The type removal game

Mab

fleeting assembly
  • 8,707
    Posts
    15
    Years
    Here's a fun game/exercise/whatever. Pick a type to remove. Can be any of them, but obviously some of them are more essential than others.
    Where would the Pokémon from that type go? (List as many or few as you like.)

    What got me thinking about this was whether Normal type is really necessary. It seems like such a misc type to me, and on top of that it's often used in contexts that don't really make sense, like Pyroar being secondary normal - why? What makes it more Normal than, say, Arcanine?

    So imma go through with them and see if I can redistribute things.

    Pure normal types

    Ratatta & Meowth lines - Dark. idc if they have alt forms with those types. don't @ me
    Lickitung - i hate this thing just kill it with fire. Or Water bc saliva? God I hate Lickitung.
    Chansey line - Fairy. Why is it not that already
    Kangaskhan - Fighting
    Tauros - Rock
    Ditto - Psychic? Admittedly with Ditto types don't matter, but I can sorta see it as reading its opponents mind to copy its moves.
    Eevee - ??? the hardest one.
    Porygon - Psychic
    Snorlax line - Fighting
    Sentret - Grass? Not all Grass types are straight up plants, some just live in a grassy environment, so maybe this is plausible.
    Aipom - Grass/Flying
    Dunsparce - Bug
    Teddiursa - Fighting
    Stantler - Grass
    Smeargle - Fairy
    Miltank - Fairy?
    Zigzagoon - Dark
    Slakoth - Fighting
    Whismur - Fairy
    Skitty - Fairy. Again, should be one anyways. Why is it not.
    Zangoose - Fighting
    Castform - ???
    Kecleon - ???
    Bidoof - Water. Bibarel gets it anyways.
    Buneary - Grass, Lopunny becomes Grass/Fighting
    Glameow - Dark
    Regigigas - ???
    Arceus - ???
    Patrat - Ground
    Lillipup - ???
    Audino - Fairy
    Minccino - Psychic
    Bouffalant - Rock
    Bunnelby - Ground. Diggersby gets it anyways.
    Furfrou - Fairy
    Yungoos - Fighting
    Type: NULL - ???
    Komala - Grass
    Skwovet - just mercy kill it
    Wooloo - weird choice, but how about Steel? It seems like not all Steel mons need to be physically made of metal - Sandslash-A or Cufant for example, and it sometimes just means that they have a very tough exterior. I could imagine that wool being portrayed more like a steel wire mesh and totally making that theme work.

    Primary Normal-type Pokemon

    Not gonna list them all individually, but all the Normal/Flying pokemon could totally just be Flying. It seems like for some reason they were scared of having Flying be a solo type for most of Pokemon's history, but they seem to be doing it more lately. I don't see any reason why it shouldn't be a solo type, so Pidgey etc is pure flying.

    Jigglypuff - Fairy. Another case where being half normal doesn't really make sense. What makes Jigglypuff more normal than, like, Clefairy?
    Girafarig - Dark/Psychic. Makes more sense visually anyways.
    Azurill - Fairy or Fairy/Water.
    Bibarel - just Water
    Audino - Fairy. Same point as above.
    Deerling - Grass
    ...in fact just imagine all the pokemon with normal as their first type just lost that type

    Secondary Normal-type Pokémon

    Litleo - Fire
    Helioptile - Electric/Bug
    Indeedee (what is this thing, since when does it exist) - Psychic

    ---

    Whew, that's it! I'm far from suggesting that as an ideal change and in reality if they removed normal they'd probably have to add one or two new types to make some mons work. Within the constraints of existing types, some of those were definitely a reach, but it was still pretty fun.

    If you want to repeat my process with Normal or try a different type, you can find a list of all Pokemon with a given type on Bulbapedia~
     
    I know how it's gonna sound coming from me, but Helioptile/Helioptisk would be Electric/Dragon. That's a lizard not a bug lol. GF logic is more times than not "Lizard /Reptile/ Reptilian Dinosaur Equals Dragon." , so therefore they'd have conceivably no choice.

    Then again, I once wrote an entire post that's almost essay length in the Dragon Club about how often they go back and forth on that, so who knows lmao.

    Honestly, nothing should have Normal as a Dual Typing. Except maybe Flying and Water in the case of Fish, like "NORMAL Bird. NORMAL Fish.", because if it's a fire breathing lion, it obviously isn't just regular ol' "Normal Type". Nothing normal about that.

    That confliction intersects with every type. How is Helioptile Normal and Electric and Pikachu is pure Electric?

    Oh!

    Gf Logic!

    Nevermind! That's the answer! Goodnight!
     
    I'm actually curious what we can do with the doduo line - sure they can just become full flying, but that would be odd to me since none of them can actually fly to begin with. I kind of want to take out both the normal and flying typings from it, and maybe retype it to psychic or something. here's a dex entry from the anime:

    The brains in its two heads appear to communicate emotions to each other with telepathic power.

    telepahy! that would've been such an interesting concept. heck, even flying/psychic seems plausible
     
    Back
    Top