WitchHunt - Endgame

[Sparkin]

I guess you're used to seeing Abby play worryless. Not scummy though.

 

[Abby]

I may be... slightly worried about maintaining my post count.

Look, we've 24 hours. We can vote ishi if you guys want, otherwise it isn't going to matter.

Also, if we're talking about Ishi's claim being irrelevant, then what about Morian's? That just struck me as out of the blue, even if it was for a scumslip.

EDIT: You could also be ysed to seeing my scum/3P game, it's been AGES since I've been town for any meaningful amount of time

 

[Nakuzami]

I dunno but probability of judge being witch is like 0.01% :p 'cause its a closed setup game where half majority is needed to get a player lynched. If half of town fails to vote it will fall at hands of Judge which ( assuming ) is mafia sided so *bam* here goes town. Next day same. This kinda make way to op mafia side.

That's why I believe ishi is town and priest shouldn't waste their NA and investigate people who are really looking scummy.

The roles are randomized as far as what alignment they fall under, so whether it makes the mafia OP is completely irrelevant. Plus, it's only OP if the town constantly fails to come to a consensus, which is a mark of a bad town to start with, so

While I agree it's more likely for Ishi to be townsided, I believe so simply because of the way events are playing out. What I'm not fond of is the way you're trying to deter something based on what you've presented.

Kiyotaka I'm less convinced of role and alignment wise, since he kind of panicked there and role revealed.... but then again his general behavior to me at least matches his claimed role.

It would be unfortunate (aka stupid) if he was lying about his role, because then the real judge would just kill him outright. And if the judge is dead, we'd know the instant no one got lynched if a majority isn't reached.

So

really people what are you doing here

 

[jombii]

I hate being on the other side of the globe since you guys are awake when I'm not :(

On everything I have read, I believe that Ishi's claim as the judge but I am not sure of his alignment claim. If he is then really trigger-happy, that explains the EC lynch day 1. But I am still doubtful as there is no damning evidence EC was scum during day 1. Any town hand on board is still a help for town. I guess I'm on board the priest investigating ishi for his alignment. we don't have a watcher role either so the identity of the priest will be kept hidden well.

I don't think Abby is scum either. He's a null read on me as of the moment.

 

[Superjolt]

There's about 13 hours left in the day!

Vote Count 2.3

Lycanthropy (3) - Bidoof FTW, Kiyotaka Ishimaru, Desinishon
Kiyotaka Ishimaru (2) - Lycanthropy, Aaron
Abby (1) - Alex Kaz

No Lynch (2) - HyperMorian, purplecicada

Currently Not Voting (12): Bardothren, Home, Johnny, Sparkin, gimmepie, jdthebud, Ash, Sword Master, Ras!, mew_nani, Nakuzami, Abby

With 20 players alive, it takes 11 votes to lynch at the end of day!

It takes 15 votes to lynch and end the day early!

The day ends in 13 hours at 12:00pm EST (5:00pm GMT) on Thursday, July 6th.

Day 2 Post counts for each player:
(might have to double check these numbers)

Spoiler:

Blue = You're good!
Bold/black = Almost there, you can do it!
Red = You'd better start posting, come join us in the thread!
Abby [18]
Kiyotaka Ishimaru [13]
Alex Kaz [10]
Ash [9]
Johnny [7]
Nakuzami [5]
Lycanthropy [5]
Home [4]
jdthebud [4]
Sparkin [4]
purplecicada [4]
Desinishon [4]
mew_nani [3]
Bidoof FTW [2]
HyperMorian [2]
Aaron [1]
Ras! [1]
Bardothren [0]
Sword Master [0]

Fletch [4] - replaced by gimmepie

 

[Bidoof FTW]

I'm starting to think my vote on Lycan was just a hasty analysis after trying to maintain activity. Although the one post may have been scummy I don't believe he's a witch at this point, however, I could be very wrong, and from the looks of it the judge will kill him anyways.

Unfortunate

Abby's potential slip has definitely caught my eye though, I tend to find abby as scummy in most games though so I won't act on it for now.

 

[jombii]

Do you guys realize that a no-one vote is almost similar to voting lycan out?

[VOTE]Aaron since he hasn't talked this day post as of superjolt's last count.

 

[jdthebud]

I don't really think Bidoof is actually maf mostly because I believe that he really is genuinely busy and can't post. I don't think a maf would deliberately employ such a strategy since it's kind of lying to the game host. I think Bidoof is only an inactive town. As for Jdthebud, I have a slight scumread on him since he's continued to push the whole Bidoof thing and the whole witch is maf idea for most of his posts, as far as I remember. He may just be concerned town, but he could still easily be maf directing the conversation.

