Route 3.3
Made for kicks and isn't in a hack yet :)
This is the first map I have made using tiles other than firered, so please rate! Its mainly an events map, not a real route as it leads from a city to this one house :).
Credits to Kyledove ^^
~~~~
bboykev~
I like the pathshapes (though infront of the PC it should be one tile wider I think) and the water. The tree's on the left side are good but they looks a bit patterened to the right side.
The house behind the P.C would look better if it was brought forward to be next to the PC as it looks a little lost behind it.
Also vary the grass tile you are using, from what I can tell they are all the same.
7/10
Ageangel~
The tree placement, especially around the bottom, is horrible, the exact row of trees under the path is particularly offputting. Also the tree shadows need to be looked at.
I don't like how you have to go along and round to get into the village, if it did that I think a path would be needed to go around
4/10
Sasquatch~
Like the path shape, and the water bodies are good too (though I agree the bottom right one looks a bit too narrow). The trees are all good too, though I think less logs might be a good idea, there seems to be loads.
Wild grass... all good.
I'm not a fan of those flowers though ;) Haha.
8.5/10