What a bold way to make an entrance, DRCM. I tip my hat off to you.
Actually STRONGLY for this though given the swear censors case we're gonna be looking at 2016 when this actually happens.
D&D for the serious conversation which can sometimes fly on interesting tangents, General Chat for modest topics which may be a little more mundane/simple (usually mundane), THE CISTERN maybe? (don't forget to credit me if you like that name ;D) I would love it to bits if you had an area where the conversation could be EVEN MORE lax, to the point where staying to a SET topic wasn't even required, and the conversation flowed freely in each topic, to wherever it naturally went.
"BUT CHAOS!? MADNESS!??? DEMONS WILL RISE FROM HELL AND DESTORY POKECOMMUNITY!!!" you may say.
"Nah ah ah." I retort, wagging my finger and shaking my head.
I believe that quite ironically, the place should be HEAVILY covered, like the scene of an unjust murder by the state. However, unlike that scenario, neither side should be looking for trouble. Instead, the heavy moderation coverage is merely to stop it devolving into personal attacks or inappropriate posting in the first place. Aside from that, anything goes. If any personal attacks etc. are snuffed swiftly, the place will keep order. Chaotic order perhaps, but it certainly won't be a bad thing for Pokécommunity to have that forum livening the place up. The artificial attempts to make Gen Chat more appealing have been like using aspartame as a substitute for natural sugar. The natural stuff can be healthier. And damn, it tastes nicer.
You'll also see a lot more of me around here. What's not to like?