As for whether or not I should be trusted on my testament, it doesn't really matter either way since I'll either probably get lynched by town, killed by maf [if I'm trusted], or killed by the court [if I'm still suspected]. Sure, I want to live and continue helping town, but as it is, the chances are low.

I haven't been pushing the "Bidoof thing" as you put it. I only wondered what the reason for killing EC over Bidoof was since Bidoof had the most votes at the time. Keep in mind I actually never voted for him.

I'm starting to think my vote on Lycan was just a hasty analysis after trying to maintain activity. Although the one post may have been scummy I don't believe he's a witch at this point, however, I could be very wrong, and from the looks of it the judge will kill him anyways.

Unfortunate

Abby's potential slip has definitely caught my eye though, I tend to find abby as scummy in most games though so I won't act on it for now.

What "potential slip" are you referring to?

 

[Lycanthropy]

I'm willing to change votes with the hope I can still get somebody else listed. (Stil think it's wise to let somebody inspect him tonight.) Next on my scum list is Desi, mainly because this post was way too quick imo. Also he needs to get his probability theory straight.
[Unvote] Kiyotaka Ishimura
[Vote] Desinishon

And since I'm dead meat anyway, I might as well share everything I know. Hi, I'm the Hunter. Town-sided, if you're willing to believe that. Obviously, I haven't made use of my role yet.

 

[jombii]

Ok so you're voting me just so I can speak in the thread? :thonk:

[UNVOTE]Kiyotaka Ishimura
[VOTE]Abby

Just wanted to hear what you have to say. Votings a good trigger for some people, idk.

[UNVOTE]Aaron

 

[Desinishon]

I'm willing to change votes with the hope I can still get somebody else listed. (Stil think it's wise to let somebody inspect him tonight.) Next on my scum list is Desi, mainly because this post was way too quick imo. Also he needs to get his probability theory straight.
[Unvote] Kiyotaka Ishimura
[Vote] Desinishon

And since I'm dead meat anyway, I might as well share everything I know. Hi, I'm the Hunter. Town-sided, if you're willing to believe that. Obviously, I haven't made use of my role yet.

There is two things about that theory: 1. I strongly believe that Judge is town, reason: Whenever I get cornered in a game as a town, I'm always desperateto make everyone believe I'm town the way ishi is. So yeah I see that thing in his play. But yeah! It's my opinion so priest can check them all they want. But I still believe that they're town.

2. I want to create a situation like "may be priest isn't going to check ishi" srsly who is priest going to listen: Desi or a number of good player *sigh*

I just happened to be around the moment ishi posted....idk.

I believe your claim so..

[Unvote]Lycan

I mentioned scum reading Abby before....I dunno why rabi voted them? @Aaron

 

[Abby]

Ok, should we try and work out who Lycan should kill, considering he's the likely lynch.

 

[Kiyotaka Ishimaru]

I can go for a no lynch though if anyone thinks I shouldn't lynch anyone.

 

[Kiyotaka Ishimaru]

Ok, should we try and work out who Lycan should kill, considering he's the likely lynch.

I don't get this post. Based from the role, hunter can only kill the next night after anyone survives, so that should be invalid. Well, probably was a mistake of sorts, so I don't find this suspicious.

Anyway, I don't think I want to change my lynch target today. Also, feel free to have priest check me tonight; I assure you I'm innocent.

 

[Abby]

Huh... I'll go check the op


Welp, apparently so, the Hunter I'm used to gets to kill someone after being lynched. Sorry.

 

[gimmepie]

Went through the OP again, think I have the gist of the game.
I haven't read through the thread yet though, what do I need to know?

 

[mew_nani]

Three role reveals and it's just Day 2. I'm not so sure if that bodes well for us. ~_~

Really I don't know who to go after any more than I did at the beginning of the phase, so for now I'll just [Vote] No One. I don't really like what's going on here much at all; we got three separate role claims and very limited resources to try and verify all of them and equally limited resources to try and protect them from the mafia. It's a huge mess.

 

[Sparkin]

Bandwagon vote on no one
[Vote] No One

 

[alisaie]

At this point we don't have time for a majority lynch. If Ichi really is the Judge he will go through with his word and kill lycan. Otherwise the actual judge can counterclaim and kill someone else.

Doubt its going to happen since I believe his claim. Not 100% on his alignment until we get better proof of that somehow.

[vote] no one

I dont know lycan should kill if they're lynched. I'm not getting any big scummy reads from anyone as of yet.

 

[Abby]

If Ishi was lying then it's not someone else being killed, it's him.

I'm believing in his innocence for now though, so [VOTE]No-one