• Our software update is now concluded. You will need to reset your password to log in. In order to do this, you will have to click "Log in" in the top right corner and then "Forgot your password?".
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

Why did they change everything up so much?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Illusionss

Banned
  • 209
    Posts
    7
    Years
    they STILL have Alolan league and even HAVE elite four and champion... just no gyms... BIG DEAL!

    That is completely irrelevant. They do not have gyms anymore, therefor the whole goal to the game defeating gyms and collecting gym badges is completely changed. :)

    they STILL have Alolan league and even HAVE elite four and champion... just no gyms... BIG DEAL!

    WOW... you sure whine a lot don't you?
    Gen 1 is only pokemon to revcieve new Alolan form
    Red and Blue is back.
    Professor Oaks Cousin is here.
    Not to mention according to leaked pokedex Alola will have various pokemon across generation INCLUDING MANY GEN 1 POKEMON!
    WHAT MORE COULD YOU WANT? THERE ARE GEN 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 POKEMONS AND GEN 1 CHARACTERS RETURNING!
    Seriously there is no pleasing people... if GF keeps old patterns people will complain every pokemon game is just a clone with improved graphic... and when GF tries something different like in Sun and Moon there are people like you who whine that their childhood is ruined!

    Where did I say sun and moon is getting rid of all the older gen Pokemon? I was comparing it to gen 5 because of it's huge changes, this time in the case of removing gyms and changing the concept of the game, talk about lack of intelligence, lol. Besides, it's also about the fact that they've gone sheer overkill with all the new Pokemon forms, there's like four different kinds of them that I'm aware of (possibly even more). I don't care for having professor Oak's cousin here at all, changes like that are barely anything more than a slight reference and will make no difference to the gameplay side of things. People have never complained before about using the same formula so why would they start now? If they insisted on making a spin-off-like game like this, then why didn't they save it for their Switch console coming out next year, that way they could have given us a regular Pokemon game on the 3DS and the spin-off-like sun and moon on the Swtch, everybody wins.
     
    Last edited by a moderator:
  • 294
    Posts
    14
    Years
    • Seen May 6, 2023
    That is completely irrelevant. They do not have gyms anymore, therefor the whole goal to the game defeating gyms and collecting gym badges is completely changed. :)





    Where did I say sun and moon is getting rid of all the older gen Pokemon? I was comparing it to gen 5 because of it's huge changes, this time in the case of removing gyms and changing the concept of the game, talk about lack of intelligence, lol. Besides, it's also about the fact that they've gone sheer overkill with all the new Pokemon forms, there's like four different kinds of them that I'm aware of (possibly even more). I don't care for having professor Oak's cousin here at all, changes like that are barely anything more than a slight reference and will make no difference to the gameplay side of things. People have never complained before about using the same formula so why would they start now? If they insisted on making a spin-off-like game like this, then why didn't they save it for their Switch console coming out next year, that way they could have given us a regular Pokemon game on the 3DS and the spin-off-like sun and moon on the Swtch, everybody wins.
    WTF? Sun and Moon is STiLL a main game... they just swapped gym leaders to Trail captain... it is still eventually same thing! Seriously the core aspect has NOT changed. you still capture pokemon, battle evil team, challenge trail captains... and level up your pokemon! WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SUN AND MOON AND OTHER MAIN GAMES EXCEPT ABSENCE OF GYMS!
    Seriously you still have Trail captains AND kahunas who still specialises in a type like gym leaders!
    NOT MUCH DIFFERENCE!
    Seriously you really do not like change do you?
    did you whine in X and y when they introduced new type? I bet you were like "WHY INTRODUCE NEW TYPE WHEN THEY HAVEN'T FOR 5 GENERATIONS! X AND Y SUCKS!"
     

    L'Belle

    I am beauty!
  • 2,175
    Posts
    8
    Years
    What I am wondering is.. what did black and white change that was so different from it's previous generations besides there being no old pokémon?

    Also something you said, yes, it is still the same thing. You travel trough the region, preparing yourself to face trials with totem pokémon and kahunas (Who specialize in a certain type) and fight an evil team alongside the way. Then when you are done, you go trough victory road and fight the elite four and the champion. There are also postgame adventures for you to discover and online battling to have fun with.

