• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Dawn, Gloria, Juliana, or Summer - which Pokémon protagonist is your favorite? Let us know by voting in our poll!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

WitchHunt - Endgame

Unfortunately, your theory of a "collaboration" can be debunked. I only merely agreed for the priest to out so that they could get protected. If that's enough for a scumread, everyone else who mentioned something along those lines could also be considered scummy lol.

I have a feeling you're trying to get rid of innocent people so that it's easier for you in the long run, Aaron.

That last part screams scum in my experience. That's exactly the play gp made against me when he tried to discredit me in botb2. (For you passive readers, gp was mafia in botb2).
It's also what I did in npm against Johnny when I claimed shuckle as mafia and Kiyo (not this one) rekt my sorry ass.

[Vote] purplecicada
This feels like a solid vote.

Can someone provide feedback on this?

____________

Slight scumread on Purp here (and thus the opposite on Aaron)

Also pretty certain as to Alex's innocence.

EDIT: @purp If I'm scummy, why did you seem so on board with my statement. It does seem like you're agreeing with the most recent thoughts.

I don't understand how Ash dying means everyone who died until now is town. Can you elaborate on it?

How are you "certain" of my innocence?

Didnt it say so in the flavor text? Or did i misread? Also, will be posting scumreads once I get back to my pc.

There's no information hidden in the flavor text in this game. Unless you are the fortune teller and slipped lul.

Pretty sure Abby is town, her playstyle reminds me of her being town in some other games I've played lately. Also got townreads on Desi Gimme and Johnny.

Aaron, however, seems to have tunnel vision on this collaboration and that worries me.

I'll have to disagree on that last bit. I'm liking what Aaron is saying so far. I agree with Abby looking good, so purp might have been trying to buddy him.
 
Okay, so

A few random things. I'm not sure I'm liking that the Nurse hasn't done anything yet. We have some roles that have been outed and a few others that it might be pertinent to keep around regardless (sadly she can't protect the Priest or Acolyte, but that makes sense . . . but can she protect the King? He shouldn't need it if the entire court is alive (which may not be the case), but he's confirmed innocent and also isn't Holy, so the Nurse could target him?). And a Witch Nurse would probably wait until they're on the chopping block to use up their ability on an ally, or just not use it at all, so I'm wondering if that's the case here.

But also keep in mind that, as long as no Witches have died yet (which, honestly, it doesn't seem likely that any have), the Angels can protect any player indefinitely until a Demon spawns and haunts that player, so we do have a solid, infinite protection that can be used up. With luck they've taken to this already, which could explain the seemingly "random" killing of Ash, as the Coven might be trying to make sure to avoid all obvious protectees.

As for current events, I never really had a scumread on Abby (besides when I got BABASHOOK kek), so this whole thing is still lost on me. But purple's responses to it do read as potential scum.
 
ALL OF NICKI'S POSTS
Day 1​

Hello guys. Apologies for only posting now, but I have been away from any kind of computer for a couple days. I'm going to shove a vote on Abby just because he dabbed.

Placeholder vote. ;)
[vote] Abby
Set up as a random vote, nothing particularly incriminating here.
You seem very upset by this. ;)

I'm messing around, guys.
[unvote] Abby
Joke Posts
To have my post count up to four, this is a placeholder. Mostly also to even out the votes. I'll put up a [vote] Desi. (I keep forgetting how to spell his name, so I hope 'Desi' is acceptable - it's hard to find things on mobile!)
Nothing of real substance here. Almost an attempt to "Coast"[/b]

Day 2​

Whew. Sorry for only just posting! I haven't forgotten. I have a slight town read on Alex, but I'm currently not too sure about anyone elze.
Doesn't provide any reason for not posting. (Not the only one with activity problems but). Actually sharing stuff...
Okay, so I have a very null read on Alex. But I'm leaning more towards innocent than witch.
Hmm, pretty sure Very Null is different to the town read she mentioned earlier
Actually.
Abby, didn't you vote for Doof both yesterday and today? I may have missed it, but is there a reason? Just wondering!
Asking a question to me, which isn't particularly bad, but the "Just wondering!" Gives a sense of innocence, or at least what we're wanted to think.
For now, I am going to [vote] No one.

