

    That's really all that it was. Maybe the amount of participants was slowing down, so I thought there was a lack of interest.

    Look for a thread discussing the state of the forum when I return home in seven hours! Because real life!
     
    It's a bit late to join in given it was for last month, but nothing is stopping you from reviewing anyway.
     
    You must log in or register to reply here.
    Back
    Top