    This really could be any pokémon game with some slight differences. Also, you should know that Gamefreak put a lot of work in these games. You should at least see for yourself if you like it before judging it so unfairly as you do now.
     
  • 294
    Posts
    14
    Years
    • Seen May 6, 2023
    seriously GYMS never has been a thing that makes pokemon a Pokemon...
    Pokemon is all about capturing your pokemon, leveling it up, and befreinding it. I don't mind if they removed the league, evil teams, or champion... as long as they have core aspect of capturing your pokemon and befriending it... it is STILL a pokemon!
     

    Illusionss

    Banned
  • 209
    Posts
    7
    Years
    WTF? Sun and Moon is STiLL a main game... they just swapped gym leaders to Trail captain... it is still eventually same thing! Seriously the core aspect has NOT changed. you still capture pokemon, battle evil team, challenge trail captains... and level up your pokemon! WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SUN AND MOON AND OTHER MAIN GAMES EXCEPT ABSENCE OF GYMS!
    Seriously you still have Trail captains AND kahunas who still specialises in a type like gym leaders!
    NOT MUCH DIFFERENCE!
    Seriously you really do not like change do you?
    did you whine in X and y when they introduced new type? I bet you were like "WHY INTRODUCE NEW TYPE WHEN THEY HAVEN'T FOR 5 GENERATIONS! X AND Y SUCKS!"

    Sun and Moon is very similar to Pokemon Colosseum and Pokemon gale of darkness, no gyms or gym badges hence the spin-off-like feel to it and a different end game goal, which sun and moon also has. Obviously there's still going to be an evil team, what else are they going to do, make a game where you battle Red and Blue for fun over and over? Also where did I complain about a new type? Adding is fine with me as long as they're not taking away key aspects of the game whilst doing so, or going complete overkill with a cluster fuck of the many different Pokemon forms.


    What I am wondering is.. what did black and white change that was so different from it's previous generations besides there being no old pokémon?

    Also something you said, yes, it is still the same thing. You travel trough the region, preparing yourself to face trials with totem pokémon and kahunas (Who specialize in a certain type) and fight an evil team alongside the way. Then when you are done, you go trough victory road and fight the elite four and the champion. There are also postgame adventures for you to discover and online battling to have fun with.

    This really could be any pokémon game with some slight differences. Also, you should know that Gamefreak put a lot of work in these games. You should at least see for yourself if you like it before judging it so unfairly as you do now.

    If you re-read the post I made comparing it to gen 5, you'll see I made the point that the difference was that hardly any earlier gen Pokemon we're available until near the end of the game/after the endgame. I played the demo and did not enjoy it, however I am going to play the full game before making a final conclusion, but even at this point in time I am just as entitled to my opinion as someone who is looking forward to the game and loving what they've seen thus far.

    I feel that it would have been so much better if they made this game for the Nintendo Switch in more ways than one. For starters it would have been better from a business standpoint as for many people this would be a deal breaker having a Pokemon game like this on a home console and would've increased sales (especially having this on the day of release of the Nintendo Switch), also it would have given them something to experiment with and would have been much less of a risk to what they're doing now, if these games and their new ideas do happen to flop then it could really hurt them and they would likely need a solid Pokemon game with the standard formula to get back on track. Putting this on the Switch would also give everyone what they want; a Pokemon game what we're used to on the 3ds for us casual fans, and a Pokemon game with a lot of big changes for you hardcore fans or fans who want something different. But hey, what do I know?


    seriously GYMS never has been a thing that makes pokemon a Pokemon...
    Pokemon is all about capturing your pokemon, leveling it up, and befreinding it. I don't mind if they removed the league, evil teams, or champion... as long as they have core aspect of capturing your pokemon and befriending it... it is STILL a pokemon!

    For me gyms was such a huge part of the game that I enjoyed, and I know I'm not the only one as many of my friends are the same. I can't really comment on "befriending it" as I've never tried to befriend a virtual Pocket monster, but whatever you're into I guess. I may have even enjoyed battling gyms even more than collecting Pokemon and powering it up, there was just something about collecting gym badges and reaching the milestone of a new gym, and also facing a whole bunch of CPU's with the same type of Pokemon whilst leading up the gym leader.