Reason being, I'm still trying to get reads on everyone. As for Abby, I have a feeling he's just eager.
[/color=magenta]You've had two days pls.

Defending me too...


Day 3​

I'm with Abby on this one. We need to know who to protect - obviously assuming that they're both alive.
An overly long ^ post
What's your hunch on this, Aaron? I was agreeing with what Abby said, but after seeing that it was a poor idea, I think I might retract it.
And here's the post that I really don't like. She's basically said She'll agree with whatever other people are saying. THIS IS SCUM BEHAVIOUR
Unfortunately, your theory of a "collaboration" can be debunked. I only merely agreed for the priest to out so that they could get protected. If that's enough for a scumread, everyone else who mentioned something along those lines could also be considered scummy lol.

I have a feeling you're trying to get rid of innocent people so that it's easier for you in the long run, Aaron.
I think it was the fact that you replied so soon after me that made it look scummy.
I will admit that Abby is a tiny bit scummy, but aside from that I don't have any reads at the moment, seeing as I agree with what you said about everyone being over-the-place. There is nothing I can pick out because of this.
Flip on me, also, completely disregarding the shifting Alex reads yesterday.
My scumread is only very faint, too. I'm a bit upset that people are scumreading me just because I mentioned the idea of protection for the Priest. It probably wasn't worded in the best of ways, and aside from this it probably wasn't needed as I now realise that witches could go for other people.
using emotion to get people off you
Once again "faint". Don't you have anything set in stone?


That being said.
[VOTE]Purplecicada


EDIT: done before Alex/Naku's posts, will follow up to Alex's shortly
 
Last edited:
You're lucky I'm using a dark theme with all that magenta, my goodness

Gurllllll I might need to teach you a thing or two about being
fabulous!


Babadrag Race maf needs to happen where's Kiyobae when you need him


But it looks like we might finally have a real target. I want to see if purple can talk themself out of this or if they'll just dig a bigger hole

For now I'll Vote purplecicada since I'll be gone for 24+ hours when I leave in a bit. Plenty of time for some Babatea

[PokeCommunity.com] WitchHunt - Endgame

why are proper Pusheen gifs impossible to find
 
The only reason I said I had a faint scumread on Abby was because he voted for Doof 2 days in a row, and I was slightly concerned.
 
As everyone is fully aware, I don't always pay attention to obvious scumreads straight away. It's something I pick up on much later in the game.
 
I don't understand how Ash dying means everyone who died until now is town. Can you elaborate on it?
To me at least, the Ash vote seemed to come out of nowhere. Why wouldn't a more townread person die, unless they were scum (which I doubt) or they were frearful of them getting protection.
How are you "certain" of my innocence?

I say certain, that doesn't mean I'm softing priest or whatever. It's merely a strong townread. In a game where for the most part we haven't done TOO much, you've been one of the most cocal players in searching for reads, will providing your own insight into the game, that I feel is genuine.



also the scumread on me was one of my least pressing points @nicki
 
also the scumread on me was one of my least pressing points @nicki

The problem is I'm not able to defend my innocence, because there isn't actually a lot to go on. So I thought at least I would justify why I had a slight scumread on you.
 
EC or Lycan? Or maybe go back in time and delay that post until tomorrow so you can target Nicki
:thonk:
 
Posts like this are always a bad idea, jsyk.
 
And so grows the hole

Bard where have you been and why are you so extra
 
Got a feeling some of you are aggreeing to the people that suggest roles outing so that when witch nk 'em, the fault goes to the one who gave the idea. aka purple for me.
[Vote] purplecicada
 
jd is so indifferent is hurts.
Are you a witch, jd? Witches are indifferent, they don't care about no shit
 
Back
Top