4th Gen Totodile? Cyndaquil? or Chikorita

[:3]

Cyndaquil.
I always choose the Fire Type starter.

I am leaning towards Totodile this time though..

 

[manga_meijin2]

I always go for Totodile but since I'm getting both games and I hate Chickorita, I'm also gonna get a Cyndaquil :)

 

[Gigatongatlingman]

I'm going for the somewhat unpopular Chikorita, considering how Growlithe's going to be a staple on my Hg/Ss team, I can't have Cyndaquil. And in the case of Totodile, well... it's not much of a looker in my opinion, so Chikorita it is.

 

[Frozen King Prawns]

Totodile. Cyndaquil is the most overrated pokemon in the history of ever and I physically want to flush it down a toilet so that its flames go out. (But it's kinda cute, I guess >.<)

 

[Demigod]

probably Totodile....................................

 

[Epoxy]

Totodile all day everyday!

 

[falconpunch94]

I'll be choosing Chikorita, I don't like Cyndaquil evolved form's for some reason... even though I'm not to keen on Meganium either :/

 

[twistedpuppy]

My favorite is Cyndaquil and it would be my first option, but I'm having second thoughts. I WANT THEM ALL!!!

 

[Johto's Best]

Cydaquil. I'm a fire type trainer. Plus my friends are taking the other two, meaning that we all have to stay on our toes to beat each other. It's fun having friends who play pokemon.

 

[Air Pichu]

I'm ordering both so: HeartGold - Totodile, SoulSilver - Cyndaquil

 

[thegeneticway]

I personally like Cyndaquil for some reason. Maybe due to the fact I chose it in Hoenn.

I might have chose Totodile but I chose Swampert and 2 weaknesses to grass in the Battle Frontier = not okay.

 

[PrismoStar]

I'm choosing Totodile because it's an advantage against Lance. ;)

 

[Kishijoten]

I am picking Chikorita no matter what. I chose it before when i played it on pokemon silver and it is very reliable. i never really go for a fire pokemon from the beginning so cyndaquil is not a option for me.

 

[bassforce288]

cyndaquil cuz im used to it and it can pwn feraligator with thunder punch and meganium with flamethrower

 

[Rezon]

I am gonna go with Totodile

 

[tonyar109]

I'm going to choose Totodile as I always have. It's the only non-Grass Starter I've ever chosen.

My first choice is Totodile, and if not Totodile, I'd choose Chikorita. I've never really liked Cyndaquil as much as the other two

 

[The Fourteenth Doctor]

i'm going to pick Totodile or Cyndaquill, i'm not sure which one to pick yet as i like them both

 

[Mika555]

I am choosing am Chikorita for one of the games. I am not sure about which I should choose between Totodile and Cyndaquil though.

 

[Olliee]

I think I will be going with Cyndaquil :)

 

[iwuzhere9]

I think I will get Cyndaquil like I did for the original games (Silver ftw!) and just breed him to get me some starter BABIES. Or something.