    If you're more into petting your Pokemon and feeding them treats on the touchscreen, as well as battling online with your Z type special moves and your Ash-Greninja or all the different regular forms or legendary forms, then that's great, each to their own. But I'm just not into that.
     

    kingdenas

    #Team Popplio <3
  • 1,707
    Posts
    9
    Years
    I mean, if you think defeating a gym leader with only 3 Pokémon, which you can OHKO easily with one member of your team is fun, then so be it.

    Honestly, I was pretty tired of gyms. They started getting really easy, and the leaders didn't participate in the plot as they should. I think adding Trials is a refreshing way to get rid of gyms. And it's not like they don't make sense, since Alola is pretty tropical and whatnot. The idea of trials seem to match Alola's environment and culture, so I'm not even mad. You shouldn't judge a book by its cover.
     

    blue

    gucci
  • 21,057
    Posts
    16
    Years
    I was skeptical about the whole trial system replacing the Gyms at a first glance, but now I'm looking forward to at least seeing how it compares. I think trials will be a lot more innovative than gym puzzles and hopefully, it will mean Trial Captains are more heavily involved with the storyline. One of the issues with gym leaders was the lack of character development with them not really having any engagement with the plot other than being there to battle against. With the combination of Captains, trials, Totem Pokémon, and Kahunas.. I think they will be full of content.
     
  • 50,218
    Posts
    13
    Years
    I was skeptical about the whole trial system replacing the Gyms at a first glance, but now I'm looking forward to at least seeing how it compares. I think trials will be a lot more innovative than gym puzzles and hopefully, it will mean Trial Captains are more heavily involved with the storyline. One of the issues with gym leaders was the lack of character development with them not really having any engagement with the plot other than being there to battle against. With the combination of Captains, trials, Totem Pokémon, and Kahunas.. I think they will be full of content.

    If I also remember, Totem Pokemon are going to be kinda tough early on since I did see a video on CoroCoro's YouTube channel where the player's team (Litten, Yungoos and Crabrawler) got destroyed easily by the Totem Gumshoos.

    Gumshoos is Sun exclusive while Moon has Alolan Raticate, which the latter will definitely be easier to beat down with a Fighting-type (4x weakness yoohoo!) plus Popplio line gets Disarming Voice early which also hits Raticate's Dark-type super-effectively. Basically, Sun players will have a harder time against that first Totem since Gumshoos doesn't have as many weaknesses as Moon's Alolan Raticate.

    Now I could only imagine how much scary these Totems will be for Nuzlockers of this game...
     
  • 294
    Posts
    14
    Years
    • Seen May 6, 2023
    Sun and Moon is very similar to Pokemon Colosseum and Pokemon gale of darkness, no gyms or gym badges hence the spin-off-like feel to it and a different end game goal, which sun and moon also has. Obviously there's still going to be an evil team, what else are they going to do, make a game where you battle Red and Blue for fun over and over? Also where did I complain about a new type? Adding is fine with me as long as they're not taking away key aspects of the game whilst doing so, or going complete overkill with a cluster **** of the many different Pokemon forms.




    If you re-read the post I made comparing it to gen 5, you'll see I made the point that the difference was that hardly any earlier gen Pokemon we're available until near the end of the game/after the endgame. I played the demo and did not enjoy it, however I am going to play the full game before making a final conclusion, but even at this point in time I am just as entitled to my opinion as someone who is looking forward to the game and loving what they've seen thus far.

    I feel that it would have been so much better if they made this game for the Nintendo Switch in more ways than one. For starters it would have been better from a business standpoint as for many people this would be a deal breaker having a Pokemon game like this on a home console and would've increased sales (especially having this on the day of release of the Nintendo Switch), also it would have given them something to experiment with and would have been much less of a risk to what they're doing now, if these games and their new ideas do happen to flop then it could really hurt them and they would likely need a solid Pokemon game with the standard formula to get back on track. Putting this on the Switch would also give everyone what they want; a Pokemon game what we're used to on the 3ds for us casual fans, and a Pokemon game with a lot of big changes for you hardcore fans or fans who want something different. But hey, what do I know?




