Alright, totes going to retroactively reply to your fourth most recent comment. So this reply happened directly after you posted and before all this business. You remember. I remember.
I like her design a lot more now. Her current design gives a more headstrong look to her, and the eyes getting darker rather than going to white adds more depth. There's just more going on in terms of colors and shades and it makes her more visually appealing, though...
...I mean, I really like the hair on the new design, but I have to wonder what you're going for. Post Gen-3 they really started moving away from the more standard hair designs for the female protags and going for designs that would grab the viewers attention and really make them stand out. All things considered, I think the previous design you showed had a more exotic design of the two if you're going for a game protagonist-esque look. It's more audacious and one of the first things that'll catch your eye from her. The newer design has more apparent character and fits well with the more subdued color, though, and I'd say if from the new design I get a feel for what she might be like from her face and clothing, from the older design it's more from her posture and form.