4th Gen There were to many legendaries in D P P

Bishopk said:
I would have preferred new stories with old legends, rather than new legends with the same old story.
Click to expand...


Or, even better, NEW legendaries with new stories. Best of both worlds.
 
Yeah, and I always wonder: Who made the Arceus egg?; What caused all that chaos in the birth of arceus? etc, and those probably wouldn't be boring legendaries like a so called "volcano spider"!l lol. All I want to say is you can never have too many legendaries, as long as they're interesting,original, and not sitting around doing nothing!
 
In later generations, I bet Nintendo/Gamefreak is going to make a Titan of Pokemon above Arceus, better than him. So yeah, they are going to probably do something about the storyline, about past legends with new legends.
 
But still, I mean, I wouldn't care if the volcano spider got a fleshed out backstory, 'cause it's still damn ugly and a disgrace to the past sweet and awesome looking legendaries.
 
LishaKara said:
Well, if you compare it to the incredible amount of gods and godesses and other figures we've got in our own mythology, there really aren't that many. I mean, there are about a couple less than 40 legendaries in all as of now in Pokemon, which seems like a lot but really isn't XD

however, I see where you're coming from. There are quite a lot of legendaries in D/P/P, having it be more spread out would be nice too. That, and the legendaries do all seem to be following a pattern, basically either a sleeping giant sort or a see-it-once-then-chase-it-around-the-country sort without much type variation.
Also. The insane amount of psychic-type legendaries! variety plz lol. I wanna see a Poison, Fighting, or Bug legendary (that works), ideally.
Click to expand...

Yeah. If you count all forms as Deoxys as 1 pokemon, there are 35 different legendaries. I liked all of em.
 
I think all the legendaries on D/P are good but I also think that uxie should be electric, azelf should be water and mesprit should be fire that wouldve been cooler instead of three boring psychics XD.
 
^Lol, yeah, cuz there's no fun in psychics??? Psychics are plenty fun, but... yes, it would've been a LOT better if they were Fire, Water, and Electric.
 
you know its not the legendaries that make the game... they just help you beat it XD
 
Freddie24 said:
Totally, and they all sucked except for Palkia and Dialga. Although I haven't seen Darkrai, Arcues, or Shaymin. Darkrai looks pretty awesome. But why were the trio of legendaries all psychic? They should be fire, ice and electric, like they were in the olden days.
Click to expand...

dude, listen to what your saying! psychics are awsome! and fire, ice and electric? please give me a break!
 
It kind of bugged me too, however, it just gives people that many more chances to get the legends. Thats the upside, but it has a sortof down side to it also. Irs sortof *just sort* of like cheating in its own way. I dont know quiet how to describe it.
 
I like them all,but your right there are 2 many.
My faves are Palkia Rotom and Darikrai (Three new event pokemon. None from other regions!)
31 legendaries in all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I guess I just think legendaries are supposed to be rare (and not just in a one-of-a-kind way). They don't need to make so many legendaries. I would say that 10 legendaries that are available in every game plus a version mascot would be sufficient.
For the 10, I'm saying it would be the same from generation to generation. That would work fine for me.

EDIT: And Rotom is just like Lapras in R/B/Y. Now that there's breeding, it's not one-of-a-kind.
 
Nintendo can have as many legendaries as they want i don't care. The annoying thing is most of them have no story the same story as all the others. They also need to have a varied array of types. I'm sure about 1/2 the legends now are psychic.
 
BlueSeal said:
Nintendo can have as many legendaries as they want i don't care. The annoying thing is most of them have no story the same story as all the others. They also need to have a varied array of types. I'm sure about 1/2 the legends now are psychic.
Click to expand...
Well, about 20-30 of the 35 have part Psychic in them. Only recently they took out the Psychic rubbish. Palkia, Dialga, Darkrai, etc. from D/P/P aren't Psychic so that's a good sign.
 
I miss the good old days when there were only five legendary Pokémon; Zapdos, Arcticuno, Moltress, Mewtwo, and Mew. It made them incredibly special!

Now, a legendary is no big deal at all. How many did you say there were in Diamond and Pearl? Fourteen?! I never actually counted them. That is way too many legendary Pokémon. I wish they would have toned it down a bit... but hey, I do like Heatran. :P
 
I'd rather have 5 awesome looking legendaries than 14 ugly ones and an even uglier volcano spider, that's all
 
I actually like the legendary hunting, it gives you something to do after you beat the story. it felt like there was practically a whole second game in there between the old chateau, spring path, the branched path on victory road, and the battle island.
 
The Legendarys need some backround and the type variation is appaling. Please, no more psycic type legendaries nintendo, and maybe a poison type for once. I also dislike the look of some legendaries like Heatran.He also doesn't have a story line. Most legendaries in D/P do not have a story line, it's just "Hey look, another legendary sitting around doing nothing. Lets catch it!" It just gets too boring. The chase around the region just got too tedious and, well, to do that twice, I couldn't be bothered and gave up. Then when they did show up it wasn't very exciting. If Nintendo wants the legendaries to be exciting, don't make as many of them, give them a story line and make them more fun to chase, or catch, maybe make a mission or quest you have to go on instead. Make some variety in it, don't make you do the same thing over and over again.
 
Last edited:
I love ubers.
I've been collecting them and I think I'm missing 8.
All the ubers from 2nd Gen, Shaymin and Acreus.​
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top