    For me gyms was such a huge part of the game that I enjoyed, and I know I'm not the only one as many of my friends are the same. I can't really comment on "befriending it" as I've never tried to befriend a virtual Pocket monster, but whatever you're into I guess. I may have even enjoyed battling gyms even more than collecting Pokemon and powering it up, there was just something about collecting gym badges and reaching the milestone of a new gym, and also facing a whole bunch of CPU's with the same type of Pokemon whilst leading up the gym leader.

    If you're more into petting your Pokemon and feeding them treats on the touchscreen, as well as battling online with your Z type special moves and your Ash-Greninja or all the different regular forms or legendary forms, then that's great, each to their own. But I'm just not into that.

    you clearly don't like change... plus YOU ALWAYS IGNORE TRAIL CAPTAINS AND KAHUNAS!
     

    Illusionss

    Banned
  • 209
    Posts
    7
    Years
    I mean, if you think defeating a gym leader with only 3 Pokémon, which you can OHKO easily with one member of your team is fun, then so be it.

    Honestly, I was pretty tired of gyms. They started getting really easy, and the leaders didn't participate in the plot as they should. I think adding Trials is a refreshing way to get rid of gyms. And it's not like they don't make sense, since Alola is pretty tropical and whatnot. The idea of trials seem to match Alola's environment and culture, so I'm not even mad. You shouldn't judge a book by its cover.

    I agree Pokemon games as of late have been too easy (X and Y especially), but they can make the game more difficult by increasing the difficulty somewhat e.g. like the elite 4 in gen 1, except to an even further extent if needed, they didn't have to completely remove gyms.


    you clearly don't like change... plus YOU ALWAYS IGNORE TRAIL CAPTAINS AND KAHUNAS!

    I encourage change for the better, but I also don't believe in trying to fix something that isn't broken. Seems like Nintendo have took a trick from Apple's book in this case.
     
  • 294
    Posts
    14
    Years
    • Seen May 6, 2023
    I agree Pokemon games as of late have been too easy (X and Y especially), but they can make the game more difficult by increasing the difficulty somewhat e.g. like the elite 4 in gen 1, except to an even further extent if needed, they didn't have to completely remove gyms.




    I encourage change for the better, but I also don't believe in trying to fix something that isn't broken. Seems like Nintendo have took a trick from Apple's book in this case.

    how is trail captain not a change for better? For EONS people have complained that Pokemon is just same thing with same boring old formula! get pokemon beat gym, fight evil teams, beat elite four, beat champion, the end! they did same old formula for 20 years and now GF is FINALLY trying to do something different and you cry foul? IT IS BROKEN! PEOPLE HAVE COMPLAINED THAT THERE IS NOTHING NEW ABOUT EACH POKEMON GAMES AND BELIEVE THAT ONCE YOU PLAYED ANY ONE POKEMON GAME THERE IS NO NEED TO PLAY ANOTHER SINCE THEY ARE BASICALLY THE SAME!
    seriously you can please people
     

    Illusionss

    Banned
  • 209
    Posts
    7
    Years
    My last post itt, take it as you will:

    There will be change in Pokemon. That's a fact. Unless you've been living under a rock or have genuinely never played Pokemon before, this is something to be expected. Game Freak removes and adds features every single generation. The Poketch? Removed. Xtransciever? Removed. Vs. Seeker? Removed. Battle Frontier? Removed. Pokemon following you in HGSS? Removed. Difficulty altering modes after B2W2? Removed. I can honestly go on and on about this but I will be honest and say that a lot of the reason you're facing some pushback in this thread is because this is nothing new on Game Freak's part, and a lot of people know this. They will always make some additions every generation that's polarized amongst fans. In Gen VI, it was Mega Evolution. This generation, it's Alola forms. No matter what Game Freak does, they're never going to please everybody. They can most certainly try, and that's their general aim, but it will never happen because there will be someone mad enough that the experience isn't tailored enough specifically for them.

    Secondly, you can develop whatever opinion you want. If, ultimately, you feel that the games aren't a fit for you based on what you've seen so far, so be it. I disagree with the premature judgment, but hey, that's your thoughts on it and if the last four pages of this thread have been of any indication, you're probably not going to change your mind on that, and chances are you're not going to change the mind of anybody you're replying to. I don't think that's your aim, as you've stated earlier you're just here to post your opinion, and that's fine. I do think however, that this has become rather one-sided and very repetitive; you keep saying that you feel that the recent generation is losing its nostalgia because of the removal of Gyms among other new additions, while others are stating to you that this isn't the case; that Pokemon has and always will be what it is at its core: catching, battling, trading, and communicating. Nothing more, nothing less. How Game Freak does that is ultimately up to them. You may not be satisfied with how they go about with these core functions, but as long as they keep them intact, it will always be Pokemon as a lot of people know it to be.

    That being said, if you feel you are going to be unhappy with your experiences with the games, then do cancel your pre-orders and skip out on this generation. A lot of people in this thread disagree with you that the removal of Gyms is removing a component that would be sending the games in a death spiral, but hey, opinions are opinions and as I said, not everyone is going to be pleased with a specific generation of games. That's just how it is.

    On another note: difficulty in Pokemon games are hardly going to be a thing. As much as some veteran players (even myself) would want it to be so, the fact of the matter is that even if you see that more adults play Pokemon, the general demographic and aim for Pokemon is for children. These games are developed so that it would be easy and simple for children as well as those who've never played Pokemon before to get into; making the games difficult would most likely turn them off and away from it.

    tl;dr: We're all here to enjoy the Pokemon games for various reasons. Some of those reasons are more for battling, some of them care more for plot, some of them care for post-game, some more for trading and breeding. What makes Pokemon such a fulfilling experience in many people's eyes is that these core aspects of the games don't seem to be compromised. In fact, they're made easier, if anything else. It's possibly likely that Super Training will make a return, Hyper Training is making getting into battling a breeze, breeding is ridiculously easy with Gen VI and will likely be easy in Gen VII.

    The point of all of this is that Gyms, while a staple in the series, are only a tiny part of what makes Pokemon what it is. And I know you're going to respond to this with "well why not replace Pokemon with nets lol", in which case I'll respond that Pokeballs are universal. They can fit anywhere, in any region, in any environment without looking out of place. Everyone knows what a Pokeball is, they're a standard method of capturing Pokemon and Pokeballs are a trainers' trustworthy tool to capture Pokemon to fill up the Pokedex. Gyms however, as much of a staple as they are, they can very well be removed because, as this generation proved, Gyms are not the only way one can be recognized as Champion of a specific region. If this point seems silly to you, then I'm not sure what else to say, but it is what it is.

    Z-moves and the such are not difficult concepts to learn, in fact, I believe they're explained even in the demo. At any rate, it sucks that you aren't happy with them, and I hope that, if you do plan on getting the games in the end, that you'll be satisfied with your experience and that SM will be a decent game to play through, after all.

    I must have missed the "Do not give your opinion" post in the terms of service, my bad!
     

    Illusionss

    Banned
  • 209
    Posts
    7
    Years
    how is trail captain not a change for better? For EONS people have complained that Pokemon is just same thing with same boring old formula! get pokemon beat gym, fight evil teams, beat elite four, beat champion, the end! they did same old formula for 20 years and now GF is FINALLY trying to do something different and you cry foul? IT IS BROKEN! PEOPLE HAVE COMPLAINED THAT THERE IS NOTHING NEW ABOUT EACH POKEMON GAMES AND BELIEVE THAT ONCE YOU PLAYED ANY ONE POKEMON GAME THERE IS NO NEED TO PLAY ANOTHER SINCE THEY ARE BASICALLY THE SAME!
    seriously you can please people

    Kind of contradicting yourself, earlier you said that not much is changing and now you're saying it's a good
    thing that they're changing the "same boring old formula".

    Bottom line is some people wanted something different, some people wanted the same thing. They could've made everyone a winner by making this spin-off-like game on the Switch and a regular Pokemon game what we're used to on the 3DS or something along those lines as I've said over and over, but instead us old school fans got bent over the desk and got it stuck up us, because we're getting a game that we didn't want and ultimately no sign of a Pokemon game with the standard formula coming anytime soon.
     

    blue

    gucci
  • 21,057
    Posts
    16
    Years
    It doesn't seem like much more can come of this discussion other than what is already being argued. Since the discussion topic has trailed off, I'm gonna go ahead and close this thread before things get out of hand.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top